- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Comparison statements: taller, older, heavier, faster
Draw conclusions from statements that compare people or things, using the chain rule and avoiding claims about the 'tallest' or 'lightest' when not everyone is compared.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statements that compare, such as 'Asha is taller than Bina', are a popular source of conclusion questions. They need no outside knowledge, only a careful reading of who is compared with whom. The main rule is a chain, and the main danger is to claim more than the comparisons give.
The chain rule
If A is taller than B and B is taller than C, then A is taller than C. The same holds for older, heavier, faster, richer and any other comparison in one direction. The comparisons chain together, and the first is above the last.
| Statements | What follows | What does not follow |
|---|---|---|
| A taller than B, and B taller than C | A is taller than C; A is tallest of the three; C is shortest of the three | B taller than A, or C taller than A |
| A is taller than B and A is taller than C | A is taller than both B and C | Which of B and C is taller |
| A is taller than C and B is taller than C | C is shorter than both | Which of A and B is taller |
| A is as tall as B and B is taller than C | A is taller than C | C is taller than A |
Flip the sentences into one direction
Statements often mix directions: one says 'taller than', another says 'shorter than'. Before you draw the chain, rewrite every sentence in the same direction. 'C is lighter than B' becomes 'B is heavier than C'. 'D is younger than A' becomes 'A is older than D'. Once all sentences point the same way, the chain is easy to see, and you can read the order from top to bottom. The same habit works for before and after, earlier and later, north and south, and for any other pair of opposite words.
Two cautions
- 'Tallest' or 'lightest' is true only among the people who have been compared. If the statement compares three people, you may say 'tallest of the three', but not 'tallest in the class'.
- A comparison in one direction does not give the opposite direction. 'A is taller than B' does not give 'B is the shortest'.
Worked example 1
Statement: Asha is taller than Bina. Bina is taller than Chitra. I. Asha is taller than Chitra. II. Bina is the shortest of the three. The chain Asha, Bina, Chitra (from tallest to shortest) gives I. In the chain, Chitra is the shortest, not Bina, so II is false. Only I follows.
Worked example 2
Statement: Ravi is older than Sanjay. Ravi is older than Tarun. I. Sanjay is older than Tarun. II. Ravi is the oldest of the three. Both Sanjay and Tarun are younger than Ravi, so II follows. Nothing compares Sanjay with Tarun, so I does not follow. Only II follows.
Worked example 3
Statement: A is heavier than B. C is lighter than B. I. A is the heaviest of the three. II. B is the heaviest of the three. 'C is lighter than B' means B is heavier than C. The chain from heaviest is A, B, C, so A is the heaviest of the three and I follows. B is in the middle, so II does not follow. Only I follows.
Comparisons chain in one direction. Two things compared with the same third thing are not compared with each other.
Key takeaways
- Write the comparisons as a chain with arrows, from the greatest down to the least.
- 'Greatest' or 'least' holds only for the group that was compared.
- If two things are never compared, say nothing about which is greater.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: P is taller than Q. Q is taller than R. I. R is taller than P. II. P is the tallest of the three.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: B. The chain from tallest is P, Q, R, so P is the tallest of the three and II follows. R is the shortest, so I is false.
-
2. Statement: X earns more than Y. X earns more than Z. I. Y earns more than Z. II. Z earns more than Y.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Both Y and Z are compared only with X. Nothing compares Y with Z, so neither I nor II follows.
-
3. Statement: Mohan is older than Naveen. Naveen is as old as Omkar. I. Mohan is older than Omkar. II. Omkar is older than Mohan.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: A. Naveen and Omkar are of equal age, and Mohan is older than Naveen, so Mohan is older than Omkar. I follows and II does not.
-
4. Statement: A is heavier than B. C is lighter than B. I. C is the lightest of the three. II. A is heavier than C.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. The chain from heaviest is A, B, C. So C is the lightest of the three (I) and A is heavier than C (II). Both follow.
-
5. From the statement 'M is faster than N', which conclusion follows?
- N is the slowest runner of all
- N is slower than M
- M is the fastest runner of all
- M is faster than every other runner
Show answer
Answer: B. Reversing a comparison is safe: 'faster than' becomes 'slower than'. Claims about 'of all' or 'every other' go beyond the two people compared.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.