Revision notes

Chapter 6 Environment and Natural Resources: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Why the environment became an issue of world politics

From awareness to the Earth Summit

  1. 1960s onwards Awareness of the environmental costs of growth becomes increasingly political
  2. 1972: Limits to Growth Book by the Club of Rome, a global think tank, on resource depletion and population growth
  3. UNEP and international studies The UN Environment Programme holds conferences and promotes studies
  4. 1987: Brundtland Report Our Common Future warns that traditional growth patterns are not sustainable
  5. June 1992: Earth Summit, Rio de Janeiro UN Conference on Environment and Development; 170 states, thousands of NGOs, many MNCs

Two environmental agendas at Rio

  • Global North (rich, developed countries)
    • Concerned with ozone depletion
    • Concerned with global warming
  • Global South (poor, developing countries)
    • Anxious to address the link between economic development and environmental management

Sustainable development: development that combines economic growth with ecological responsibility, so that meeting today's needs does not ruin the environment for the future.

— Definition in our words

Key takeaways: environmental issues are political because governments' responses have political consequences, because no single state can solve them, and because they raise questions of who causes damage, who pays and who uses resources. Awareness grew from the 1960s through the Club of Rome's Limits to Growth (1972), UNEP and the Brundtland Report (1987) to the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, which produced conventions, Agenda 21 and the goal of sustainable development but exposed the North-South divide.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Global commons and common property resources

Global commons

  • Earth's atmosphere
    • Affected by greenhouse gases and ozone depletion
  • Antarctica
    • Coldest, farthest, windiest continent
    • Disputed: some states claim sovereignty, most treat it as commons
  • Ocean floor
    • Beyond national jurisdiction
  • Outer space
    • Use shaped by technology and industrial capacity

Who owns the Antarctic? Two claims

  • Claims of sovereignty
    • Made by the UK, Argentina, Chile, Norway, France, Australia and New Zealand
  • Global commons view
    • Held by most other states
    • Not subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of any state

Global commons are areas outside any state's jurisdiction needing international governance; common property resources belong to a defined group whose members share rights and duties over them.

— Key distinction in our words

Key takeaways: global commons (the atmosphere, Antarctica, the ocean floor and outer space) lie outside any state's jurisdiction. Agreements such as the 1959 Antarctic Treaty, the 1987 Montreal Protocol and the 1991 Antarctic Environmental Protocol show cooperation is possible, but consensus is hard and North-South inequalities shape who benefits. Common property resources belong to a group with rights and duties; India's sacred groves are a traditional example now under pressure.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Common but differentiated responsibilities and India's stand

Who should bear responsibility?

  • Developed North
    • Discuss the environment as it stands now
    • Everyone equally responsible for conservation
  • Developing South
    • Most degradation came from the North's industrial development
    • Those who caused more damage should do more to undo it
    • Industrialising countries should not face the same restrictions
    • Special needs of developing countries must count in environmental law

Common but differentiated responsibilities: all states share the duty to protect the environment, but those that caused more damage and have more resources (the developed countries) must bear a larger share of the burden.

— Principle in our words
India's steps
MeasurePurpose
National Auto-fuel PolicyMandates cleaner fuels for vehicles
Energy Conservation Act, 2001Initiatives to improve energy efficiency
Electricity Act, 2003Encourages renewable energy
Natural gas imports and clean coal technologiesSigns of real effort to cut pollution
Paris Climate AgreementRatified by India on 2 October 2016
Renewable energyThe textbook says India has one of the largest renewable energy programmes in the world

Key takeaways: the North wants equal responsibility now; the South says those who caused most damage should do most to repair it. The Rio Declaration accepted 'common but differentiated responsibilities', reflected in the 1992 UNFCCC and the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, which set targets for industrialised countries and exempted India and China. India ratified Kyoto in August 2002, stresses per capita emissions and historical responsibility, resists binding commitments on developing countries, seeks finance and technology from the North, and has its own clean energy laws and policies; it ratified the Paris Agreement on 2 October 2016.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Environmental movements: one or many?

Are forests 'wilderness'?

  • View common in the North
    • Forests seen as more or less empty of people
    • Wilderness as a 'wild place' where people do not live
    • Humans not seen as part of nature
    • Protect nature from people through parks and reserves
    • Strong in Australia, Scandinavia, North America, New Zealand
  • View common in the South
    • Forests are still peopled
    • Environmental issues assume people live in forests
    • Protection must include the people who live there

Types of environmental movement in the chapter

  • Forest movements
    • Mexico, Chile, Brazil, Malaysia, Indonesia, Africa, India
    • Against rapid forest clearing
  • Wilderness and biodiversity campaigns
    • Bengal tigers, birds of prey, elephants
    • Often with NGOs such as WWF
  • Anti-mining movements
    • Philippines network against WMC
    • Phulbari, Bangladesh, 2006
  • Anti-dam, pro-river movements
    • Franklin River, Australia
    • Narmada Bachao Andolan, India

Environmental movements are diverse: they differ on whether forests are wild places to be kept free of people or homes whose inhabitants are part of nature, and on what should be protected and how.

— Key idea in our words

Key takeaways: environmental movements, mostly local and volunteer-led, are diverse and powerful. Southern forest movements see forests as peopled, unlike the Northern wilderness view; wilderness issues are increasingly framed as biodiversity. Movements resist mining (the Philippines campaign against WMC) and mega-dams (Franklin River in Australia, Narmada Bachao Andolan in India), and Indian movements share a commitment to non-violence.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Resource geopolitics and the rights of indigenous peoples

How the industrialised North secured resources during the Cold War

  • Military means
    • Forces deployed near exploitation sites
    • Forces along sea-lanes of communication
  • Economic means
    • Stockpiling strategic resources
    • Support to multinational companies
    • Favourable international agreements
  • Political means
    • Propping up friendly governments in producing countries

How a river dispute arises

  1. Upstream state acts Builds a dam, irrigates heavily, or pollutes
  2. Less or poorer water flows down Quantity or quality falls
  3. Downstream state objects Sees a threat to its people and farms
  4. Tension or conflict Negotiation, or in some cases threats and force

Resource geopolitics: the struggle among states and other actors over who gets which resources, when, where and how.

— Definition in our words

Key takeaways: resource geopolitics asks who gets what, when, where and how. From naval timber to oil, resources have driven rivalry; during the Cold War the North secured supplies through military deployments, stockpiles, friendly governments, support to MNCs and agreements. Oil remains central, especially in West Asia, and shared rivers can cause 'water wars' (Jordan and Yarmuk, Euphrates). Indigenous peoples, defined by the UN as descendants of original inhabitants who were overcome by newcomers, seek recognition as equals and protection of their lands; in India, Scheduled Tribes have borne a heavy cost of displacement. The World Council of Indigenous Peoples was formed in 1975.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery