Revision notes

Ethical Dilemmas: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Mapping a case: stakeholders, values and constraints

The stakeholder-value map
ColumnWhat to writeCommon mistake
StakeholdersEveryone affected, directly or indirectly, including the absent and futureForgetting the voiceless: children, future residents, the public purse
InterestsWhat each stakeholder wants or needsTreating wants and rights as the same
Values at stakeThe ethical values engaged for each: life, dignity, fairness, honesty, rule of law, loyaltyListing values without linking them to people
ConstraintsLaw, rules, time, budget, authority, informationIgnoring what the decision-maker actually has power to do
Map for the factory case
StakeholderInterestValuesConstraint
Downstream villagersSafe water, healthRight to life and healthHarm is ongoing
WorkersJobs, wagesLivelihood, dignityNo alternative employer nearby
OwnerContinue businessProperty, fair processMust comply with environmental law
Pollution control boardEnforce normsRule of lawHas powers to order closure or conditions
You (DM)Protect public, keep orderDuty, impartialityMust act within law; limited time

Map before you decide: stakeholders, interests, values, constraints. The voiceless and the constraints are where most answers go wrong.

  • Draw a four-column map: stakeholders, interests, values, constraints.
  • Look for voiceless stakeholders and for the most serious value at stake.
  • Constraints define the options that are actually open to you.
  • Compassion can often be expressed within the rules.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Applying Kidder's three resolution principles

Kidder's three resolution principles
PrincipleTraditionQuestionWatch out for
Ends-basedUtilitarianism (Bentham, Mill)Which option does the greatest good for the greatest number?Predictions may be wrong; minorities may be sacrificed
Rule-basedKant's categorical imperativeWhich rule would I want everyone in my position to follow?Rigidity when two rules conflict
Care-basedThe golden rule, found in many traditionsWhat would I want done if I were the person affected?Bias towards the person in front of you

Ends, rules, care: apply all three. Where they agree, act firmly; where they differ, keep the rule and let consequences and care shape how you carry it out.

  • Kidder's principles: ends-based (utilitarian), rule-based (Kantian), care-based (golden rule).
  • Applying all three exposes hidden costs and builds a stronger justification.
  • Disagreement between principles often points to how, not whether, to act.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Public-service dilemmas: law, loyalty and compassion

Four cases, four resolutions
CaseCore conflictKey action
Oral orderObedience versus rule of lawAsk for a written order with reasons; follow the rule
Poor encroacherRule of law versus compassionComply with the court; offer lawful support and alternatives
Colleague's claimsTruth versus loyaltyAdvise correction first; report if it continues
Admission pressurePolitical pressure versus fairnessCourteous refusal; record and inform superior

Obey lawfully, refuse respectfully, record everything, and wherever the law must bite, use your discretion to soften the blow for the vulnerable.

  • Ask for written orders when an instruction seems irregular.
  • Combine justice and mercy: follow the law and use lawful means to support the vulnerable.
  • Give a colleague a chance to correct a fresh, small lapse, but do not cover up.
  • Some 'dilemmas' are really pressure; respond courteously, firmly and on record.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Dilemmas of truth, confidentiality and the duty to warn

Keep confidences, but not at the price of serious harm to an identifiable person; seek consent first, disclose only what is necessary, and tell the truth with compassion.

  • Confidentiality is strong but not absolute.
  • The Tarasoff principle: serious danger to an identifiable person can create a duty to protect.
  • Seek consent first, then disclose only as much as needed, and tell the person why.
  • Honesty and compassion can often be combined through manner and timing.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Exam-style dilemmas: timed practice with model reasoning

Traps in dilemma answers
TrapWhy it loses marksBetter approach
Resigning as the solutionAbandons responsibility and the people affectedAct within the role; exit only as last resort
Going straight to the mediaBypasses proper channels and due processUse internal and statutory channels first
Passing the buck to a superiorAvoids the decision the case asks you to makeDecide within your authority; inform superiors
Extreme punishment without inquiryViolates due processProportionate action after quick inquiry
Ignoring the vulnerableMisses the most serious valueName and protect the most vulnerable first

Issue, stakeholders, options, decision, justification, prevention: six lines that turn a messy case into a clear answer.

  • Use a compact six-part structure under time pressure.
  • In emergencies, use legitimate emergency provisions and keep records.
  • Avoid resignation, media leaks, buck-passing and punishment without inquiry as default answers.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery