- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Assumptions behind comparisons, numbers and results
Spot what a decision based on a comparison, a figure or a change in results takes for granted, and avoid the extreme claims that are only decoys.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many statements justify a decision with a comparison ('it costs less'), a figure ('one tap for every 200 people') or a change ('accidents fell after the rule'). A decision like this rests on silent beliefs about what matters and what caused the change. Your job is to name those beliefs and to reject the sweeping ones that the decision does not need.
Three hidden beliefs
- The measure matters. If someone says 'Buy A, it is cheaper', they assume price matters to the listener.
- The figure is a problem or a benefit. A decision to add taps because there is one tap per 200 people assumes that figure is too few.
- The change is linked to the action. Keeping a rule because accidents fell assumes the rule may have helped. A mere coincidence would not justify keeping it.
All the figures in these questions are made up to explain the idea; the method is what matters. The decision-maker is also assumed to believe the figures are reliable, but that belief is rarely offered as an option, so concentrate on the three above.
What is not an assumption
- Insulting the other choice, such as 'Brand B is of poor quality'. The advice needs only that A is cheaper and price matters.
- 'All' or 'only' claims, such as 'only in July' or 'everyone'.
- A repeat of the same figure in the future, such as 'it will double again'.
Worked example 1
Statement: Buy Brand A tea; it costs less than Brand B. I. Buyers want to save money. II. Brand B tea is of poor quality. The advice works as a reason only if price matters to the buyer, so I is implicit. Brand B may be perfectly good, and the advice does not need to say otherwise. Only I is implicit.
Worked example 2
Statement: The principal advises students to sleep eight hours, because students who slept eight hours scored higher in a test than those who slept five. I. Sleep can affect performance in a test. II. All students who sleep five hours fail. The advice treats the difference in scores as something sleep may cause, so I is implicit. II is extreme and the advice does not need it. Only I is implicit.
Worked example 3
Statement: Suppose a village has one tap for every 200 people, and the panchayat decides to add taps. I. One tap for 200 people is too few. II. More taps can improve the supply to people. Deny I: if one tap for 200 were enough, adding taps would be unnecessary. Deny II: if more taps could not help, the decision would be pointless. Both I and II are implicit.
A decision from a comparison or a figure assumes that the measure matters and that the change or gap is linked to the action. It does not assume that the other choice is bad.
Key takeaways
- Ask: does the measure matter, is the figure a problem, is the change linked to the action?
- Do not run down the alternative; the decision does not need that.
- Reject 'all', 'only' and 'again' claims.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: Buy Brand A tea; it costs less than Brand B. I. Buyers want to save money. II. Brand B tea is of poor quality.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: A. The advice makes sense only if price matters to the buyer, so I is implicit. Nothing in the advice needs Brand B to be poor, so II is not implicit.
-
2. Statement: A town has one bus for every 500 residents, so the council has ordered more buses. I. Every resident travels by bus daily. II. More buses can improve the service for residents.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: B. Ordering more buses assumes they can improve service, so II is implicit. I is an extreme claim about every resident, so it is not implicit.
-
3. Statement: The city kept the helmet rule because accidents fell after it began. I. The rule may have helped reduce accidents. II. The city wants fewer accidents.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: C. Keeping the rule for that reason assumes it may have helped (I) and that fewer accidents is something the city values (II). Both are implicit.
-
4. Statement: Umbrella sales doubled in July, so the shopkeeper ordered more for next July. I. Sales will double again next July. II. People buy umbrellas only in July.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. He needs only a reason to expect good sales again, not an exact repeat, so I is not implicit. 'Only in July' is extreme, so II is not implicit.
-
5. What belief is almost always hidden in a decision based on a comparison?
- The other choice is bad in every possible way
- The thing being measured matters to the person deciding
- Every person will take the same decision
- The comparison will stay true for ever
Show answer
Answer: B. A comparison supports a decision only if the measure (price, speed, quality) matters. The other options are extreme claims.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.