• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Problem set 2: civic notices, announcements and public services

Practise assumption questions on appeals and announcements made by a municipality, panchayat, school or library, using three questions about the audience.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Statements about public services are common in exams: a council asks citizens to do something, a school starts a facility, a library introduces a new service. They follow a pattern, so with a little practice you can answer them quickly. This lesson gives the pattern and four worked items, one for each possible answer.

Three questions for any public announcement

  • Is there a need? The announcement assumes that the problem or the need really exists.
  • Can the step work? The announcement assumes that the service, request or rule can do what it is meant to do.
  • Can the audience receive it? The announcement assumes that people can hear, read or use it.

The common wrong options are about all citizens doing something, about other places, and about what will happen in future. These claims are not needed for the announcement to make sense. A person can ask citizens to use dustbins without believing that every citizen will.

A quick check on the audience

Before you read the options, ask who the announcement is addressed to. A request to citizens assumes that citizens can understand it. A rule for shopkeepers assumes that shopkeepers can follow it. A service for students assumes that students can use it. This single question often gives you the implicit option in one step, because the options usually offer one belief about the audience that is reasonable and another that is exaggerated. Choose the reasonable one and reject the exaggerated one.

Worked items

Item 1. The municipality has asked citizens to use dustbins for waste. I. Dustbins can keep the city cleaner. II. Every citizen will use the dustbins. Deny I: if dustbins did not help cleanliness, the request would be pointless. II is extreme, since the request exists because some may not comply. Only I is implicit.

Item 2. The school has started a bus service for students from distant villages. I. Students from distant villages find it difficult to reach school without it. II. The bus can bring the students to school. Deny I: if they had no difficulty, the service would not be needed. Deny II: if the bus could not bring them, the service would be useless. Both I and II are implicit.

Item 3. The district office has announced a holiday for schools on the day of the local fair. I. All shops will be closed that day. II. Fairs are held only in this district. Neither claim is needed for declaring a holiday. Both are extreme. Neither is implicit.

Item 4. The library has started an app to reserve books. I. All members own smartphones. II. Members can use an app to reserve books. The service assumes that members can use it, so II is implicit. I says 'all members', which is extreme. Only II is implicit.

For a public announcement ask: is there a need, can the step work, can the audience receive it? Never assume that all citizens will comply.

Key takeaways

  • Use the three questions: need, workability, reach.
  • Reject claims about all citizens, other places and the future.
  • Expect every one of the four answer patterns.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statement: The gram sabha has fixed a day for cleaning the village pond. I. A dirty pond is a problem for the village. II. Every villager will take part.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Cleaning the pond makes sense only if a dirty pond is a problem, so I is implicit. II is extreme and not needed.

  2. 2. Statement: The electricity board has asked people to use energy-saving bulbs to reduce the load. I. Every consumer has already bought such bulbs. II. Using less electricity per bulb can reduce the load.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The request depends on such bulbs being able to reduce the load, so II is implicit. If every consumer already had them, no request would be needed, so I is not implicit.

  3. 3. Statement: The school has put a ramp at the entrance. I. A ramp can make entry easier for people who cannot climb steps. II. Some people who cannot climb steps may use the school.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Deny I: if a ramp did not help, it would be pointless. Deny II: if nobody who needed it came to the school, it would be pointless too. Both are implicit.

  4. 4. Statement: The mayor has asked shopkeepers to display prices openly. I. All shopkeepers cheat customers. II. No shop displayed prices earlier anywhere.

    1. Only I is implicit
    2. Only II is implicit
    3. Both I and II are implicit
    4. Neither I nor II is implicit
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The request needs neither claim. Both use extreme words ('all', 'no ... anywhere') and are not implicit.

  5. 5. Which question is NOT one of the three useful questions for a public announcement?

    1. Will every citizen obey the announcement?
    2. Is there a need for the step?
    3. Can the step really work?
    4. Can the audience receive the message?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Obedience by every citizen is an extreme claim and is not assumed. The other three questions are the useful ones: need, workability and reach.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery