- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The negation test
Use the negation test: deny the assumption and see whether the statement collapses. If it does, the assumption was implicit.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
How can you be sure that an assumption is truly hidden in a statement? Use the negation test. Take the assumption, say its opposite, and ask whether the statement still makes sense. If the opposite makes the statement pointless or false, the original assumption was implicit.
Steps
The negation test
- Write the assumption
- Write its opposite The negation.
- Reread the statement With the opposite in mind.
- No sense now? Then the assumption is implicit.
- Still stands? Then the assumption is not implicit.
- Write the assumption.
- Write its opposite (negation).
- Read the statement again with the opposite in mind.
- If the statement now makes no sense, the assumption is implicit.
- If the statement still stands, the assumption is not implicit.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statement: 'Use the helmet while riding; it protects your head.' Assumption: A helmet protects the head. Negation: A helmet does not protect the head. Then the advice is pointless, so the assumption is implicit.
Example 2. Statement: 'The company advertised the new phone on television.' Assumption I: Television advertisements can reach potential buyers. Negation: Television advertisements cannot reach potential buyers. Then advertising on television would be pointless, so I is implicit. Assumption II: The new phone is cheaper than all other phones. Negation: The new phone is not cheaper than all others. The advertisement still makes sense, so II is not implicit.
The phone advertised on television
-
I: TV ads can reach buyers
- Negation: they cannot reach buyers
- Advertising on television would be pointless
- Implicit
-
II: The phone is the cheapest
- Negation: it is not cheaper than all others
- The advertisement still makes sense
- Not implicit
Example 3. Statement: 'Ravi says: I will travel by the early morning train to reach the meeting on time.' Assumption: The early morning train will reach in time for the meeting. Negation: The early train will not reach in time. Then Ravi's choice is pointless. The assumption is implicit.
Example 4. Statement: 'The school has introduced a library period for all students.' Assumption: Students will benefit from reading books. Negation: Students will not benefit from reading books. The new period would then be pointless, so the assumption is implicit.
Deny the assumption. If the statement collapses, the assumption was implicit.
Key takeaways
- Use the negation test every time you are unsure.
- If the statement collapses without the assumption, it is implicit.
- If the statement stands without it, it is not implicit.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the negation test for an assumption?
- Deny the statement; if the assumption still holds, it is implicit
- If the assumption is true in real life, it is implicit
- Deny the assumption; if the statement then makes no sense, the assumption is implicit
- If denying the assumption leaves the statement unchanged, it is implicit
Show answer
Answer: C. Say the opposite of the assumption and reread the statement. If it collapses or becomes pointless, the assumption was implicit; if it still stands, the assumption was not.
-
2. Statement: 'Use pesticides to protect the crop.' Assumptions: I. All farmers use pesticides. II. Pesticides can protect crops.
- Only I is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
- Only II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. Negate II: pesticides cannot protect crops - then the advice is pointless, so II is implicit. Negate I: not all farmers use pesticides - the advice still makes sense, so I is not implicit.
-
3. Statement: 'Book your tickets early to get a seat.' Assumptions: I. Seats may not be available later. II. Tickets are cheaper on the day of travel.
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
- Only I is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. Negate I: seats will always be available - then early booking is pointless, so I is implicit. II has nothing to do with getting a seat, and the advice stands without it.
-
4. Statement: 'The company advertised its new phone on television.' Assumptions: I. Television advertisements can reach possible buyers. II. The new phone is cheaper than all other phones.
- Only II is implicit
- Only I is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: B. Negate I: television ads cannot reach buyers - then advertising there is pointless, so I is implicit. Negate II: the phone is not the cheapest - the advertisement still makes sense, so II is not implicit.
-
5. Statement: 'Call the doctor if the fever lasts more than two days.' The negation of the assumption 'A doctor can help with fever' is 'A doctor cannot help with fever'. What does this show?
- The advice becomes pointless, so the assumption is implicit
- The advice still stands, so the assumption is not implicit
- The advice becomes pointless, so the assumption is not implicit
- The negation test cannot be used on advice
Show answer
Answer: A. If a doctor could not help, calling one would serve no purpose. The statement collapses when the assumption is denied, so the assumption is implicit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.