• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Who acts in an emergency: the President, the Cabinet and the Governor

Understand that the President acts on the advice of the Union Cabinet, how the Governor's report fits into President's Rule, and who runs a state during it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Constitution says that the President proclaims an emergency. A student may therefore think the President decides alone. In India's parliamentary system, however, the real decisions are taken by the elected government. To answer questions correctly, you need to know whose advice the President follows, what changed after the experience of 1975, and what role the Governor plays.

The President acts on advice

Article 74(1) provides that there shall be a Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister to aid and advise the President. The 42nd Amendment (1976) made this advice binding on the President. The 44th Amendment (1978) allowed the President to ask the Council of Ministers to reconsider its advice once, but the President must act on the advice given after reconsideration. So the President does not take the decision alone.

What the 44th Amendment added for a national emergency

Under Article 352(3), the President may proclaim a national emergency only after the Union Cabinet has decided to recommend it and has communicated that decision in writing to the President. The Cabinet, not just the Prime Minister alone, must have taken the decision. The purpose was to make sure that the Cabinet as a whole, and not one person alone, takes this serious decision.

The Governor and President's Rule

The Governor is appointed by the President and acts as the Union's representative in the state. Under Article 356, the President may proclaim President's Rule on receipt of a report from the Governor or otherwise. The words 'or otherwise' mean that a report is not essential; the President, on the advice of the Union Cabinet, may act on other information. Once President's Rule is in force, the Governor usually runs the state on behalf of the President, often with the help of advisers, while the state's Council of Ministers is dismissed and its legislature is suspended or dissolved.

Who does what
Person or bodyRole
Union CabinetDecides to recommend a National Emergency and sends the decision in writing
PresidentProclaims the emergency on the Cabinet's advice and may ask for reconsideration once
GovernorReports on a state; runs the state for the President during President's Rule
ParliamentApproves the proclamation within the time limit

Worked example 1: the chain of steps

Question: Put in order: (a) Parliament approves, (b) the President proclaims President's Rule, (c) the Governor sends a report, (d) the Union Cabinet decides to advise the proclamation. Working: the Governor's report comes first, (c). The Union Cabinet then decides, (d). On that advice the President proclaims, (b). Finally, Parliament must approve within two months, (a). Answer: (c), (d), (b), (a).

Worked example 2: testing a statement

Statement: 'The President may proclaim a national emergency on his own judgment, without the Cabinet's written decision.' Working: Article 352(3), added by the 44th Amendment, says the President cannot proclaim unless the decision of the Union Cabinet, communicated in writing, has been received. Therefore the statement is false. Further, even before that, Article 74 required the President to follow the Council of Ministers' advice. Answer: false.

The President proclaims; the Union Cabinet decides, in writing for Article 352. A Governor's report is common for Article 356 but not essential ('or otherwise').

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • The President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers; the 44th Amendment allows one reconsideration.
  • A national emergency needs the Union Cabinet's decision communicated in writing.
  • The Governor's report is not essential for President's Rule, and the Governor runs the state for the President during it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A national emergency can be proclaimed only after the decision of:

    1. the Union Cabinet, in writing
    2. the Prime Minister alone
    3. the Chief Justice of India
    4. the Governors of all states
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 352(3) requires the written communication of the Union Cabinet's decision.

  2. 2. Which Amendment allowed the President to send advice back for reconsideration once?

    1. 42nd Amendment
    2. 61st Amendment
    3. 44th Amendment
    4. 24th Amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The 44th Amendment (1978) added the right to return the advice once for reconsideration.

  3. 3. In Article 356, the words 'or otherwise' mean that:

    1. the Governor's report is compulsory
    2. the Governor's report is optional
    3. the Governor must be consulted first
    4. Parliament's approval is not needed
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The President may act even without the Governor's report, on the advice of the Union Cabinet.

  4. 4. During President's Rule, who usually runs the state on behalf of the President?

    1. The Chief Minister
    2. The Speaker
    3. The Chief Justice of the High Court
    4. The Governor
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Governor administers the state as the President's agent, often with advisers.

  5. 5. Who must approve a proclamation of emergency?

    1. Parliament
    2. The Supreme Court
    3. The Election Commission
    4. The Governors
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Every proclamation must be approved by Parliament within the time fixed by the Constitution.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery