- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Either-or conclusions
Decide when two conclusions form a complete pair so that one must be true even though neither follows alone.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
When a statement leaves an outcome open, two conclusions may cover every possibility, like 'will' and 'will not'. Neither follows alone, but one of them must be true. Then the answer is 'either I or II follows'.
Conditions for either-or
- Neither conclusion follows from the statement alone.
- The two conclusions are about the same thing.
- Together they cover every possibility, so one of them must be true.
Worked example 1
Statement: Rohan may attend the meeting tomorrow. I. Rohan will attend the meeting. II. Rohan will not attend the meeting. The statement leaves both open, so neither follows alone. Rohan either attends or does not, so either I or II follows.
Worked example 2
Statement: The exam result will be declared next week. I. All candidates will pass. II. No candidate will pass. These are not a complete pair, because some candidates may pass and some may fail. Neither follows.
Either-or needs a complete pair. If a middle case exists, it is 'neither'.
Key takeaways: test whether the pair is complete. If a third case exists, neither follows.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: Meena may pass the exam. Conclusions: I. Meena will pass the exam. II. Meena will not pass the exam.
- Either I or II follows
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: A. 'May' leaves both outcomes open, so neither follows alone. 'Will pass' and 'will not pass' cover every possibility, so one must be true: either I or II follows.
-
2. Statement: The exam result will be declared next week. Conclusions: I. All candidates will pass. II. No candidate will pass.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Neither I nor II follows
- Either I or II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. This pair is not complete: some candidates may pass and some may fail. Neither conclusion is certain and one of them need not be true, so neither follows.
-
3. Statement: The train may be late today. Conclusions: I. The train will be late today. II. The train will arrive on time today.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Neither I nor II follows
- Either I or II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. The train could also arrive early, so the two conclusions do not cover every possibility. Neither is certain, so neither follows.
-
4. Statement: A coin is tossed once. Conclusions: I. It will show heads. II. It will show tails.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Neither I nor II follows
- Either I or II follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Neither outcome is certain, but heads and tails are the only two outcomes of one toss, so one must be true: either I or II follows.
-
5. Which pair of conclusions can give the answer 'either I or II follows'?
- I. All candidates will pass. II. No candidate will pass.
- I. The shop will open tomorrow. II. The shop will not open tomorrow.
- I. It will rain tomorrow. II. It will be sunny tomorrow.
- I. Ravi will come by bus. II. Ravi will come by train.
Show answer
Answer: B. Either-or needs a complete pair about the same thing. 'Will open' and 'will not open' cover every case. Each other pair leaves a middle case: some pass and some fail, a cloudy day without rain, or Ravi coming by car.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.