- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Problem set 3: if-then and requirement statements
Practise the safe and unsafe moves on 'if', 'only' and 'cannot unless' statements, with a problem set that includes the reversal trap.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson trains the reflex that separates strong candidates from weak ones: when a statement says 'if' or 'only', check which direction the conclusion moves. The two safe moves are to confirm the 'if' part or to deny the 'then' part. Everything else is a trap. The problem set below uses each trap at least once.
Quick reference
| Statement form | Safe conclusion | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| If P then Q | P true so Q true; Q false so P false | Q true so P true; P false so Q false |
| Only those with X can do Y | Someone who did Y has X; someone without X cannot do Y | Everyone with X does Y |
| Cannot do Y unless X | Someone without X cannot do Y; someone who did Y has X | Everyone with X will do Y |
Problem set
Item 1. If the bell rings, the class begins. The bell rang. I. The class began. II. The class never begins without the bell. The 'if' part is true, so I follows. II reverses the statement. Only I follows.
Item 2. If a customer buys goods worth more than Rs 1,000, the shop gives a free bag. Mira bought goods worth Rs 800. I. Mira did not get a free bag. II. Mira did not buy goods worth more than Rs 1,000. II is a fact from the given figures, so it follows. The shop may give free bags for other reasons, so I does not follow. Only II follows.
Item 3. Only registered voters can vote. Gita voted. I. Gita is a registered voter. II. All registered voters voted. Gita voted, so she met the requirement: I follows. II is a guarantee the statement does not give. Only I follows.
Item 4. Employees cannot leave early unless the manager permits. Anil left early. I. The manager permitted Anil. II. Every employee left early. Anil left, so the requirement was met, and I follows. II is unrelated. Only I follows.
Item 5. If the power fails, the lights go out. The lights are out. I. The power failed. II. The power failure will last for hours. I confirms the 'then' part, which is unsafe, and II is a prediction. Neither follows.
Confirm the 'if' or deny the 'then'. Never confirm the 'then' and never deny the 'if'.
The extra fact
In most of these questions the statement has two parts: a general rule and a particular fact, such as 'Gita voted'. The rule alone usually supports no conclusion about Gita; the particular fact tells you which door of the rule you are standing at. Read the fact first, ask whether it confirms the 'if', denies the 'then', or does neither, and only then read the conclusions. When the fact does neither, the answer is almost always that nothing follows about the person.
A short method for any such question
- Mark the statement's condition as P and its result as Q.
- Mark the conclusion as starting from P or Q, and as true or false.
- Check the four moves against the quick reference.
- If the conclusion adds anything else, such as a time or a group, it does not follow.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement: If the shop opens early, it gets more customers. The shop did not open early. I. The shop did not get more customers. II. The shop is closed all day.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Denying the 'if' part proves nothing about the result, so I does not follow. Nothing suggests the shop is closed all day, so II does not follow.
-
2. Statement: Only those who hold a pass can enter the reading room. Mina entered the reading room. I. Mina holds a pass. II. Everyone who holds a pass entered.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: A. Mina entered, so she met the requirement: I follows. II is a guarantee that is not given.
-
3. Statement: If the exam is postponed, the students get extra time. The students did not get extra time. I. The exam was postponed. II. The exam was not postponed.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: B. The 'then' part is false, so the 'if' part is false: the exam was not postponed. So II follows and I does not.
-
4. Statement: Pupils cannot go on the trip unless their parents sign the form. Leela went on the trip. I. Leela's parents signed the form. II. Pupils whose parents did not sign the form did not go on the trip.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both I and II follow
- Neither I nor II follows
Show answer
Answer: C. Leela went, so the requirement was met: I follows. II restates the requirement, so it follows too. Both follow.
-
5. From 'If P then Q', and the fact that Q is true, what can be said about P?
- P must also be true
- Nothing definite follows about P
- P must be false
- P is true only when Q is false
Show answer
Answer: B. Confirming the 'then' part gives no information about the 'if' part, because Q may have other causes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.