- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Public-service dilemmas: law, loyalty and compassion
Resolve typical public-service dilemmas, including an improper oral order, a poor encroacher, and a colleague's misconduct, choosing actions that are lawful, fair and humane.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Public servants face dilemmas shaped by hierarchy, law and the needs of vulnerable citizens. This lesson works through four typical cases, using the map and the three principles, and shows how to reach a course of action an examiner will accept.
Case 1: the oral order
Your superior tells you by phone to issue a contract to a particular firm without inviting bids, citing urgency. The rules allow single-source purchase only in defined emergencies, and you see none. Values: obedience and loyalty versus rule of law and fairness. Course: politely ask for the order in writing with the reasons for urgency; point out the relevant rule; if a genuine emergency exists, follow the emergency procedure with records; if not, proceed with the normal tender. Do not refuse rudely, and do not comply silently. A written order with reasons protects both the public and you.
Case 2: the poor encroacher
A court has directed removal of encroachments from a footpath. Among the encroachers is an elderly widow selling vegetables, whose only income is this stall. Values: rule of law versus compassion. Course: carry out the court's direction, which is binding; but use lawful means to soften the impact: give notice and time, inform her of vending zones under the street vendors' scheme, help her register, and coordinate with welfare departments for pension or support. Justice and mercy are combined: the law is applied, and the person is not abandoned.
Case 3: the colleague's misconduct
A colleague and friend, under financial stress, has been inflating travel claims. Values: truth versus loyalty. Course: speak to him first, advise him to correct the claims and repay; if he refuses or the practice continues, report through proper channels. Covering up would make you complicit; reporting without first giving him a chance to correct may be needlessly harsh when the amounts are small and the conduct is fresh. The order of steps matters, but the duty to the public remains.
Case 4: the medical college seat
A minister's office calls asking you, an admissions officer, to 'look into' a candidate whose rank is below the cut-off. Values: loyalty to political executive versus fairness to all candidates. Course: respond courteously that admissions follow the published merit list and offer to explain the process; record the call; inform your superior. There is no genuine dilemma here about the outcome; the challenge is handling pressure respectfully and safely.
| Case | Core conflict | Key action |
|---|---|---|
| Oral order | Obedience versus rule of law | Ask for a written order with reasons; follow the rule |
| Poor encroacher | Rule of law versus compassion | Comply with the court; offer lawful support and alternatives |
| Colleague's claims | Truth versus loyalty | Advise correction first; report if it continues |
| Admission pressure | Political pressure versus fairness | Courteous refusal; record and inform superior |
Obey lawfully, refuse respectfully, record everything, and wherever the law must bite, use your discretion to soften the blow for the vulnerable.
Key takeaways
- Ask for written orders when an instruction seems irregular.
- Combine justice and mercy: follow the law and use lawful means to support the vulnerable.
- Give a colleague a chance to correct a fresh, small lapse, but do not cover up.
- Some 'dilemmas' are really pressure; respond courteously, firmly and on record.
Check your understanding
-
1. Your superior orders by phone that a contract be given without bids, and you see no emergency. What is the best first step?
- Comply at once without asking any question, since the order is from a superior
- Refuse rudely, hang up the phone and report the superior to his own colleagues
- Ask for the order in writing with reasons, pointing to the relevant rule
- Complain to the media at once about the order given by the superior officer
Show answer
Answer: C. A written order with reasons creates accountability and lets you follow the correct procedure.
-
2. In the encroachment case, how are justice and mercy combined?
- Ignore the court order because of the widow's poverty and her age
- Comply with the court and help her with notice, vending zones and welfare support
- Remove her stall without notice and without any help for her livelihood
- Fine her heavily and let the court see that the order was carried out
Show answer
Answer: B. The binding order is carried out, while lawful steps reduce harm to a vulnerable person.
-
3. A friend has inflated travel claims for the first time, by small amounts. What is the most appropriate first step?
- Advise him to correct the claims and repay, and report if he refuses or continues
- Report him immediately to the media and to his friends, without speaking to him
- Ignore it out of friendship, because the amounts are small and it was the first time
- Inflate your own claims as well, since everybody in the office does so
Show answer
Answer: A. Giving a chance to correct a fresh lapse is fair, but the duty to report remains if it is not corrected.
-
4. A minister's office asks an admissions officer to 'look into' a below-cut-off candidate. How is this best described?
- A genuine dilemma in which two equally right answers conflict with each other
- A matter of justice versus mercy, in which the candidate's hardship decides the case
- A short-term versus long-term conflict between the minister's wishes and the college's name
- Pressure, not a genuine dilemma; respond courteously, follow the merit list and record the call
Show answer
Answer: D. Admitting the candidate would be unfair. The challenge is managing pressure, not choosing between two rights.
-
5. Why is recording calls and informing superiors useful in pressure situations?
- It creates a record that protects fairness and the officer
- It is a way to threaten politicians and officers who may press the officer
- It replaces the need to follow rules, since the record itself protects the decision
- It guarantees promotion for the officer who keeps the records of the calls
Show answer
Answer: A. Records protect both the integrity of the decision and the officer who resists pressure.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.