• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Exam-style dilemmas: timed practice with model reasoning

Practise answering dilemma case studies under time pressure using a compact structure, avoid common traps such as extreme options and passing the buck, and compare your reasoning with model answers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

This lesson is practice. Each case below is followed by a model answer in compact form. Read the case, spend three minutes noting your own answer using the structure, then compare.

A compact answer structure

  1. Issue: name the conflict in one line.
  2. Stakeholders: list them, marking the most vulnerable.
  3. Options: two to four, each with one merit and one demerit.
  4. Decision: the chosen course, with steps in order.
  5. Justification: values and law in two or three lines.
  6. Prevention: one systemic change.

Case A: the ambulance

You are a sub-divisional officer. One government ambulance is available. Two calls come together: a road accident with two seriously injured people 20 km away, and a woman in difficult labour 5 km away. Model answer. Issue: allocation of a scarce life-saving resource. Stakeholders: the injured, the woman and her baby, the ambulance crew. Options: send to the nearer case first, then the other; send to the case with more lives at risk; seek other transport for one case at once. Decision: send the ambulance to the nearer labour case, which it can reach and clear fastest, while simultaneously arranging police or private vehicles and alerting the nearest hospital for the accident victims, then redirect the ambulance. Justification: maximise lives saved (utilitarian), treat both cases as equally deserving of urgent effort (fairness), use every legitimate resource. Prevention: a district-level ambulance dispatch plan with backup tie-ups.

Case B: the viral video

A junior officer in your team is seen in a viral video being rude to an elderly applicant. Social media demands his suspension. Model answer. Issue: public accountability versus fairness to the employee. Options: suspend at once to satisfy public anger; ignore; inquire quickly, act on findings. Decision: apologise publicly to the applicant on behalf of the office, resolve the applicant's work the same day, start a quick inquiry with the officer's version heard, and take proportionate action. Justification: due process, accountability, respect for the citizen. Prevention: training in courteous conduct and a visible complaints channel.

Case C: the relief material

During a cyclone, a trader offers to supply tarpaulins at below market price if you buy without tender. Model answer. Issue: speed versus procedural fairness. Decision: use the emergency procurement provisions that rules typically allow in disasters, recording reasons, checking prices against others available, and publishing the purchase afterwards. Justification: lives and shelter come first, but accountability is preserved through records and later disclosure. Prevention: pre-negotiated rate contracts for disaster supplies.

Common traps to avoid

Traps in dilemma answers
TrapWhy it loses marksBetter approach
Resigning as the solutionAbandons responsibility and the people affectedAct within the role; exit only as last resort
Going straight to the mediaBypasses proper channels and due processUse internal and statutory channels first
Passing the buck to a superiorAvoids the decision the case asks you to makeDecide within your authority; inform superiors
Extreme punishment without inquiryViolates due processProportionate action after quick inquiry
Ignoring the vulnerableMisses the most serious valueName and protect the most vulnerable first

Issue, stakeholders, options, decision, justification, prevention: six lines that turn a messy case into a clear answer.

Key takeaways

  • Use a compact six-part structure under time pressure.
  • In emergencies, use legitimate emergency provisions and keep records.
  • Avoid resignation, media leaks, buck-passing and punishment without inquiry as default answers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the ambulance case, why is arranging other vehicles for the accident victims part of the model answer?

    1. To avoid using the ambulance at all for the injured at the scene
    2. Because every legitimate resource should be used to save as many lives as possible
    3. Because accident victims are less important than the original patient waiting
    4. Because the rules forbid the use of ambulances for road accident victims
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Using backup transport while the ambulance clears the nearer case maximises the chance of saving all lives.

  2. 2. A viral video shows a junior being rude to a citizen. Which response best balances accountability and fairness?

    1. Suspend him immediately without giving him a hearing, to show the public quick action
    2. Ignore the video, because a clip on social media is not proof of anything
    3. Apologise to the citizen, resolve her work, and take proportionate action after a quick inquiry
    4. Delete the accounts of the office on social media, so that nobody can see it
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It respects the citizen and due process together.

  3. 3. During a cyclone, which approach to buying tarpaulins without tender is best?

    1. Buy from a trader chosen secretly, without any record of the price paid
    2. Wait for a full tender process, even while the families are exposed to rain
    3. Refuse all purchases until the state government gives written permission in full
    4. Use emergency procurement provisions, record reasons, check prices and disclose afterwards
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Emergency rules allow speed; records and disclosure preserve accountability.

  4. 4. Why is 'resign' usually a weak answer to a dilemma case?

    1. It abandons responsibility and the people the officer could protect
    2. Resignation is illegal for a public servant in a case of this kind
    3. It is always the best option, since it avoids any later blame
    4. Examiners prefer longer answers, and a resignation is a short answer
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Resignation may be a last resort, but it usually leaves the problem and the vulnerable unaddressed.

  5. 5. Which line belongs to the 'prevention' part of the structure?

    1. The injured are the most vulnerable people in this case
    2. A district ambulance dispatch plan with backup tie-ups
    3. The conflict here is really between speed and fairness
    4. Send the ambulance to the nearer of the two cases
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Prevention proposes a systemic change to avoid or ease the same problem in future.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery