- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Problem set 3: surveys, comparisons and results
Practise statements built on a survey, a comparison of two choices or a change in results, and see which beliefs they need and which extras are decoys.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statements that use a survey, a comparison or a change in results are popular because they hide two kinds of belief: that the evidence is fair, and that it matters to the decision. This lesson trains you to notice both, with four worked items and a short list of what such statements never assume.
What these statements need
| Kind of statement | Belief it needs | Decoy to reject |
|---|---|---|
| Survey, then a decision | The people surveyed represent those affected | All people will act on the result |
| Comparison of two choices | The measure used is the one that matters | The other choice is bad in every way |
| Result changed after an action | The action may have caused the change | The change will repeat or continue for ever |
| Choice by past experience | The past is a fair guide to the future | Nothing in the future can ever differ |
Why a fair sample matters
Suppose a survey asks only the people who stand outside a sweet shop whether they like sweets. The answer says nothing about the whole town. A decision based on that survey would be sensible only if the people asked were fairly like the people affected. That is why the representative-sample belief is so often implicit when a statement says 'a survey showed'. The decision-maker may be wrong about it, but the decision relies on it, and that is what makes it an assumption.
Worked items
Item 1. A survey of 100 shoppers showed that most prefer cloth bags, so the market committee will encourage cloth bags. I. The shoppers surveyed represent the market's shoppers. II. All shoppers will switch to cloth bags. Deny I: if the 100 shoppers were not like the market's shoppers, the survey would give no basis for the decision. II is extreme. Only I is implicit.
Item 2. Sales of notebooks rose after a shop moved near a school, so the owner plans another shop near a college. I. A location near students can raise sales. II. The college has students who buy notebooks. Deny I: if location did not matter, moving would be pointless. Deny II: if no college student bought notebooks, the new shop would fail. Both I and II are implicit.
Item 3. Rahul scored 80 in Mathematics and 70 in Science, so he decides to spend more time on Science. I. Every student scores higher in Mathematics. II. More time spent on Science can raise his Science marks. I is extreme. II is the link between his plan and his aim. Only II is implicit.
Item 4. Of two roads, the new road is 5 km shorter, so the driver takes it. I. A shorter road always saves time. II. Nobody uses the old road. The driver needs only a reason to expect that the shorter road helps. 'Always' and 'nobody' are extreme. Neither is implicit.
Surveys need a fair sample, comparisons need a measure that matters, and changes need a possible link to the action. Everything with all, always or nobody is a decoy.
Key takeaways
- Ask whether the evidence is fair and whether the measure matters.
- A 'may have caused' link is enough; a 'certainly caused' link is too strong.
- Always, nobody and for ever mark the decoys.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: A survey of 200 customers found that most want longer opening hours, so the library extended its hours. I. The customers surveyed represent the library's users. II. All users will come in the extended hours.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: A. Without a fair sample the survey gives no basis for the decision, so I is implicit. II uses 'all' and is not needed.
-
2. Statement: The coach compared the running times of two athletes and chose Arun because his time was lower. I. Arun will win the race. II. A lower running time is better.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: B. The choice rests on a lower time being better, so II is implicit. I is a prediction the choice does not need.
-
3. Statement: The dairy raised the price of milk by Rs 2 because the cost of cattle feed has risen. I. The dairy's costs matter to its prices. II. Customers may still buy milk at the new price.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: C. Deny I: if costs did not matter to prices, the reason would be pointless. Deny II: if customers would stop buying altogether, raising the price would defeat its purpose. Both are implicit.
-
4. Statement: The shopkeeper noticed that more people buy ice cream on hot days and stocked more in summer. I. People buy ice cream only on hot days. II. Ice cream cannot be sold in winter.
- Only I is implicit
- Only II is implicit
- Both I and II are implicit
- Neither I nor II is implicit
Show answer
Answer: D. He needs only that hot days raise sales, not that sales are zero otherwise. Both options are extreme, so neither is implicit.
-
5. A statement uses a survey of some people to justify a decision. Which belief does the decision depend on?
- Every affected person was surveyed
- The people surveyed are fairly like those affected
- All people will accept the result
- The survey will never be repeated
Show answer
Answer: B. A survey supports a decision only if its sample fairly represents the people affected. The other options are extreme.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.