- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Changes by ordinary law: when Parliament does not use Article 368
Learn which matters Parliament can change by an ordinary law passed by a simple majority, how to spot them in the text, and why they are not treated as amendments.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every change to the Constitution's contents needs the special procedure of Article 368. The framers left some matters flexible, so that Parliament could settle them by an ordinary law. Knowing these matters helps you answer questions about the procedure and also helps you understand why the Constitution is called partly flexible.
The key phrase
When you read the Constitution, look for the words until Parliament by law provides or until Parliament by law prescribes. They tell you that the present rule was meant to be temporary and that Parliament may replace it by an ordinary Act. For example, Article 124(1) said that the Supreme Court would have a Chief Justice and, until Parliament by law prescribed a larger number, not more than seven other judges. Parliament later raised the number by an ordinary Act, without an amendment under Article 368.
Five families of matters
| Family | Articles or parts | What can be done |
|---|---|---|
| New states and boundaries | Articles 2, 3 and 4 | Admit or form new states, change areas, boundaries and names of states |
| Legislative Councils | Article 169 | Create or abolish a Council in a state, after the state's Assembly passes a resolution |
| Citizenship | Articles 5 to 11 | Parliament may make laws on the acquisition and end of citizenship |
| Scheduled and Tribal Areas | Fifth Schedule, paragraph 7; Sixth Schedule, paragraph 21 | Amend those Schedules by law |
| Elections and some details | Article 327 and others | Laws on elections to Parliament and state legislatures; salaries and the number of judges |
In several of these cases the Constitution itself says that the law is not to be treated as an amendment of the Constitution for the purposes of Article 368. Article 4 says so for laws under Articles 2 and 3, and Article 169 says so for the law on Councils. This is why a bill for a new state is passed by a simple majority and needs no ratification by the states.
Ordinary law, not Article 368: new states and boundaries, Legislative Councils, citizenship, Fifth and Sixth Schedules, many details such as the number of judges.
Worked example 1
Question: Parliament wishes to change the name of a state. Which procedure applies? Step 1: changing the name of a state is within Article 3. Step 2: the bill is introduced on the recommendation of the President and is sent to the state legislature for its views. Step 3: Parliament passes it by a simple majority; it is not bound by the state's views. Step 4: Article 4 says this is not an amendment under Article 368. Answer: an ordinary law by simple majority, with no ratification.
Worked example 2
Question: Parliament wants to increase the number of judges of the Supreme Court. Is an amendment needed? Step 1: look at Article 124(1): the number was fixed 'until Parliament by law prescribes'. Step 2: so the number is for Parliament to decide by law. Step 3: therefore an ordinary Act by simple majority is enough. Answer: no amendment is needed.
Worked example 3
Question: A student says, 'Anything in the Constitution can be changed by a simple majority if Parliament wishes.' Check it. Step 1: the claim is too wide. Step 2: only specific matters are left to ordinary law. Step 3: most of the Constitution needs a special majority under Article 368, and federal matters need ratification as well. Answer: the claim is wrong.
Key takeaways: some matters are left to ordinary law so that Parliament can settle them easily; look for the words until Parliament by law provides; new states, Councils, citizenship, the Fifth and Sixth Schedules and similar details are changed by a simple majority; most of the Constitution is not changed this way.
Check your understanding
-
1. A law creating a new state is passed by
- A special majority and ratification by half the states
- A simple majority, as an ordinary law
- A referendum of all citizens
- The President alone, by an order
Show answer
Answer: B. Under Articles 3 and 4 a law forming a new state is an ordinary law passed by a simple majority and is not an amendment under Article 368.
-
2. The words 'until Parliament by law provides' show that
- The provision can never be changed at all
- The provision needs a referendum of citizens
- The provision is a Fundamental Right in Part III
- Parliament may change the rule by ordinary law
Show answer
Answer: D. These words mean that the rule is temporary and Parliament can replace it by an Act.
-
3. Which of these is generally changed by ordinary law?
- The number of Supreme Court judges
- The election of the President
- The Seventh Schedule lists
- Article 368 itself
Show answer
Answer: A. The number of judges was left to Parliament by Article 124(1). The other items need an amendment under Article 368.
-
4. Article 4 says that laws made under Articles 2 and 3 are
- Subject to ratification by all states
- Not amendments under Article 368
- Void unless the Supreme Court approves
- Valid only for ten years
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 4 states that such laws are not to be treated as amendments of the Constitution for Article 368.
-
5. Is it correct that any provision of the Constitution can be changed by a simple majority?
- Yes, if the President agrees
- Yes, if the Supreme Court agrees
- No, only specific matters can be
- No, nothing can be changed
Show answer
Answer: C. Only specified matters are left to ordinary law. Most provisions need a special majority, and some need ratification too.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.