• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Option traps: extreme, stated, future, irrelevant and reversed

Name the five kinds of wrong option in assumption questions, so that you can reject decoys quickly and keep only the belief the statement depends on.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most wrong options in assumption questions belong to one of five families. If you can name the family, you can reject the option in seconds without long thought. This lesson gives a name to each family, shows an example, and then lets you practise spotting them in full questions.

The five traps

TrapWhat it looks likeExample for 'The school opened a new science lab'
ExtremeUses all, every, never, only, noneEvery student will become a scientist
StatedRepeats the statement in other wordsThe school has a science lab now
FuturePredicts what will happen laterStudents will score higher in science
IrrelevantTrue or false, but unrelated to the decisionOther schools have no labs
ReversedSays the opposite of what the statement needsStudents do not need practical work

The assumption in this example is something like 'Practical work in a lab can help students learn science'. It is none of the five traps. It is the unstated belief that makes opening the lab sensible.

Modest words are usually safe

The real assumption in most questions is stated in modest words such as 'can', 'may', 'helps', 'some' or 'is able to'. Decoys prefer strong words such as 'all', 'never', 'only' and 'will certainly'. This is not a law, because a strong word is sometimes forced by the statement, but it is a very reliable first filter. When two options remain after the filter, run the denial test on each.

Using the traps in the exam

  1. Read the options and put a short label beside each: E, S, F, I or R for the five traps, or A if you think it may be the assumption.
  2. Reject every option you have labelled with a trap letter.
  3. Run the denial test on any option labelled A, and then choose your answer.

Worked example 1: naming the traps

Statement: The college has set up a career counselling centre for final-year students. I. Students need guidance about careers. II. All final-year students will get jobs. III. The college has set up a centre. IV. Other colleges have no such centres. Option I is the assumption: if students needed no guidance, the centre would be pointless. Option II is extreme and about the future. Option III is stated. Option IV is irrelevant. Only I is implicit.

Worked example 2

Statement: The coach advised the team to practise in the morning because the afternoons are hot. I. Hot afternoons make practice harder. II. The team cannot practise at all in the afternoon. Deny I: if hot afternoons did not make practice harder, the advice would have no reason. II is extreme: 'cannot ... at all' goes beyond 'harder'. Only I is implicit.

Worked example 3: the reversed trap

Statement: The town has fixed speed limits near schools to protect children. I. Slower vehicles are less likely to hurt children. II. Fast vehicles are safer for children. Option I supports the statement. Option II says the opposite of what the plan needs, so it is reversed. Only I is implicit.

Name the trap and reject: extreme, stated, future, irrelevant or reversed. What remains is the belief the statement stands on.

Key takeaways

  • Learn the five families by name.
  • A stated option is never an assumption, however true it is.
  • A future prediction and an extreme word are the two most common decoys.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. For the statement 'The school opened a new science lab', one option says 'Every student will become a scientist'. What is wrong with it?

    1. It is extreme and it predicts the future
    2. It repeats the statement in other words
    3. It is true but unrelated to the lab
    4. It says the opposite of what the lab needs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Every' is an extreme word and 'will become' is a prediction about the future. Neither is needed for the lab to be opened.

  2. 2. Statement: The firm has asked employees to submit reports online. I. The firm has asked employees to submit reports online. II. Employees can access the internet to submit reports.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Option I repeats the statement, so it is a stated fact and not an assumption. Option II is the belief the request depends on, so it is implicit.

  3. 3. Statement: The hotel has built a lift near the dining hall. I. Some guests find stairs difficult to climb. II. All guests will use the lift.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A lift is useful only if some guests find stairs difficult, so I is implicit. II uses 'all' and is a prediction, so it is not implicit.

  4. 4. Statement: The teacher asked the class to bring dictionaries tomorrow. I. Dictionaries are sold in the school. II. The class will finish early.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Neither option is needed for the request. Where dictionaries are sold is irrelevant, and the class finishing early is a prediction.

  5. 5. Statement: The town has fixed speed limits near schools to protect children. I. Slower vehicles are less likely to hurt children. II. Drivers can see and understand the speed-limit signs.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Deny I: if slower vehicles were not safer, the limits would not protect anyone. Deny II: if drivers could not understand the signs, the limits could not work. Both are implicit.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery