• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Safeguards against misuse: a ladder of checks on emergency powers

See the checks the Constitution places on each emergency, from Cabinet decision to Parliament's approval, renewal, revocation and the courts, and learn which check belongs to which emergency.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Emergency powers are strong. If they were used without limits, they could be used to hold on to power or to silence opponents. India's experience in 1975-77 showed this danger. After it, the 44th Amendment (1978) added many safeguards. This lesson arranges the checks in a ladder so that you can recall them by stage: before, during and after the proclamation.

Before the proclamation

  • Union Cabinet's written decision is needed for a national emergency (Article 352(3)).
  • Defined grounds: war, external aggression or armed rebellion. 'Internal disturbance' was removed in 1978.

Soon after the proclamation

  • Parliament must approve. A national emergency needs approval by both Houses within one month, by a special majority. President's Rule and a financial emergency need approval within two months, by a simple majority.
  • If the proclamation is not approved in time, it lapses.

While it continues

  • Renewal: a national emergency lasts six months at a time and needs a fresh special majority to continue. President's Rule is renewed in blocks of six months, up to a maximum of three years.
  • Lok Sabha can end a national emergency. A resolution of disapproval by a simple majority of the Lok Sabha forces the President to revoke it. One-tenth of the members of the Lok Sabha can demand a special sitting.
  • Protection of life and liberty. Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended even in a national emergency.
  • President's Rule beyond one year needs a national emergency and a certificate of the Election Commission.

Through the courts

The courts examine emergencies. In Minerva Mills (1980) the Supreme Court held that the courts can examine a proclamation on limited grounds, such as bad faith (mala fides). In S.R. Bommai (1994) the Court laid down principles for reviewing a proclamation under Article 356, including that the state assembly should not be dissolved until Parliament has approved the proclamation. The High Court's powers continue even under President's Rule.

The ladder of checks
StageSafeguardApplies to
BeforeCabinet's written decisionNational emergency
Soon afterParliamentary approval in one or two monthsAll three emergencies
DuringSix-monthly renewal; Lok Sabha disapprovalNational emergency (renewal also President's Rule)
DuringMaximum of three yearsPresident's Rule
ThroughoutJudicial review; Articles 20 and 21 protectedProclamations, and rights during a national emergency

Worked example 1: which safeguard?

Question: A proclamation of President's Rule is issued on 1 March. By when must Parliament approve it, and what happens if it does not? Working: President's Rule needs approval within two months, so by 1 May. If both Houses do not approve it by then, the proclamation lapses at the end of the two months. Answer: 1 May; it lapses if not approved.

Worked example 2: the Lok Sabha's power

Question: The Lok Sabha has 500 members (illustrative). How many members must sign a notice to demand a special sitting about a national emergency, and how will the House decide? Working: one-tenth of 500 is 50, so at least 50 members must sign. The notice goes to the Speaker, or to the President if the House is not in session, and the sitting must be held within 14 days. If the House passes a resolution disapproving the continuance of the emergency by a simple majority, the emergency must be revoked. Answer: 50 members; a simple majority resolution forces revocation.

Cabinet in writing, Parliament's approval, periodic renewal, the Lok Sabha's power to end a national emergency, Articles 20 and 21 protected, and judicial review.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Safeguards operate before, soon after, during and through the courts.
  • A national emergency is checked more heavily than the other two because it affects rights.
  • The checks are different for each emergency; learn them as a ladder.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Within how long must Parliament approve a national emergency?

    1. One month
    2. Two months
    3. Three months
    4. Six months
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A proclamation under Article 352 must be approved within one month, by a special majority.

  2. 2. Which Fundamental Rights cannot be suspended during a national emergency?

    1. Article 19 and Article 14
    2. Article 25 and Article 26
    3. Article 20 and Article 21
    4. Article 29 and Article 30
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Articles 20 and 21 cannot be suspended even during a national emergency.

  3. 3. What happens if the Lok Sabha passes a resolution of disapproval by a simple majority?

    1. Nothing happens
    2. The emergency continues
    3. The Lok Sabha is dissolved
    4. The emergency must be revoked
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Under Article 352 the President must revoke the proclamation when the Lok Sabha disapproves its continuance.

  4. 4. What is the maximum period of President's Rule?

    1. One year
    2. Two years
    3. Three years
    4. Five years
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Six-month extensions are possible up to a maximum of three years, with conditions after one year.

  5. 5. The Supreme Court's principles on reviewing Article 356 were laid down in:

    1. Kesavananda Bharati
    2. Bommai
    3. Gopalan
    4. Golaknath
    Show answer

    Answer: B. S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) set the principles for judicial review of President's Rule.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery