- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Dilemmas of truth, confidentiality and the duty to warn
Resolve dilemmas where honesty, privacy and the prevention of harm conflict, including medical confidentiality, the duty to warn third parties and sensitive official information.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Few values are as basic as honesty and privacy, and few dilemmas are as common as those in which they collide with the need to prevent harm. This lesson works through typical cases from medicine, administration and everyday life.
Three principles to balance
- Confidentiality: information given in trust should not be disclosed without consent.
- Honesty: we should not deceive people, especially those who rely on us.
- Harm prevention: where serious, foreseeable harm to others can be prevented, there may be a duty to act, including disclosure.
Most professional codes treat confidentiality as strong but not absolute. A widely discussed example is the Tarasoff case decided by the Supreme Court of California in 1976, which held that a therapist whose patient poses a serious danger of violence to an identifiable person has a duty to take reasonable steps to protect that person. The idea, often called the duty to warn or protect, appears in many professional codes in some form.
Case 1: the counsellor's knowledge
A school counsellor learns from a student that he plans to harm a classmate who bullied him, and he names a day. Values: confidentiality and trust versus preventing serious harm. Course: the threat is specific and serious, so the duty to protect outweighs confidentiality. Inform the head of the school and the parents as policy requires, ensure the classmate's safety, and continue to support the student who made the threat. Tell the student honestly why the information must be shared; do not promise secrecy that cannot be kept.
Case 2: the doctor and the family
A patient tests positive for a serious infectious disease and refuses to inform his spouse, who is at risk. Course: counsel the patient strongly to disclose and offer to help; if he still refuses, follow the professional and legal guidance that permits disclosure to protect an identifiable person at serious risk, informing the patient of the step. The principle is the same as in Tarasoff: serious, identifiable risk can override confidentiality, but only after attempts to obtain consent and only to the extent necessary.
Case 3: the official information
A district officer knows that a list of slum households to be relocated has been finalised but not yet announced. A journalist friend asks for it. The list contains personal details. Values: transparency versus confidentiality and privacy. Course: decline to leak it; personal information must be protected, and premature disclosure could cause panic or exploitation by middlemen. Instead, press for a timely official announcement with an explanation of rights and rehabilitation. Transparency is served through proper channels.
Case 4: the white lie
A dying patient asks whether her son, who has been in an accident, is safe. He has died. The family asks the doctor to say he is recovering. Honesty and compassion conflict sharply. Options: tell the full truth bluntly; lie; or respond honestly but gently, for example by saying that the family will come to talk to her, while ensuring she is not left with a deliberate falsehood if she asks directly. Kant would forbid the lie; a utilitarian might permit it to spare suffering; a care perspective focuses on how and by whom the truth is shared. Many ethicists favour truthful but compassionate communication, with timing and manner chosen carefully.
Keep confidences, but not at the price of serious harm to an identifiable person; seek consent first, disclose only what is necessary, and tell the truth with compassion.
Key takeaways
- Confidentiality is strong but not absolute.
- The Tarasoff principle: serious danger to an identifiable person can create a duty to protect.
- Seek consent first, then disclose only as much as needed, and tell the person why.
- Honesty and compassion can often be combined through manner and timing.
Check your understanding
-
1. What did the Tarasoff decision of 1976 establish?
- Therapists may never break confidentiality under any circumstances, even if the life of an identifiable person is directly threatened
- A therapist whose patient poses serious danger to an identifiable person has a duty to take reasonable steps to protect that person
- Doctors must report every diagnosis that they make to the police, so that the public can be protected from every kind of danger
- Patients have no right to privacy once they begin treatment with a licensed therapist, who may then tell anyone he chooses
Show answer
Answer: B. The California Supreme Court recognised a duty to protect identifiable third parties from serious danger.
-
2. A student tells a counsellor he plans to harm a named classmate on a stated day. What should the counsellor do?
- Keep it secret from everyone, to maintain the trust of the student, and offer him counselling in the school
- Share it with the other students in the class, so that they can protect themselves and warn their friend
- Wait to see whether it happens, and act only if the classmate is actually harmed on the day that was stated
- Inform the school head and parents as policy requires, protect the classmate, and keep supporting the student
Show answer
Answer: D. A specific, serious threat to an identifiable person overrides confidentiality; support for the student continues.
-
3. Before disclosing a patient's infection to an at-risk spouse, what should the doctor first do?
- Counsel the patient to disclose and offer help
- Post the news on the hospital notice board, so that the spouse is certain to see it
- Tell the patient's employer, who can then talk to the family of the patient
- Do nothing, because medical secrecy applies in every case without exception
Show answer
Answer: A. Seeking consent and supporting voluntary disclosure comes first; disclosure without consent is a last resort, limited to what is necessary.
-
4. A journalist friend asks an officer for an unannounced list of households to be relocated, with personal details. What is right?
- Share it with the journalist, because transparency is always good in every case
- Share it without the names, but with all the other details about the households
- Decline, and press for a timely official announcement with information on rights and rehabilitation
- Sell it to the highest bidder among the newspapers that are interested in the list
Show answer
Answer: C. Personal data must be protected, and transparency is served properly by official announcement, not by leaks.
-
5. Which approach best combines honesty and compassion when giving very bad news?
- A deliberate lie told with kindness, to spare the feelings of the listener
- Truthful communication with careful choice of timing, manner and messenger
- Blunt disclosure of the facts, without regard for the state of the listener
- Avoiding the person entirely until someone else has given the news to him
Show answer
Answer: B. Many ethicists favour truthful but compassionate communication rather than either deception or bluntness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.