- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Applying Kidder's three resolution principles
Resolve dilemmas using Kidder's ends-based, rule-based and care-based principles, compare where they agree and differ, and justify a final choice clearly in an answer.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Once you have mapped a dilemma, you need principles to choose between options. Rushworth Kidder suggested three, each drawn from a major tradition. Applying all three and comparing the results is a quick, examiner-friendly way to reason.
The three principles
| Principle | Tradition | Question | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ends-based | Utilitarianism (Bentham, Mill) | Which option does the greatest good for the greatest number? | Predictions may be wrong; minorities may be sacrificed |
| Rule-based | Kant's categorical imperative | Which rule would I want everyone in my position to follow? | Rigidity when two rules conflict |
| Care-based | The golden rule, found in many traditions | What would I want done if I were the person affected? | Bias towards the person in front of you |
Worked example 1: the flood relief list
Case: After a flood, relief is to be given only to families on the official damage survey list. A widow whose hut was destroyed was missed by the survey; her name is not on the list. A village leader asks you, the relief officer, to give her relief anyway. Ends-based: giving relief to a clearly affected family increases welfare at small cost; but making unlisted payments routinely could lead to misuse. Rule-based: what rule would you want every relief officer to follow? Not 'pay anyone a leader recommends', but 'ensure every genuinely affected family is listed through a proper, quick verification'. Care-based: in her place, you would want to be included without delay. Resolution: all three point to the same action, done properly: verify her loss on the spot, add her to the list through a supplementary survey, and pay her relief. Do not pay outside the list on a recommendation.
Worked example 2: the friend's appointment letter
Case: You are on an interview panel. A close friend's son is a candidate; you were told only on the morning of the interview. Ends-based: recusal costs little; staying risks bias and loss of public trust. Rule-based: the rule you would want for every panel member is to declare and step aside. Care-based: if you were another candidate, you would want a panel without conflicts. Resolution: declare the relationship and recuse yourself from that interview. Here the principles agree strongly.
When the principles disagree
Case: A child labourer is found working in a roadside eatery. Removing him at once follows the law (rule-based) and protects his long-term welfare; but his family depends on his income, and he may end up in worse work (ends-based concern). Care-based: if you were the child, you would want both rescue and a future. Resolution: rescue the child as the law requires, and at the same time link the family to schemes for income support and the child to school and rehabilitation. When principles disagree, the answer is often to honour the rule while using the other principles to shape how it is carried out.
Ends, rules, care: apply all three. Where they agree, act firmly; where they differ, keep the rule and let consequences and care shape how you carry it out.
Key takeaways
- Kidder's principles: ends-based (utilitarian), rule-based (Kantian), care-based (golden rule).
- Applying all three exposes hidden costs and builds a stronger justification.
- Disagreement between principles often points to how, not whether, to act.
Check your understanding
-
1. Kidder's rule-based principle draws mainly on:
- Kant's categorical imperative
- Bentham's utilitarianism
- Aristotle's golden mean
- Hobbes's social contract
Show answer
Answer: A. The rule-based principle asks which rule you would want everyone in your position to follow, echoing Kant.
-
2. In the flood relief case, why is paying the widow outside the list on the leader's recommendation rejected?
- Because she is not genuinely affected by the flood, as the leader himself has stated clearly
- Because relief should never be given to anyone who is outside the original survey list
- Because the rule we would want all officers to follow is proper verification, not payment on recommendation
- Because the leader recommending her is from another party and has no standing in the district
Show answer
Answer: C. Verifying and adding her to the list helps her quickly while keeping the system fair and resistant to misuse.
-
3. Which principle asks 'What would I want done if I were the person affected?'
- Ends-based
- Rule-based
- Universality
- Care-based
Show answer
Answer: D. The care-based principle is a form of the golden rule.
-
4. In the child labour case, the principles partly disagree. What is the recommended resolution?
- Leave the child working in the eatery to protect the income of his poor family for now
- Rescue the child as the law requires and link the family to income support and the child to school
- Fine the eatery owner under the law and do nothing else for the child or the family
- Ask the child what he prefers and follow his wish, because he is the one affected
Show answer
Answer: B. The rule is followed, while consequences and care shape the follow-up so the child and family are protected.
-
5. Which weakness is associated with the ends-based principle?
- It ignores outcomes and looks only at the rules, which is why it is criticised
- It cannot be applied to public policy, because policy has no effect on groups
- Predictions may be wrong and minorities may be sacrificed for the majority
- It forbids helping others, because the outcome of helping is uncertain in advance
Show answer
Answer: C. Utilitarian reasoning depends on predicting outcomes and can override individual rights.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.