- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
India's amendment process compared with other countries
Compare how India, the United Kingdom, the United States, Switzerland and Australia change their constitutions, and see why India's method is called a mix of rigid and flexible.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Every country has to decide how hard it should be to change its constitution. If it is too easy, rulers may change the basic rules for their own benefit. If it is too hard, the constitution may become out of date. Looking at how other countries choose helps you understand India's choice and answer comparison questions.
Four common methods
- Ordinary law: the legislature changes the constitution as it makes any other law. This is the flexible method.
- Special majority in the legislature: a bigger majority than for ordinary laws is needed.
- Approval by the units of a federation: the states or provinces must agree.
- Referendum: the people vote directly on the change.
| Country | Method in brief | Type |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | Constitutional rules can be changed by ordinary Acts of Parliament | Flexible |
| United States | Two-thirds of both Houses of Congress propose; three-fourths of the states ratify | Rigid |
| Switzerland | A referendum in which a majority of voters and a majority of cantons agree | Rigid, with direct vote |
| Australia | A referendum won by a majority of voters overall and a majority of voters in a majority of the states | Rigid, with direct vote |
| India | Most parts: special majority in each House of Parliament; federal parts: ratification by half the states as well; some parts by ordinary law | Mixed |
Where India's method came from
Textbooks usually say that the idea of amending the Constitution by a special majority of Parliament was drawn from the Constitution of South Africa. India did not copy the American model of ratification by three-fourths of the states for every amendment, and it did not copy the Swiss or Australian use of a referendum. India asks the states to ratify only for the matters that affect the federal balance.
Why a mixed system
The framers wanted the Constitution to be a living document that could be changed as society changed, so most parts need only a special majority in Parliament. They also wished to protect the federal arrangement, so the matters that concern states need half of the states to agree. And they left minor matters to ordinary law so that the Constitution would not be clogged with small changes.
India: not purely rigid like the United States, not purely flexible like the United Kingdom; no referendum, and no role for the President except giving assent.
Worked example 1
Question: Which country amends its constitution by ordinary Acts of its Parliament? Step 1: look for the flexible method. Step 2: the United Kingdom does not have a single written constitution, and Parliament can change constitutional rules like any other law. Answer: the United Kingdom.
Worked example 2
Question: Does an amendment of the Indian Constitution ever need approval by the people in a referendum? Step 1: Article 368 lists the steps: introduction in Parliament, special majority in each House, ratification by states for some matters, assent of the President. Step 2: there is no step for a referendum. Answer: no.
Worked example 3
Question: In the United States, how many states must ratify an amendment, and how does this differ from India? Step 1: three-fourths of the states must ratify. Step 2: in India only half of the states need ratify, and only for federal matters. Answer: the Indian requirement is smaller and applies to fewer matters.
Key takeaways: the United Kingdom is flexible; the United States is rigid with a three-fourths ratification; Switzerland and Australia use referendums; India mixes special majority, ratification by half of the states for federal matters, and ordinary law for some matters; there is no referendum in India.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which country is usually described as having a flexible constitution?
- United States
- Switzerland
- Australia
- United Kingdom
Show answer
Answer: D. In the United Kingdom, constitutional rules can be changed by ordinary Acts of Parliament.
-
2. In the United States, ratification of an amendment needs
- Half of the states
- Three-fourths of the states
- Nine-tenths of the states
- The President's signature only
Show answer
Answer: B. Three-fourths of the states must ratify an amendment proposed by Congress.
-
3. India's amendment procedure is usually described as having been drawn from the constitution of
- The United States
- Australia
- South Africa
- Switzerland
Show answer
Answer: C. Textbooks usually trace the special majority procedure of Article 368 to the South African Constitution.
-
4. Which country requires a majority of voters and a majority of cantons in a referendum?
- Switzerland
- India
- United Kingdom
- South Africa
Show answer
Answer: A. Switzerland requires the double majority of voters and cantons. India has no referendum and the United Kingdom uses ordinary Acts.
-
5. Ratification by half the states is required in India for
- Every amendment
- Federal matters only
- Fundamental Rights
- Directive Principles
Show answer
Answer: B. Only amendments touching the federal provisions listed in the proviso to Article 368(2) need ratification by half of the states.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.