• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Two conclusions and the either-or case

Judge two conclusions together, and recognise the case where neither follows alone but one of them must be true.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most questions give two conclusions, I and II. You judge each separately first. Then, only if neither follows, you check for the either-or case: two conclusions about the same thing that are opposites, so that exactly one of them must be true.

Four possible answers

  • Only I follows.
  • Only II follows.
  • Both follow.
  • Neither follows.
  • Either I or II follows (the fifth option in many papers).

The either-or rule

Either-or applies if: (1) neither conclusion follows alone; (2) both are about the same subject and the same property; (3) one conclusion is the exact opposite of the other, so that one of them has to be true (for example, 'some are' and 'none are').

Either-or applies if

  • Neither follows alone
  • Same subject, same property
  • Exact opposites One of them has to be true.
    • 'Some are' and 'none are'

Worked examples

Example 1. Statement: The committee has 10 members. Conclusion I: Some members of the committee are women. Conclusion II: No member of the committee is a woman. The statement says nothing about gender, so neither follows alone. They are opposites about the same group, so either I or II follows.

Example 2. Statement: A new highway will be built between two cities. Conclusion I: The travel time between the two cities will reduce. Conclusion II: The highway will be free of cost. Conclusion I may seem likely, but the statement does not say that travel time will reduce; it only says a highway will be built. Neither follows. They are not opposites, so the answer is neither follows.

Either-or or neither?

  • Opposites on the same group
    • Example 1: some members are women; no member is a woman
    • Neither follows alone
    • Either I or II follows
  • Not opposites
    • Example 2: travel time will reduce; the highway will be free
    • Neither follows alone
    • Neither follows

Example 3. Statement: All students must attend the seminar. Conclusion I: A student who skips the seminar breaks the rule. Conclusion II: Teachers need not attend. Conclusion I follows. Conclusion II goes beyond the statement. Only I follows.

Judge I and II one at a time. Use either-or only when neither follows and they are true opposites on the same topic.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Judge each conclusion alone first.
  • Either-or needs opposite conclusions on the same topic.
  • Likely is not the same as follows.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statement: A cricket team has 11 players. Conclusions: I. Some players in the team are left-handed. II. No player in the team is left-handed.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Either I or II follows
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The statement says nothing about left-handed players, so neither follows alone. Both are about the same group and property, and 'some are' and 'none are' are opposites, so one must be true: either I or II.

  2. 2. Statement: A new library is opening in the town. Conclusions: I. Everyone in the town will read more. II. Membership of the library will be free.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Either I or II follows
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Neither conclusion is stated. They are about different things (reading habits and fees), so they are not opposites and the either-or case does not apply. Neither follows.

  3. 3. Statement: Students who score above 80 receive a certificate. Conclusions: I. A student who scored 70 does not receive a certificate. II. A student who scored 85 receives a certificate.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 85 is above 80, so II follows. The statement does not say that ONLY those above 80 get a certificate, so I does not follow.

  4. 4. Which of these is NOT a condition for answering 'either I or II follows'?

    1. Both conclusions follow from the statement on their own
    2. Neither conclusion follows on its own
    3. Both conclusions are about the same subject and property
    4. One conclusion is the exact opposite of the other
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Either-or is used only when NEITHER conclusion follows alone, both are about the same thing, and they are opposites so that one must be true. If a conclusion follows on its own, judge it normally.

  5. 5. Statement: All students must attend the morning assembly. Conclusions: I. A student who misses the assembly breaks the rule. II. Some students must attend the morning assembly.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both follow
    4. Neither follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. I is a direct consequence of the rule. 'All' implies 'some', so II follows too. Both follow.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery