- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The three ways to amend: simple, special and special plus states
Tell apart a simple majority, a special majority and ratification by the states, and recognise which kind of provision needs which procedure.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every provision of the Constitution is equally important to the balance of power in India. Changing the name of a state is not as weighty as changing how the President is elected. So the Constitution sets three levels of difficulty. Once you know what each level means, many questions answer themselves.
First, what is a 'majority'?
A simple majority means more than half of the members present and voting. If 100 members vote, 51 'yes' votes are enough. A special majority under Article 368 has two parts, and both must be met in each House: (a) a majority of the total membership of the House, and (b) at least two-thirds of the members present and voting. Total membership means the whole strength of the House, not just those in the room.
Level 1: simple majority of Parliament
Some provisions can be changed by an ordinary law passed by a simple majority. The Constitution itself says that such changes are not 'amendments' for the purposes of Article 368. Examples include forming new states or changing the area, boundaries or names of existing states (Articles 2, 3 and 4), creating or abolishing a Legislative Council in a state (Article 169), and many matters where the Constitution says 'until Parliament by law provides', such as rules on citizenship and the salaries and allowances of members of Parliament.
Level 2: special majority of Parliament
Most of the Constitution falls here. Fundamental Rights and the Directive Principles of State Policy, for example, are amended by a special majority of both Houses. No approval of the states is needed.
Level 3: special majority plus ratification by states
Provisions that affect the federal structure need a special majority in Parliament and ratification by the legislatures of at least half of the states, each by a simple majority. These include the election of the President, the Supreme Court and the High Courts, the distribution of legislative powers between the Union and the states, any of the lists in the Seventh Schedule, the representation of states in Parliament, and Article 368 itself.
| Level | What is needed | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Simple majority | Ordinary law of Parliament | New states, names and boundaries; Legislative Councils; citizenship rules |
| Special majority | Total-membership majority and two-thirds present and voting, in each House | Fundamental Rights; Directive Principles |
| Special majority plus states | As above, plus at least half of the state legislatures | Election of the President; Supreme Court and High Courts; Seventh Schedule lists; Article 368 |
Special majority = majority of total membership AND two-thirds of those present and voting, in each House. Federal provisions also need half the states.
Worked example 1
Suppose (for practice) a House has a total membership of 300. On the day of the vote, 240 members are present and all vote. What is the smallest 'yes' vote that passes an amendment? Part (a): a majority of 300 is more than 150, so at least 151. Part (b): two-thirds of 240 is 160. Both must hold, so the answer is the larger number, 160.
Worked example 2
A bill changes the method of electing the President. Which procedure applies? Step 1: is it a simple-majority matter? No, the election of the President is not in that group. Step 2: does it affect the federal structure? Yes, the President is elected by both Parliament and the state assemblies. Step 3: so it needs a special majority in both Houses and ratification by at least half of the states.
Key takeaways: three levels - simple majority (outside Article 368), special majority (most provisions, including Fundamental Rights), and special majority with ratification by half the states (federal provisions). In a special majority, both conditions must be met; the higher number decides.
Check your understanding
-
1. A special majority under Article 368 requires
- Two-thirds of the total membership only
- A majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting
- Half of the members present
- Three-fourths of members present and voting
Show answer
Answer: B. Both conditions must be met in each House: majority of total membership and at least two-thirds of those present and voting.
-
2. Changing the name of a state requires
- A simple majority law of Parliament
- A special majority only
- A special majority and ratification by states
- A national referendum
Show answer
Answer: A. Under Articles 3 and 4 this is done by an ordinary law and is not deemed an amendment under Article 368.
-
3. Fundamental Rights can be amended by
- Simple majority
- Special majority and ratification by half the states
- Special majority of Parliament
- They can never be amended
Show answer
Answer: C. Fundamental Rights need a special majority; state ratification is not required.
-
4. A House has total membership 200; 150 members are present and voting. What is the minimum number of 'yes' votes needed for a special majority?
- 76
- 100
- 134
- 101
Show answer
Answer: D. Majority of total membership 200 = more than 100, i.e. 101. Two-thirds of 150 present and voting = 100. Both must hold, so the larger figure, 101, is the minimum; 100 fails the first condition.
-
5. Which provision needs ratification by at least half of the state legislatures?
- Directive Principles
- Representation of states in Parliament
- Salaries of MPs
- Creation of a Legislative Council
Show answer
Answer: B. Representation of states in Parliament is a federal provision listed in the proviso to Article 368(2).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.