- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
If-then statements: what follows and what does not
Learn the two safe conclusions from an 'if ... then' statement and the two common mistakes, using simple everyday examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statements such as 'If it rains, the match will be cancelled' appear often in conclusion questions. They look easy, yet many wrong answers come from them, because people reverse the statement without noticing. There are exactly two safe conclusions from an 'if-then' statement, and two tempting but unsafe ones. Learn them once and you will not lose these marks again.
Four moves from one statement
Take the statement: If it rains, the match is cancelled. Call 'it rains' P and 'the match is cancelled' Q.
| Move | In words | Safe? |
|---|---|---|
| P is true, so Q is true | It rained, so the match was cancelled | Yes |
| Q is false, so P is false | The match was not cancelled, so it did not rain | Yes |
| Q is true, so P is true | The match was cancelled, so it rained | No |
| P is false, so Q is false | It did not rain, so the match was not cancelled | No |
The third move is unsafe because the match may have been cancelled for another reason, such as a strike or a holiday. The fourth is unsafe for the same reason: even without rain, something else may cancel the match.
Why the wrong moves feel right
In daily life 'if' often hides the word 'only'. When someone says 'If you finish your homework, you may play', a child hears that playing is possible only after homework. But a conclusion question uses the words exactly as written. The statement says that finishing homework is enough to be allowed to play. It does not say that nobody else is allowed to play. In the exam, read 'if' as a one-way door: you can walk from P to Q, but you cannot walk back from Q to P.
- Say the statement aloud as 'P is enough for Q'.
- Ask whether the conclusion starts from P (safe) or from Q (not safe), unless it denies Q.
- Think of one other reason that could produce Q; if you can, the reverse move is unsafe.
Worked example 1
Statement: If a student scores 40 marks or more, the student passes. Ravi scored 45. I. Ravi passes. II. Meena, who scored 35, fails. Ravi's score satisfies the 'if' part, so I follows. The statement says nothing about those who score below 40, so II does not follow. Only I follows.
Worked example 2
Statement: If the alarm rings, the guard comes. The guard did not come. I. The alarm did not ring. II. The guard comes only when the alarm rings. If the alarm had rung, the guard would have come. He did not come, so the alarm did not ring, and I follows. II reverses the statement, since the guard may come for other reasons. Only I follows.
Worked example 3
Statement: If it is Sunday, the office is closed. Today is Monday. I. The office is open today. II. Today is not Sunday. Monday is not Sunday, so II follows. But the office may be closed on Monday for another reason, so I does not follow. Only II follows.
From 'if P then Q' you may say: P true so Q true; Q false so P false. You may not say: Q true so P true; P false so Q false.
Key takeaways
- Two safe moves: confirm the 'if' part, or deny the 'then' part.
- Two unsafe moves: confirm the 'then' part, or deny the 'if' part.
- Look for other reasons that could produce the same result.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: If a train is late, passengers miss the connection. The train was late. I. Passengers missed the connection. II. The train is always late.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: A. The 'if' part is true, so the 'then' part follows: I follows. 'Always late' is not given, so II does not follow.
-
2. Statement: If it rains, the match is cancelled. The match was not cancelled. I. It rained. II. It did not rain.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: B. The 'then' part is false, so the 'if' part must be false: it did not rain. So II follows and I does not.
-
3. Statement: If the shop sells an item, it records the sale. The shop sold a pen. I. The sale of the pen was recorded. II. The shop sold an item.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. A pen is an item, so the 'if' part is true and I follows. II also follows, since a pen is an item and the shop sold it.
-
4. Statement: If the tank is full, the pump stops. The pump stopped. I. The tank is full. II. The tank is empty.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Confirming the 'then' part does not prove the 'if' part, so I does not follow. Nothing suggests that the tank is empty, so II does not follow either.
-
5. Which conclusion is valid from 'If P then Q'?
- If Q is false, then P is false
- If Q is true, then P is true
- If P is false, then Q is false
- If P is false, then Q is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Denying the 'then' part denies the 'if' part. The other three moves do not follow from 'if P then Q'.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.