- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
From field to kitchen: threshing, winnowing and sieving
Describe how grain is separated from stalks by threshing and from husk by winnowing, and how sieving separates particles of different sizes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain threshing and winnowing and the property each uses.
- Explain sieving and when it works.
- Choose between winnowing and sieving for a given mixture.
Wheat in a field grows as grains on stalks, wrapped in husk. Before it becomes atta for rotis, several separation steps take place, many of them on the farm itself.
Threshing
After harvesting, the stalks are dried in the sun. Threshing is the process of separating grains from the stalks. Traditionally, farmers beat bundles of stalks against a hard surface such as a wooden log, or let cattle walk over them. The grains fall off, but they are now mixed with light, papery husk.
Winnowing
Rub some roasted peanuts between your palms: the thin red skins come loose. Blow gently over them and the light skins fly off, leaving the heavier peanuts. This is the idea behind winnowing. A farmer stands on a raised platform and slowly lets threshed grain fall from a bamboo tray called a soop, with the wind blowing across it. The heavy grains fall straight down in a heap; the light husk is carried further away and forms a separate heap.
Winnowing separates the heavier and lighter components of a mixture using wind or blowing air.
From stalk to clean grain
- Harvest and dry Cut stalks are dried in the sun.
- Threshing Beat stalks so grains fall off.
- Winnowing Wind blows away light husk; heavy grain falls close.
- Clean grain Ready to be stored or ground.
Today many farmers use machines called threshers, which do threshing and winnowing together. Winnowing needs moving air, so it works poorly in a closed room with still air; outdoors on a breezy day, or with a fan, it works well.
Sieving
A sieve is a mesh with holes. Small particles pass through the holes; bigger ones stay on top. Sieving is used when the solid components of a mixture have different sizes. At home, flour is sieved to remove bran and any small stones. At a building site, sand is thrown against a large slanted wire mesh so that fine sand passes through and pebbles are left behind.
Worked example 1: choosing the hole size
Meera wants to separate fine flour from bran flakes. She has two sieves: one with holes bigger than the bran flakes and one with holes smaller than the bran but bigger than flour grains. Step 1: in the first sieve, both flour and bran would pass through, so nothing is separated. Step 2: in the second, flour passes through and bran stays on top. Answer: use the second sieve. Sieving works only if the holes are bigger than one component and smaller than the other.
Worked example 2: winnowing or sieving?
| Mixture | Method | Property used |
|---|---|---|
| Husk with rice grains | Winnowing | Husk is much lighter |
| Pebbles with sand | Sieving | Pebbles are much bigger |
| Peanut skins with peanuts | Winnowing (blowing) | Skins are lighter |
| Bran with flour | Sieving | Bran flakes are bigger |
Working: if the components differ mainly in weight, use moving air (winnowing). If they differ mainly in size, use a sieve.
Key takeaways: threshing separates grain from stalks; winnowing uses wind to separate heavy grain from light husk; sieving separates solid particles of different sizes, and the holes must be between the two sizes. Threshers do threshing and winnowing together. Choose winnowing for differences in weight and sieving for differences in size.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is threshing?
- Separating grains from stalks
- Separating husk from grain using wind
- Separating flour from bran
- Separating butter from curd
Show answer
Answer: A. Threshing is the process of separating grains from the stalks, for example by beating them.
-
2. In winnowing, why does husk land further away than grain?
- Husk is magnetic
- Husk is heavier
- Husk is lighter, so the wind carries it further
- Husk dissolves in air
Show answer
Answer: C. The wind pushes the light husk further, while the heavy grains fall almost straight down.
-
3. Which mixture is best separated by sieving?
- Salt and water
- Oil and water
- Husk and grain
- Pebbles and sand
Show answer
Answer: D. Pebbles and sand differ in size; sand passes through the sieve and pebbles stay on top.
-
4. Why does winnowing not work well in a closed room with no fan?
- Grain is too heavy
- There is no moving air to carry the husk away
- The soop breaks indoors
- Husk sticks to walls
Show answer
Answer: B. Winnowing needs wind or blowing air; still air cannot carry the husk away from the grain.
-
5. For sieving flour from bran, the holes of the sieve must be:
- Bigger than flour grains but smaller than bran flakes
- Bigger than both
- Smaller than both
- Any size at all
Show answer
Answer: A. Flour must pass through and bran must stay behind, so the hole size must lie between the two.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.