Does it follow?
- Read the statement Note exactly what it says.
- Read the conclusion Is it definitely true, given only the statement?
- Adds, reverses or goes beyond? Then it does not follow.
- Direct consequence or restatement? Then it follows.
| Kind | Example reaction |
|---|---|
| Directly supported by the statement | Follows |
| Goes beyond the statement (adds a new fact or cause) | Does not follow |
| Contradicts the statement | Does not follow |
Regular exercise improves health
-
I: Exercise is beneficial for health
- Restates the statement
- Follows
-
II: Will never fall ill
- 'Never' is far stronger than 'improves'
- Does not follow
A conclusion follows only if the statement alone supports it. Do not add facts from outside.
- A conclusion must be supported by the statement alone.
- Adding facts, causes or extremes makes a conclusion fail.
- A restatement or direct consequence follows.