- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Hidden doers and objects: commands, short answers and understood words
Find the karta and karm when a word is left out, as in commands, short answers and sentences where the verb ending already shows the doer.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every sentence names its doer. 'दरवाज़ा बंद करो' has no word for the person who must close the door, and 'कल बाज़ार जाऊँगा' has no मैं. The method you have learnt still works, because the doer is understood. This lesson shows how to find it, and how to answer questions that ask for the karak of a word that is not written.
Commands
In a command the doer is the person spoken to, and it is usually left out. The verb ending tells you who it is. Verbs ending in ओ (पढ़ो, करो) are addressed to तुम. Verbs ending in इए (पढ़िए, कीजिए) are addressed to आप. A verb in its root form (पढ़, कर) is addressed to तू. So in 'दरवाज़ा बंद करो', the understood kartri is तुम, and दरवाज़ा is the karm, without a marker.
Sentences without a stated doer
In Hindi the verb often carries the doer. 'जा रहा हूँ' must be 'मैं जा रहा हूँ', because हूँ goes with मैं. 'कल बाज़ार जाऊँगा' can only be said by मैं, because ऊँगा goes with मैं. Likewise 'जाओगे' goes with तुम, and 'जाएँगे' with हम, आप or वे. When a question asks who the kartri is, read it from the helper verb or the ending.
| Sentence | Understood kartri | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| पानी पियो। | तुम | the ending ओ |
| कृपया बैठिए। | आप | the ending इए |
| कल बाज़ार जाऊँगा। | मैं | the ending ऊँगा |
| कहानी सुना रहे हैं। | हम, आप या वे | the helper हैं |
| रोज़ व्यायाम करना चाहिए। | हमें (people in general) | the sense of duty |
Short answers
A question and its short answer share the same karak. 'किसने पत्र लिखा?' asks for the kartri, and the answer 'मोहन ने' gives it. 'किसे बुलाया?' asks for the karm, and the answer 'मीना को' gives it. 'किससे काटा?' asks for the karan, and the answer 'चाकू से' gives it. So the question word tells you the karak of the answer.
जो शब्द लिखा नहीं है, उसका कारक भी क्रिया के रूप से पहचाना जा सकता है।
Worked example 1: a command
Name the karaks in 'पुस्तक पढ़ो।' पढ़ो ends in ओ, so the understood kartri is तुम. पुस्तक answers क्या पढ़ो?, so it is the karm. Neither has a marker: the first is missing, the second is a thing.
Worked example 2: no stated doer
Find the kartri in 'आज रात ट्रेन से जाऊँगा।' The verb जाऊँगा ends in ऊँगा, so the kartri is मैं. ट्रेन से names the means of travel, so it is karan.
Worked example 3: short answers
A question is 'सुनार ने क्या बनाया?' and the answer is 'अँगूठी'. The question word क्या asks for the karm, so अँगूठी is karm. Another question is 'किसके लिए बनाया?' with the answer 'बेटी के लिए'. The question asks for the beneficiary, so बेटी के लिए is sampradan.
Worked example 4: a general statement
In 'सुबह उठना अच्छी आदत है', the infinitive उठना is the subject of the statement, but it names an action in general and no particular person. Such sentences are common in paragraphs. Do not look for a doer with ने in them; the sentence simply states a rule about getting up early.
Key takeaways
Read the doer from the verb ending when it is not written: ओ for तुम, इए for आप, ऊँगा for मैं. In a command the doer is the person addressed. A short answer has the same karak as the question word that asked for it.
Check your understanding
-
1. In 'दरवाज़ा बंद करो।' who is the understood kartri?
- मैं
- वह
- हम
- तुम
Show answer
Answer: D. The ending ओ in करो is used when addressing तुम.
-
2. In 'पानी पियो।' which word is the karm?
- पियो
- पानी
- तुम (understood)
- there is no karm
Show answer
Answer: B. Ask क्या पियो? The answer is पानी, so पानी is the karm, with no marker.
-
3. In 'कल बाज़ार जाऊँगा।' who is the understood kartri?
- तुम
- आप
- मैं
- वे
Show answer
Answer: C. The ending ऊँगा goes only with the subject मैं.
-
4. Question: 'किसने पत्र लिखा?' Answer: 'मोहन ने'. What is the karak of मोहन ने?
- kartri
- karm
- karan
- sampradan
Show answer
Answer: A. The question word किसने asks for the doer, so the answer is the kartri.
-
5. Question: 'किसके लिए बनाया?' Answer: 'बेटी के लिए'. What is the karak of the answer?
- adhikaran
- apadan
- sampradan
- sambodhan
Show answer
Answer: C. के लिए gives the beneficiary, so the phrase is sampradan.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.