• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Assumptions behind notices, rules and instructions

See what a notice, a rule or an instruction takes for granted: that the problem can really happen, that the step helps, and that readers can understand it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Notices and rules are short, and they hide a lot of belief. Someone who puts up a notice believes that a problem can happen, that the instruction will help, and that people passing by can read and understand the words. Assumption questions on notices ask you to pick out those beliefs and to leave out the exaggerated ones.

Three beliefs inside every notice

Notice or ruleBelief that the problem can happenBelief that the step helpsBelief about the reader
Keep your phone on silent in the libraryRinging phones can disturb readersSilent phones reduce disturbanceReaders can read and understand the notice
Wet floor board in a corridorSomeone could slip on a wet floorSeeing the board makes people carefulPassers-by can see and understand the board
Read the safety rules before using lab equipmentEquipment can be unsafe if misusedReading rules helps avoid accidentsStudents can understand the rules

The third belief, about the reader, is the one beginners miss. Nobody puts up a notice in a language the reader cannot read, or hides it where nobody can see it. So whenever a statement says that something was displayed, announced or written, the belief that the audience can receive and understand it is a safe, implicit assumption. It is different from the belief that the audience will do what the notice asks, which is not needed.

What is not an assumption

  • That everyone will obey. A rule is made because some might not, so 'everyone will obey' is an extreme claim.
  • That the problem occurs everywhere or all the time. One place and one risk are enough for a notice.
  • Extra facts about other places, such as 'no other library has this problem'.

Worked example 1

Statement: A notice in the library says: 'Please keep your mobile phones on silent.' I. Ringing phones can disturb readers. II. Every visitor will keep the phone silent. The request makes sense only if ringing phones can disturb readers, so I is implicit. Deny II: if some visitors did not obey, the notice would still have been a sensible request. II is extreme. Only I is implicit.

Worked example 2

Statement: The railway station has displayed the train timetable at the platform entrance. I. Passengers can read and use a displayed timetable. II. Trains never run late. Putting up a timetable assumes that passengers can read it and use it, so I is implicit. Whether trains run late has nothing to do with the decision to display it, and 'never' is extreme, so II is not implicit. Only I is implicit.

Worked example 3

Statement: Before using the lab equipment, read the safety rules, says the teacher. I. Reading the rules can help prevent accidents. II. Students are able to understand the rules. Deny I: if reading rules did not help, the instruction would be pointless. Deny II: if students could not understand the rules, reading them would achieve nothing. Both I and II are implicit.

A notice assumes that the risk is real, that the step helps and that readers can understand it. It never assumes that everyone will obey.

Key takeaways

  • Ask three things: can the problem happen, does the step help, can readers understand?
  • Reject 'everyone will obey', 'never' and 'always' claims.
  • An unrelated fact is not an assumption, however true it is.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statement: A notice near the pond says: 'Do not feed the fish.' I. Feeding may harm the fish. II. Nobody will ever feed them.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The notice is sensible only if feeding may harm the fish, so I is implicit. II is extreme: the notice exists because someone might feed them.

  2. 2. Statement: The bank has put up a board giving its working hours at the entrance. I. Customers visit the bank only during these hours. II. Customers can read the board.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Putting up a board assumes customers can read it, so II is implicit. I is extreme and the board does not need it.

  3. 3. Statement: Before using the lab equipment, read the safety rules, says the teacher. I. Reading the rules can help prevent accidents. II. Students are able to understand the rules.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: C. If reading the rules could not prevent accidents, the instruction would be pointless; if students could not understand them, reading would achieve nothing. Both are implicit.

  4. 4. Statement: The warden has asked hostel students to switch off lights when leaving their rooms. I. Every student forgets to switch off lights. II. Electricity is wasted only in hostels.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The request does not need every student to forget, and it does not need hostels to be the only place of waste. Both are extreme, so neither is implicit.

  5. 5. A 'Wet floor' board is placed in a corridor. Which belief does the placing of the board depend on?

    1. People passing by can see and understand the board
    2. Nobody has ever slipped in any corridor
    3. Every person will walk past very slowly
    4. The floor will stay wet for a whole day
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Putting up a sign assumes that passers-by can see and understand it. The other options are extreme or unrelated to the decision.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery