- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Spotting extreme and irrelevant assumptions
Reject assumptions that use extreme words, add unrelated facts or repeat the statement, and accept those that are modest and necessary.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most wrong options in assumption questions fall into a few types. If you learn to recognise them, you can eliminate them quickly. The right options are usually modest, practical beliefs that the statement depends on.
Types of wrong assumptions
Types of wrong assumptions
- Extreme Uses all, only, always, never, none, or 'the best'.
- Irrelevant About something the statement does not depend on.
- A conclusion in disguise States an outcome rather than a prior belief.
- A restatement Simply repeats the statement.
- Extreme: uses all, only, always, never, none, or 'the best'.
- Irrelevant: talks about something the statement does not depend on.
- A conclusion in disguise: states an outcome or result rather than a prior belief.
- A restatement: simply repeats the statement.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statement: 'A mobile company offers free home delivery of its phones.' Assumption I: Customers value the convenience of home delivery. Assumption II: Only home delivery can increase sales. I is modest and necessary (otherwise the offer would be pointless): implicit. II is extreme ('only'): not implicit.
Example 2. Statement: 'The principal advised students to avoid social media during exams.' Assumption I: Social media can distract students. Assumption II: Students will score higher if they avoid social media. I is a prior belief behind the advice: implicit. II predicts an outcome (a result, which is more like a conclusion) and is stronger than the advice needs: not implicit.
Example 3. Statement: 'Buy tickets online to avoid queues.' Assumption: There are queues at the ticket counter. The advice makes sense only if queues exist, so the assumption is implicit. A different option, 'The ticket counter is at the station', is irrelevant to the advice and not implicit.
Reject extreme words, outcomes, repeats and irrelevant facts. Accept the modest belief that the advice or action needs.
Key takeaways
- Extreme words usually make an assumption wrong.
- An outcome is a conclusion, not an assumption.
- A modest, necessary belief is what you want.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: 'Use public transport to reduce pollution.' Assumptions: I. Public transport causes less pollution per person than private vehicles. II. Private vehicles are the only cause of pollution.
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
- Only I is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. I is the modest belief behind the advice, so it is implicit. II uses the extreme word 'only' and the advice does not need it.
-
2. Statement: 'Revise daily to remember the lessons well.' Assumptions: I. Revision helps in remembering. II. Students forget everything they read.
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Only I is implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: C. The advice rests on I. II is extreme ('everything'); revision is useful even if students forget only some of what they read.
-
3. Statement: 'The city plans to plant 10,000 trees along the roads.' Assumptions: I. The city has no trees at present. II. Trees improve the environment.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: B. The plan relies on trees being beneficial, so II is implicit. The city could already have some trees, so I is not needed.
-
4. Statement: 'The principal advised students to avoid social media during exams.' Option: 'Students will score higher if they avoid social media.' Why is this option not implicit?
- It states an outcome, which is a conclusion in disguise, and is stronger than the advice needs
- It simply repeats the statement
- It is about something unrelated to the advice
- It is a modest belief the advice depends on
Show answer
Answer: A. The belief behind the advice is that social media can distract. A promised result such as higher scores is an outcome, not a prior belief, so it is not implicit.
-
5. Statement: 'Buy tickets online to avoid queues.' Assumptions: I. There are queues at the ticket counter. II. The ticket counter is at the station.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: A. The advice makes sense only if queues exist, so I is implicit. Where the counter is has nothing to do with the advice, so II is irrelevant.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.