• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mixtures, why we separate them, and handpicking

Explain what a mixture is, give the two reasons we separate its components, and use handpicking when the unwanted part differs in size, colour or shape and is small in amount.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what a mixture and its components are.
  • Give the two main reasons for separating substances.
  • Decide when handpicking is a sensible method.

Before dal is cooked, someone in many Indian homes spreads it on a plate and picks out tiny stones. Before tea is served, the leaves are strained out. Separating things is part of everyday life. A famous couplet by the poet Kabir compares a wise person to a winnowing tray: keep what is good, let the useless blow away.

What is a mixture?

A mixture is formed when two or more substances are mixed together. Each substance in it is a component, and components can be separated using differences in their properties.

Rice with small stones, sand with pebbles, tea with tea leaves, seawater (water with salts dissolved in it) and curd (which contains butter fat) are all mixtures. Methods of separation work because the components differ in some property: size, colour, shape, weight, whether they dissolve, whether they are magnetic, and so on.

Why separate?

Two reasons for separating

  • Remove an unwanted or harmful part
    • Stones from rice or dal
    • Husk from grain
    • Mud from water
  • Obtain a useful part (or keep both)
    • Butter from curd
    • Salt from seawater
    • Grain from stalks

Handpicking

Handpicking means picking out components of a mixture by hand. It works using differences in size, colour and shape that we can see. It is convenient only when the part to be removed is present in small quantities and is easy to pick. Picking stones from a plate of rice, removing whole spices from a pulao before eating, and picking out rotten tomatoes from a basket are all handpicking.

Worked example 1: is handpicking sensible?

Deciding whether to handpick
MixtureHandpick?Reason
A few stones in a kilogram of riceYesStones are few and look different
A cup of green chillies mixed in a cup of beansYesBig pieces, easy to see
Fine sand mixed with saltNoParticles are tiny and too many
Husk mixed in a heap of threshed wheatNoFar too much husk to pick by hand

Working: ask two questions. Can I see and grasp the pieces? Is there only a small amount to remove? If both answers are yes, handpicking works. If not, another method is needed.

Worked example 2: a mixture of puffed rice and chana dal

A bowl contains mostly puffed rice with a small amount of chana dal. Step 1, compare properties: chana dal is small, hard and yellow; puffed rice is bigger, white and very light. Step 2, choose: the dal is in small amount and looks different, so it can be handpicked. Step 3, alternative: because puffed rice is very light, gently blowing across the bowl would also move it away from the heavier dal, an idea we will meet next lesson as winnowing. Often more than one method can work; pick the one that is quickest and wastes least.

Key takeaways: a mixture contains two or more components that can be separated by using differences in their properties. We separate to remove unwanted parts or to obtain useful ones. Handpicking uses differences in size, colour and shape and is suitable when the part to remove is small in amount and easy to pick.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is a mixture?

    1. A single pure substance
    2. Two or more substances mixed together
    3. Only a liquid
    4. Only a solid
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A mixture is formed when two or more substances are mixed. Its components can be separated.

  2. 2. Picking out stones from rice is done mainly to:

    1. Obtain a useful component
    2. Make the rice heavier
    3. Change the colour of the rice
    4. Remove an unwanted component
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Stones are unwanted and harmful to eat, so they are removed to make the rice fit for cooking.

  3. 3. On which differences does handpicking depend?

    1. Size, colour and shape
    2. Magnetism only
    3. Whether the substance dissolves
    4. Temperature
    Show answer

    Answer: A. We pick out pieces we can see and grasp, so handpicking depends on differences in size, colour and shape.

  4. 4. Which mixture is best separated by handpicking?

    1. Salt dissolved in water
    2. Fine flour mixed with fine sugar
    3. A few stones in a bag of dal
    4. Mud in water
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A few stones are easy to see and pick, and only a small amount needs removing. The other mixtures have tiny or dissolved parts.

  5. 5. Churning curd to get butter is an example of separating to:

    1. Remove a harmful part
    2. Obtain a useful component
    3. Make curd sour
    4. Remove stones
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Butter is a useful component taken out of curd; the buttermilk left is useful too.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery