- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
President's Rule (Article 356): when and how it is used
Learn the grounds for President's Rule in a state, how Parliament approves it, how long it can last, what happens to the state, and the safeguards from the Bommai case.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
President's Rule is the emergency that has been used most often in India. It is imposed on a single state when its government cannot function according to the Constitution, for example when no party can form a stable government. Because it removes an elected state government, the Constitution and the courts have placed safeguards around it. This lesson explains its grounds, approval, duration, effects and limits.
Grounds
- Article 356: the President, on receiving a report from the Governor of the state or otherwise, is satisfied that the government of the state cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution.
- Article 365: a state fails to comply with, or to give effect to, directions given by the Union; the President may then hold that the state's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution.
Approval and duration
Both Houses of Parliament must approve the proclamation within two months of its issue. Approval needs only a simple majority of each House. Once approved, it lasts six months from the date of issue, and it can be extended for a maximum of three years, with Parliament's approval every six months. Beyond one year, it can be continued only if two conditions are both met: a national emergency is in force in the whole of India or in the whole or part of that state, and the Election Commission certifies that elections to the state assembly cannot be held because of difficulties. The President can revoke President's Rule at any time without Parliament's approval.
What happens in the state
- The President takes over the functions of the state government; the Chief Minister and Council of Ministers are dismissed.
- The Governor runs the state on behalf of the President, usually with the help of advisers.
- Parliament makes laws for the state, or allows the President to make them (Article 357). These laws continue after President's Rule ends until the state legislature changes them.
- The state legislative assembly is either suspended or dissolved.
- The High Court is not affected; its powers cannot be taken over.
The Bommai case (1994)
In the S.R. Bommai case, the Supreme Court set important limits. A proclamation under Article 356 can be reviewed by the courts, and it can be struck down if it rests on irrelevant or improper grounds. Whether a government has lost its majority should be tested on the floor of the assembly, not decided in the Governor's office. The assembly should be dissolved only after Parliament approves the proclamation; until then it can only be suspended. The case also held that secularism is part of the basic structure of the Constitution.
Worked example 1: a President's Rule timeline
Suppose President's Rule is proclaimed in a state on 1 January. Step 1, approval: both Houses must approve within two months, that is, by about 1 March. Step 2, first period: if approved, it lasts six months from the date of issue, to about 1 July. Step 3, extensions: each further six months needs approval again. Step 4, the one-year mark: to continue beyond 1 January of the next year, a national emergency must be in force and the Election Commission must certify the difficulty in holding elections. Step 5, the outer limit: three years from issue, that is, until 1 January three years later.
Worked example 2: counting the approvals
How many times must Parliament approve President's Rule to keep it running for the full three years? Three years is 36 months; each approval covers six months, so 36 ÷ 6 = 6 periods, and each period needs approval. So both Houses must approve six times: the first approval of the proclamation, then five extensions. Compare this with a national emergency, which also needs approval every six months but has no upper limit.
President's Rule: approved within two months by simple majority; six months at a time from the date of issue; at most three years; beyond one year only with a national emergency and the Election Commission's certificate. The High Court is never affected.
Key takeaways
President's Rule is imposed on a state under Article 356 (or after a failure to follow Union directions, Article 365). It needs approval within two months by simple majority and can last up to three years. The state government is dismissed and Parliament legislates for the state, but the High Court continues as before. The Bommai case made the proclamation open to judicial review and stressed the floor test.
Check your understanding
-
1. Within what time must Parliament approve a proclamation of President's Rule?
- One month
- Two months
- Six months
- One year
Show answer
Answer: B. Both Houses must approve a proclamation under Article 356 within two months of its issue.
-
2. What is the maximum period for which President's Rule can continue in a state?
- One year
- Six months
- Five years
- Three years
Show answer
Answer: D. With Parliament's approval every six months, President's Rule can last up to three years at most.
-
3. Which of these is NOT affected by President's Rule in a state?
- The state Council of Ministers
- The state legislative assembly
- The High Court of the state
- The power to make laws for the state
Show answer
Answer: C. The Council of Ministers is dismissed, the assembly is suspended or dissolved, and law-making passes to Parliament, but the High Court's powers are untouched.
-
4. To continue President's Rule beyond one year, which conditions must be met?
- A national emergency is in force and the Election Commission certifies difficulty in holding elections
- The Governor sends a second report
- The Supreme Court approves the extension
- The state assembly passes a resolution asking for it
Show answer
Answer: A. Since the 44th Amendment, extension beyond one year needs both a national emergency in operation and the Election Commission's certificate that assembly elections cannot be held.
-
5. Which case held that a proclamation of President's Rule is open to judicial review and that a majority should be tested on the floor of the House?
- Kesavananda Bharati case
- Golaknath case
- S.R. Bommai case
- Maneka Gandhi case
Show answer
Answer: C. The S.R. Bommai case (1994) laid down these safeguards on the use of Article 356.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.