- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Environmental movements: one or many?
Describe the diversity of environmental movements, including forest movements in the South and wilderness campaigns in the North, movements against mining and against mega-dams, and the role of non-violence in India.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why environmental movements are diverse and why they matter.
- Contrast the Southern view of peopled forests with the Northern idea of wilderness.
- Describe movements against mining and mega-dams, with the textbook's examples.
Some of the most significant responses to environmental damage have come not from governments but from groups of environmentally conscious volunteers, mostly working locally. The textbook calls these movements among the most vibrant, diverse and powerful social movements today. Within them new forms of political action are born or reinvented, and new ideas and long-term visions emerge about how we should live. Diversity is their key trait, as these examples show.
Forest movements of the South
Forest movements in Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Malaysia, Indonesia, continental Africa and India face enormous pressure. Despite three decades of activism, forest clearing in the Third World continues at an alarming rate, and the textbook says destruction of the world's last remaining grand forests actually increased in the last decade.
Are forests 'wilderness'?
-
View common in the North
- Forests seen as more or less empty of people
- Wilderness as a 'wild place' where people do not live
- Humans not seen as part of nature
- Protect nature from people through parks and reserves
- Strong in Australia, Scandinavia, North America, New Zealand
-
View common in the South
- Forests are still peopled
- Environmental issues assume people live in forests
- Protection must include the people who live there
Wilderness campaigns are not absent in the South: the textbook mentions efforts to protect eagles and other birds of prey in the Philippines, the struggle to protect the low numbers of Bengal tigers in India, campaigns against the ivory trade and the slaughter of elephants in Africa, and famous struggles in the forests of Brazil and Indonesia. Many wilderness issues have been renamed biodiversity issues, since 'wilderness' proved hard to sell in the South; many campaigns were started and funded by NGOs such as the Worldwide Wildlife Fund (WWF) together with local people.
Movements against mining
The minerals industry is one of the most powerful on the planet, and many Southern economies are being reopened to multinational companies through liberalisation. Its extraction of earth, use of chemicals, pollution of water and land, clearing of vegetation and displacement of communities invite resistance worldwide. The textbook's example: in the Philippines, a vast network of groups campaigned against the Western Mining Corporation (WMC), an Australia-based multinational; in Australia itself, opposition to the company drew on anti-nuclear sentiment and support for the rights of Australian indigenous peoples. The book also shows a 2006 protest in Phulbari, Bangladesh, against a proposed open-cast coal mine.
Movements against mega-dams
- Wherever a mega-dam is built, an environmental movement is likely to oppose it; increasingly, anti-dam movements are pro-river movements seeking sustainable and equitable management of rivers and valleys.
- The first anti-dam movement in the North, in the early 1980s, was the campaign to save the Franklin River and its forests in Australia, at once a wilderness, forest and anti-dam campaign.
- Mega-dam building has spread in the South, from Turkey to Thailand to South Africa, and from Indonesia to China.
- India has had leading anti-dam, pro-river movements; the Narmada Bachao Andolan is one of the best known.
- In Indian environmental movements, the most important shared idea is non-violence.
Types of environmental movement in the chapter
-
Forest movements
- Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Malaysia, Indonesia, Africa, India
- Against rapid forest clearing
-
Wilderness and biodiversity campaigns
- Bengal tigers, birds of prey, elephants
- Often with NGOs such as WWF
-
Anti-mining movements
- Philippines network against WMC
- Phulbari, Bangladesh, 2006
-
Anti-dam, pro-river movements
- Franklin River, Australia
- Narmada Bachao Andolan, India
Environmental movements are diverse: they differ on whether forests are wild places to be kept free of people or homes whose inhabitants are part of nature, and on what should be protected and how.
Worked example 1: applying the wilderness debate
Question: A made-up government plans to turn a forest where several villages live into a reserve, moving the villagers out. Which view of forests does this reflect, and how would a Southern forest movement respond? Reasoning: removing people to protect nature reflects the wilderness view common in the North, which treats environment as 'somewhere out there' to be protected from humans. A Southern movement, assuming forests are peopled, would argue that the villagers are part of the forest's ecology and that protection should include their rights and livelihoods.
Worked example 2: classifying movements
Question: Classify: (i) a campaign against a planned large dam that would flood a valley; (ii) protests against an open-cast coal mine; (iii) a drive to protect a declining tiger population. Answer: (i) anti-dam, pro-river movement; (ii) anti-mining movement; (iii) wilderness or biodiversity campaign.
Key takeaways: environmental movements, mostly local and volunteer-led, are diverse and powerful. Southern forest movements see forests as peopled, unlike the Northern wilderness view; wilderness issues are increasingly framed as biodiversity. Movements resist mining (the Philippines campaign against WMC) and mega-dams (Franklin River in Australia, Narmada Bachao Andolan in India), and Indian movements share a commitment to non-violence.
Check your understanding
-
1. What distinguishes the forest movements of the South from those of the North, according to the textbook?
- The North has no forests
- Forests of the South have no trees
- Forests of the South are still peopled
- Southern movements reject all conservation
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says the forests of the South are still peopled, while those of the North are more or less devoid of human habitat or perceived as such.
-
2. The first anti-dam movement in the North, in the early 1980s, was the campaign to save the:
- Franklin River in Australia
- Narmada river
- Aral Sea
- Euphrates River
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says the campaign to save the Franklin River and its forests in Australia was the first anti-dam movement launched in the North.
-
3. The most important shared idea in anti-dam and other environmental movements in India, according to the chapter, is:
- armed struggle
- wilderness without people
- privatisation
- non-violence
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter notes that in anti-dam and other environmental movements in India, the most important shared idea is non-violence.
-
4. The network of groups in the Philippines campaigned against:
- the Worldwide Wildlife Fund
- the Western Mining Corporation, an Australia-based multinational
- the UNEP
- the Narmada Bachao Andolan
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook gives the example of a vast network in the Philippines campaigning against the Western Mining Corporation, an Australia-based multinational.
-
5. Assertion (A): Many wilderness issues have been renamed biodiversity issues in recent times. Reason (R): The concept of wilderness has proved difficult to sell in the South.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because 'wilderness' did not appeal in the South, where forests are peopled, such campaigns came to be framed as biodiversity issues.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.