- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Condition words: only if, unless and 'cannot ... without'
Understand statements that set a requirement, such as 'only if' and 'cannot unless', and see the difference between a requirement and a guarantee.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some statements set a requirement: a ticket for the platform, a card for the library, a code for the gate. Such statements use the words 'only if', 'cannot ... unless' or 'only those who'. They tell you what is required, not what is guaranteed. Confusing a requirement with a guarantee is the most common mistake in these questions.
Requirement against guarantee
| Statement | It gives (a requirement) | It does not give (a guarantee) |
|---|---|---|
| Only passengers with a ticket may enter the platform | A person on the platform has a ticket | Every person with a ticket is on the platform |
| The gate opens only if the code is correct | If the gate opened, the code was correct | If the code is correct, the gate opens |
| Students cannot appear in the test unless they have submitted the project | A student who has not submitted the project cannot appear | Every student who has submitted will appear |
Notice that all three forms say the same kind of thing: something is needed. A requirement is like a locked door that needs a key. Having the key does not mean the door will be opened, but not having the key means the door will stay shut.
Three ways to say the same thing
The sentences 'Only members may enter', 'Members alone may enter' and 'Nobody may enter unless he is a member' all say that membership is required. In each of them you can safely say that a person who entered is a member, and that a person who is not a member did not enter. In none of them can you say that a member will enter, because the statement tells you who is allowed, not who will actually come. Read the sentence for what it needs, and then check whether the conclusion asks for more than that.
Worked example 1
Statement: Only passengers with a valid ticket are allowed on the platform. Rani is on the platform. I. Rani has a valid ticket. II. Every passenger with a ticket is on the platform. Rani is on the platform, so she satisfies the requirement, and I follows. Having a ticket does not force a passenger to come to the platform, so II does not follow. Only I follows.
Worked example 2
Statement: Students cannot appear in the final test unless they have submitted the project. Seema has not submitted the project. I. Seema cannot appear in the final test. II. Everyone who has submitted the project will appear in the test. Seema lacks the key, so she cannot appear, and I follows. II confuses a requirement with a guarantee. Only I follows.
Worked example 3
Statement: The library lends books only if the member has a card. Rina has a card. I. The library will lend Rina a book. II. Members without a card cannot borrow books. Having a card is required, not sufficient, so I does not follow. II is the requirement itself, so it follows. Only II follows.
'Only if' and 'cannot unless' name something that is needed. Lacking it blocks the result, but having it does not guarantee the result.
Key takeaways
- A requirement blocks those who lack it; it does not guarantee those who have it.
- Safe conclusions: someone who got the result met the requirement; someone who lacks it did not get the result.
- Unsafe conclusions: everyone who meets the requirement gets the result.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: Entry to the hall is allowed only with an invitation. Kiran has an invitation. I. Kiran is allowed to enter. II. People without an invitation are not allowed to enter.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: B. The statement makes an invitation a requirement. People without one cannot enter, so II follows. It does not say that everyone with an invitation will be allowed in, so I does not follow.
-
2. Statement: Players cannot join the match unless they wear a helmet. Deepak is not wearing a helmet. I. Deepak cannot join the match. II. Players who wear helmets will always win.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: A. Deepak lacks the requirement, so he cannot join: I follows. Winning is not mentioned, so II does not follow.
-
3. Statement: The machine starts only if the button is pressed. The machine started. I. The button was pressed. II. The machine does not start without the button being pressed.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. The machine started, so the requirement was met: I follows. II restates the requirement, so it follows too.
-
4. Statement: The club admits only members. Tarun is a member. I. Tarun is admitted to the club. II. Non-members are admitted to the club.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Being a member is only a requirement, so I does not follow. II contradicts the statement. Neither follows.
-
5. What does the statement 'The shop opens only if the power is on' tell us?
- Power is enough for the shop to open
- The shop opens whenever the power is on
- Power is needed for the shop to open
- The shop stays closed when the power is on
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Only if' names a requirement. Without power the shop cannot open, but power alone is not said to be enough.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.