- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
The negation test
Test a suggested assumption by imagining it is false and checking whether the statement then loses its point.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A strong way to check an assumption is the negation test. Suppose the assumption is false. If the statement then makes no sense, the assumption is implicit. If the statement still makes sense, it is not.
How to apply it
- Take the suggested assumption.
- Reverse it ('TV ads do not reach customers').
- Ask whether the speaker's action or advice would still be sensible.
- If it would collapse, the assumption is implicit.
Worked example 1
Statement: 'The company advertised on TV to increase sales.' Assumption: TV ads reach potential customers. Reversed: TV ads do not reach any customers. Then advertising on TV would be pointless, so the assumption is implicit.
Worked example 2
Statement: 'Rina took a loan to start a shop.' Assumption A: the shop can earn enough to repay the loan. Reversed: the shop cannot earn anything. Taking the loan would then be unwise, so A is implicit. Assumption B: Rina has no savings. Reversed: she has savings. She could still borrow, so B is not implicit.
If reversing the assumption destroys the statement, the assumption is implicit.
Key takeaways: reverse the assumption and see whether the statement still stands.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: 'Rina took a loan to start a shop.' Assumptions: I. The shop can earn enough to repay the loan. II. Rina has no savings.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: A. Reverse I: the shop can earn nothing - taking the loan would be unwise, so I is implicit. Reverse II: Rina has savings - she could still borrow, so II is not implicit.
-
2. Statement: 'The hospital opened a night clinic for working people.' Assumptions: I. Day clinics are closed. II. Some people cannot visit during the day.
- Only I is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: C. Reverse II: everyone can visit in the day - a night clinic would be pointless, so II is implicit. The plan does not need day clinics to be closed, so I is not implicit.
-
3. Statement: 'Keep the medicine in a cool place.' Assumptions: I. Heat can spoil medicine. II. All medicines are expensive.
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
- Only I is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. Reverse I: heat does no harm - the advice is pointless, so I is implicit. Reverse II: some medicines are cheap - the advice still stands, so II is not implicit.
-
4. Statement: 'Apply early to avoid the rush.' Assumptions: I. Applications are never accepted late. II. A rush may occur later.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: B. Reverse II: no rush will occur later - there is no reason to apply early, so II is implicit. The advice is about the rush, not about late applications, so I is not needed.
-
5. Statement: 'The company advertised on TV to increase sales.' You reverse the assumption to 'TV ads do not reach any customers'. What do you decide?
- It is not implicit, because the company still advertised
- The assumption is implicit, because advertising on TV would then be pointless
- It is not implicit, because reversing it changes nothing
- You cannot decide without the sales figures
Show answer
Answer: B. If TV ads reached nobody, advertising on TV to increase sales would make no sense. The statement collapses when the assumption is reversed, so it is implicit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.