- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
What amending the Constitution means
Explain why a constitution needs a way to change, what makes the Indian Constitution partly rigid and partly flexible, and where the amending power is found.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A constitution is written for generations, but no group of people can foresee every problem the future will bring. If a constitution could never change, it would either be ignored or overthrown. If it could be changed as easily as an ordinary law, it would give no lasting protection. Every constitution therefore chooses a middle path: change is allowed, but through a special procedure. This lesson explains that idea in plain language.
What an amendment is
To amend means to change. A constitutional amendment adds a new provision, changes an existing one, or removes one. In India the power to do this belongs to Parliament, and the procedure is laid down in Article 368, which sits in Part XX of the Constitution, titled 'Amendment of the Constitution'. A proposal to amend is introduced as a Constitution Amendment Bill. When it completes the procedure and the President gives assent, it becomes a Constitution (Amendment) Act, numbered in order, such as the 'Forty-second Amendment'.
Rigid and flexible constitutions
Political scientists sort constitutions into two kinds. A rigid constitution needs a special, harder procedure to change it - for example, a larger majority than for ordinary laws, or the approval of the states. The Constitution of the United States is a well-known example. A flexible constitution can be changed in the same way as an ordinary law; the British constitution, which is not written in one document, is the usual example.
The Indian Constitution is neither wholly rigid nor wholly flexible; it is a mix of both. Some provisions can be changed by Parliament with a simple majority, like an ordinary law. Most need a special majority in both Houses. A few, which affect the federal structure, also need the approval of at least half of the states. This blend is one of the most frequently tested ideas in competitive exams.
| Type | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Rigid | Needs a special procedure harder than for ordinary laws | Constitution of the USA |
| Flexible | Changed like an ordinary law | British constitution |
| Partly rigid, partly flexible | Different procedures for different provisions | Constitution of India |
Where the idea came from
The framers studied many constitutions. The procedure for amendment with a special majority is usually described in textbooks as borrowed from the Constitution of South Africa. The framers wanted a procedure that was not so hard that the Constitution would become frozen, and not so easy that a passing majority could rewrite it.
Article 368, Part XX: Parliament amends the Constitution. India's Constitution is partly rigid and partly flexible.
Worked example 1
Question: 'The Indian Constitution is rigid.' Is this fully correct? Step 1: ask whether every part needs a special procedure. Step 2: no - some provisions can be changed by a simple majority of Parliament. Step 3: so the statement is only partly correct. The accurate description is 'partly rigid and partly flexible'.
Worked example 2
Question: A student says, 'An amendment is made by the President by order.' Check it. Step 1: who has the power? Article 368 gives the power to Parliament. Step 2: what does the President do? The President gives assent after Parliament has passed the bill. Step 3: so the statement is wrong; the President signs, but does not make, the amendment.
Key takeaways: amending means formally changing the Constitution; the power is with Parliament under Article 368 in Part XX; India's Constitution is a mix of rigid and flexible; the special majority procedure is traced to South Africa.
Check your understanding
-
1. The procedure for amending the Indian Constitution is given in
- Article 356
- Article 368
- Article 370
- Article 360
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 368 in Part XX lays down the power and procedure of amendment.
-
2. Article 368 is placed in which Part of the Constitution?
- Part XX
- Part III
- Part XVIII
- Part IV
Show answer
Answer: A. Part XX is titled 'Amendment of the Constitution' and contains Article 368.
-
3. A constitution that can be amended in the same way as an ordinary law is called
- Rigid
- Federal
- Flexible
- Unwritten only
Show answer
Answer: C. A flexible constitution is changed by the ordinary law-making process.
-
4. The Indian Constitution is best described as
- Wholly rigid
- Wholly flexible
- Unamendable
- Partly rigid and partly flexible
Show answer
Answer: D. Some provisions need only a simple majority, others a special majority, and some also need state ratification.
-
5. The procedure of amendment of the Indian Constitution is usually said to be borrowed from the Constitution of
- South Africa
- USA
- Canada
- Ireland
Show answer
Answer: A. Standard textbooks trace the amendment procedure to the Constitution of South Africa.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.