• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why conclusions fail: six families of wrong answers

Name the six families of wrong conclusion, so that you can reject most options in seconds and spend your time on the rest.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A wrong conclusion is rarely wrong in a new way. Almost every one belongs to one of six families. If you can name the family, you can reject the conclusion quickly, and you can often see why a tempting option is tempting. This lesson names the families, shows one example of each, and lets you practise.

The six families

FamilyWhat the conclusion doesExample: 'The library is closed today'
Added reasonGives a cause the statement does notIt is closed because of a holiday
PredictionSays what will happen laterIt will open tomorrow
Wider groupMoves from some to all, or from a sample to everyoneAll libraries are closed today
ReversalTurns the statement roundIf it is closed, there is a holiday
Outside knowledgeUses a fact the statement does not giveThe librarian is on leave
OpinionAdds a judgement such as best or shouldThe library should not close

Worked example 1

Statement: The town's water supply was cut for six hours yesterday. I. The town had no water supply for six hours yesterday. II. The town will face a water shortage soon. I restates the cut. II is a prediction. Only I follows.

Worked example 2

Statement: Many players in the team are from villages. I. Some players of the team are from villages. II. The team's success is due to the village players. 'Many' includes 'some', so I follows. II is an added reason: the statement says nothing about success or its cause. Only I follows.

Worked example 3

Statement: The new road reduced travel time from 60 minutes to 45 minutes. I. The new road is the best road in the city. II. Travel time fell by 15 minutes. 60 - 45 = 15, so II follows. I is an opinion and goes beyond the facts. Only II follows.

Worked example 4

Statement: The chief guest at the function was a famous cricketer. I. The function was a cricket match. II. A cricketer was present at the function. II restates the statement. I uses outside knowledge: a cricketer can attend many kinds of function. Only II follows.

Name the family: added reason, prediction, wider group, reversal, outside knowledge or opinion. Reject it, and keep only restatements and forced results.

A speed check for every conclusion

  • Does it contain because, due to or so that? If so, it adds a reason.
  • Does it contain will, soon or in future? If so, it predicts.
  • Does it contain all, every, always or never where the statement said some, many or most? If so, it widens the group.
  • Does it contain best, should or worst? If so, it is an opinion.

These four quick questions catch most wrong conclusions without any long thought. A conclusion that passes all four checks is not yet proved, but it is worth a careful second look, and it is usually a restatement or a calculation. In that case compare it word by word with the statement to confirm that it says no more than the statement does.

Key takeaways

  • Learn the six families by name.
  • Many wrong options belong to the first three.
  • A restatement or a forced calculation is the only kind of conclusion that can follow.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The statement says 'Many players in the team are from villages'. A conclusion says 'The team won because of the village players'. Which family of error is this?

    1. An added reason that the statement does not give
    2. A reversal of the statement's meaning
    3. A fact taken from outside knowledge
    4. A plain restatement of the statement
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The statement says nothing about winning or its cause. The conclusion adds a cause, so it belongs to the family of added reasons.

  2. 2. Statement: The new road reduced travel time from 60 minutes to 45 minutes. I. The new road is the best road. II. Travel time fell by 15 minutes.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 60 - 45 = 15, so II follows. 'Best' is an opinion, so I does not follow.

  3. 3. Statement: Many students of the school took part in the quiz. I. Some students of the school took part in the quiz. II. All students of the school took part in the quiz.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Many' includes 'some', so I follows. 'All' goes beyond 'many', so II does not follow.

  4. 4. Statement: The library is closed today. I. The library is closed because of a holiday. II. The librarian is absent.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The statement gives no reason for the closure. I adds a cause and II adds a fact from outside. Neither follows.

  5. 5. Statement: Out of 50 trees in the garden, 20 are mango trees. I. 30 trees in the garden are not mango trees. II. Mango trees are fewer than half of the trees.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 50 - 20 = 30, so I follows. Half of 50 is 25 and 20 is below it, so II follows. Both follow.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery