An assumption is unstated, reasonable and needed by the statement.
Key takeaways: ask why the speaker says it, and accept only the hidden belief that the statement needs.
Revision notes
The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".
Lesson 1
An assumption is unstated, reasonable and needed by the statement.
Key takeaways: ask why the speaker says it, and accept only the hidden belief that the statement needs.
Lesson 2
If reversing the assumption destroys the statement, the assumption is implicit.
Key takeaways: reverse the assumption and see whether the statement still stands.
Lesson 3
Appeals assume the audience wants the benefit and can act on it.
Key takeaways: ask what the speaker believes the audience wants, and avoid extreme claims about 'everyone' or 'nobody'.
Lesson 4
| Kind | Test | Counts as assumption? |
|---|---|---|
| Restatement | Says the same thing again | No |
| Conclusion | Follows from the statement | No |
| Assumption | Must be true for the statement to make sense | Yes |
Restatements and conclusions are not assumptions. The assumption sits behind the statement.
Key takeaways: restatements and conclusions are not assumptions; look for the belief hidden behind the statement.
Lesson 5
Reject extreme words, unrelated claims and restatements; accept the hidden need.
Key takeaways: combine the three-step test with the negation test, and be wary of extreme wording.
Lesson 6
In one minute: underline the link, deny each option, and reject any option with all, every, never or only.
Lesson 7
For a public announcement ask: is there a need, can the step work, can the audience receive it? Never assume that all citizens will comply.
Lesson 8
| Kind of statement | Belief it needs | Decoy to reject |
|---|---|---|
| Survey, then a decision | The people surveyed represent those affected | All people will act on the result |
| Comparison of two choices | The measure used is the one that matters | The other choice is bad in every way |
| Result changed after an action | The action may have caused the change | The change will repeat or continue for ever |
| Choice by past experience | The past is a fair guide to the future | Nothing in the future can ever differ |
Surveys need a fair sample, comparisons need a measure that matters, and changes need a possible link to the action. Everything with all, always or nobody is a decoy.
Lesson 9
| Trap | What it looks like | Example for 'The school opened a new science lab' |
|---|---|---|
| Extreme | Uses all, every, never, only, none | Every student will become a scientist |
| Stated | Repeats the statement in other words | The school has a science lab now |
| Future | Predicts what will happen later | Students will score higher in science |
| Irrelevant | True or false, but unrelated to the decision | Other schools have no labs |
| Reversed | Says the opposite of what the statement needs | Students do not need practical work |
Name the trap and reject: extreme, stated, future, irrelevant or reversed. What remains is the belief the statement stands on.