• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Where the emergency provisions came from: the 1935 Act, Weimar and the framers' reasons

Learn the sources of India's emergency provisions, why the framers chose a strong Union in a crisis, and how to answer simple source-matching questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on the emergency provisions often start with where they came from. Behind these questions is a simple idea: the makers of the Constitution had just seen Partition, communal violence and the problems of keeping a large country together. They wanted the Union government to be able to act quickly when the country or a state faced a real crisis. This lesson explains the sources and the reasons in plain terms.

Two main sources

The first source is the Government of India Act, 1935, the law under which India was governed before independence. It gave the Governor-General special powers in an emergency and allowed a provincial Governor to take over the government of a province if it could not be carried on under the Act. The powers of the President under Article 356 are based on this second idea.

The second source is the Weimar Constitution of Germany, which allowed the head of state to act in an emergency and to suspend certain rights. India's provisions on the suspension of Fundamental Rights during an emergency are traced to it. You do not need the German details; you only need to remember the name of the source in a matching question.

Where some important parts of the Constitution were borrowed from
Part of the ConstitutionMain source
Emergency provisions (Part XVIII)Government of India Act, 1935 and the Weimar Constitution of Germany
Fundamental RightsConstitution of the United States
Directive Principles of State PolicyConstitution of Ireland
Strong Union in a federationConstitution of Canada
Parliamentary governmentBritain

Why the framers kept these powers

  • Unity and security. After Partition, the framers wanted the Union to be able to protect the country from war, rebellion and breakdown without waiting for long procedures.
  • One country, many governments. India has a Union and many states. If a state government fails, someone must be responsible for ensuring that the Constitution is followed. Article 355 makes this a duty of the Union.
  • A temporary measure. The provisions were meant for rare occasions. Dr Ambedkar, in the Constituent Assembly, said that he hoped the powers would hardly be used and would remain, in practice, a safety device; he also expected the President to act with care and to give warnings before taking drastic steps. This is a summary of his view, not an exact quotation.

Not a break in the Constitution

It is important to see that an emergency is a part of the Constitution, not a pause in it. Every emergency is declared by following an Article, must be approved by Parliament, and can be examined by the courts. The purpose of Part XVIII is to let the Constitution work in a different way in a crisis, not to replace it.

Worked example 1: matching sources

Question: Match the feature with its source: (i) emergency provisions, (ii) Directive Principles, (iii) Fundamental Rights. Sources: (a) Ireland, (b) United States, (c) Government of India Act 1935 and the Weimar Constitution. Working: Emergency provisions are from the 1935 Act and the Weimar Constitution, so (i) matches (c). The Directive Principles are from Ireland, so (ii) matches (a). Fundamental Rights are from the United States, so (iii) matches (b). Answer: (i)-(c), (ii)-(a), (iii)-(b).

Worked example 2: reasoning from the purpose

Question: Why does the Constitution give the Union the power to take over the government of a state under Article 356 even though India is a federation? Working: Step 1, India is a federation, but it is also meant to remain one country. Step 2, Article 355 makes it the Union's duty to ensure that every state government works according to the Constitution. Step 3, if a state government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution, the Union needs a lawful way to step in. Article 356 provides it, and Parliament must approve the step. Answer: to protect the constitutional government of the state and the unity of the country, subject to approval by Parliament.

Emergency provisions: Government of India Act, 1935 and the Weimar Constitution. They are a part of the Constitution, meant for rare use, and Article 355 is the Union's duty behind them.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • The emergency provisions come mainly from the 1935 Act and the Weimar Constitution.
  • The framers wanted a Union strong enough to protect unity and security in a crisis.
  • The provisions are safeguards that are part of the Constitution, and they are checked by Parliament and the courts.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The suspension of Fundamental Rights during an emergency was borrowed from:

    1. the Constitution of Ireland
    2. the Constitution of Canada
    3. the Weimar Constitution of Germany
    4. the Constitution of Australia
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The suspension of Fundamental Rights comes from the Weimar Constitution of Germany; most of Part XVIII comes from the Government of India Act, 1935.

  2. 2. Under which earlier law could a provincial Governor take over a province's government?

    1. The Indian Councils Act, 1909
    2. The Government of India Act, 1935
    3. The Indian Independence Act, 1947
    4. The Regulating Act, 1773
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 1935 Act allowed such a takeover and is the model for Article 356.

  3. 3. Which Article makes it the Union's duty to protect every state against external aggression and internal disturbance?

    1. Article 353
    2. Article 354
    3. Article 356
    4. Article 355
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 355 states this duty. Article 356 provides one way of acting on it.

  4. 4. The Directive Principles of State Policy were borrowed mainly from:

    1. Ireland
    2. the United States
    3. Germany
    4. Britain
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Directive Principles come from the Constitution of Ireland.

  5. 5. Which statement about the framers' view is the best summary?

    1. Emergency powers should be used often
    2. Emergency powers should replace Parliament
    3. Emergency powers should not need approval
    4. Emergency powers should be used with care
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The framers expected these powers to be used rarely and carefully, with Parliament's approval.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery