• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Problem set 1: announcements and policy statements

Practise conclusions on announcements, rules and policy decisions, accepting what the announcement says and rejecting predictions and extra facts.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Announcements and policy decisions are a common kind of statement: a council closes a bridge, a bank fixes its holidays, a railway adds trains. A conclusion follows from such a statement only if it repeats what is announced or is forced by it. This lesson gives a four-step routine and a problem set of five exam-style items, one of each kind of answer.

The four-step routine

  1. Restate the announcement in your own words, keeping its exact scope: who, what, when.
  2. Check each conclusion: is it the same as the announcement, or forced by it?
  3. Look for decoys: a prediction (will), a reason (because), a wider group (all), or an unrelated fact.
  4. Only if neither conclusion follows, check whether the pair is complementary (either-or).

Scope: the most common slip

Announcements have a scope, and most wrong conclusions step outside it. A rule for first-year students says nothing about second-year students. A closure on one Saturday says nothing about other Saturdays. A decision to run extra trains says nothing about how full they will be. When you read a conclusion, underline the group and the time it talks about, and then check that the announcement talks about the same group and the same time. If either has changed, the conclusion does not follow.

Problem set

Item 1. The municipal council has decided to close the old bridge for repairs for three months. I. Vehicles cannot use the old bridge during the repairs. II. The repairs will be completed in three months. A bridge closed for repairs cannot be used while closed, so I follows. The repairs may take longer than planned, so II is a prediction. Only I follows.

Item 2. The bank has announced that it will remain closed on the second Saturday of every month. I. The bank is open on all other Saturdays. II. The bank is closed on the second Saturday. II is the announcement itself. The statement does not say what happens on other Saturdays, so I does not follow. Only II follows.

Item 3. The railway has decided to run two extra trains between two cities during the festival week. I. More trains will run between the two cities during that week. II. All tickets will be sold out. Two extra trains means more trains, so I follows. II is a prediction. Only I follows.

Item 4. The committee will announce the winners of the contest next week. I. Some of the winners will be women. II. None of the winners will be women. The statement gives no information about the winners' gender, so neither follows alone. The two conclusions are complete opposites about the same group: either some are, or none are. Either I or II follows.

Item 5. The library has increased its fine for late return of books. I. Late returns will stop. II. All members were late earlier. I is a prediction, and II uses 'all' and goes beyond the statement. Neither follows.

Restate the announcement, accept what it says or forces, and reject predictions, reasons and wider groups.

Key takeaways

  • Keep the exact scope of the announcement: who, what and when.
  • A decision to do something does not tell you that it will succeed.
  • Use either-or only when the two conclusions are complete opposites.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statement: The college has made computer practicals compulsory for all first-year students. I. First-year students must attend computer practicals. II. Computer practicals will be easy.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: A. I is the rule itself. Difficulty is not mentioned, so II does not follow.

  2. 2. Statement: The post office will remain closed on public holidays. I. The post office is open on all other days. II. The post office is closed on a public holiday.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: B. II restates the announcement. The statement does not say what happens on other days, so I does not follow.

  3. 3. Statement: The city has banned smoking in all public parks. I. Smoking in a public park is not allowed. II. A person who smokes in a public park is breaking the rule.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. I is the ban itself. A person who smokes in a park does what is banned, so II follows too. Both follow.

  4. 4. Statement: The shop has reduced the price of rice by 10%. I. The shop's profit will fall. II. More customers will buy rice.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Both I and II follow
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both are predictions about the future. The statement says only that the price was reduced.

  5. 5. Statement: A new shop will open in the market next month. I. The shop will sell clothes. II. The shop will not sell clothes.

    1. Only I follows
    2. Only II follows
    3. Either I or II follows
    4. Neither I nor II follows
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The statement does not say what the shop will sell, so neither follows alone. The two conclusions are complete opposites about the same shop, so one of them must be true: either I or II follows.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery