A conclusion follows only if the statement alone makes it certain.
Key takeaways: use only the statement, accept direct implications, and reject added reasons and predictions.
Revision notes
The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".
Lesson 1
A conclusion follows only if the statement alone makes it certain.
Key takeaways: use only the statement, accept direct implications, and reject added reasons and predictions.
Lesson 2
| Word | What it needs |
|---|---|
| All, every, always, never | The statement must say so for every case |
| Some, at least one | The statement must give at least one case |
| Only | Limits the group; others are excluded |
| Most, many | More than 'some' but not 'all' |
Watch the quantity words. 'All' is never supported by 'some'.
Key takeaways: a strong word needs strong support, and a weak word is satisfied by one case.
Lesson 3
Either-or needs a complete pair. If a middle case exists, it is 'neither'.
Key takeaways: test whether the pair is complete. If a third case exists, neither follows.
Lesson 4
Overlap is at least (group 1 + group 2) minus the total.
Key takeaways: use the overlap formula and subtraction, and do not add facts the statement does not give.
Lesson 5
If the conclusion needs a 'because', a 'will' or a wider group, it does not follow.
Key takeaways: accept only what is stated or forced by arithmetic, and run the checklist on every conclusion.
Lesson 6
Restate the announcement, accept what it says or forces, and reject predictions, reasons and wider groups.
Lesson 7
Convert to counts, compare with half, and never speak for the people who are not in the group the figure describes.
Lesson 8
| Statement form | Safe conclusion | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| If P then Q | P true so Q true; Q false so P false | Q true so P true; P false so Q false |
| Only those with X can do Y | Someone who did Y has X; someone without X cannot do Y | Everyone with X does Y |
| Cannot do Y unless X | Someone without X cannot do Y; someone who did Y has X | Everyone with X will do Y |
Confirm the 'if' or deny the 'then'. Never confirm the 'then' and never deny the 'if'.
Lesson 9
| Family | What the conclusion does | Example: 'The library is closed today' |
|---|---|---|
| Added reason | Gives a cause the statement does not | It is closed because of a holiday |
| Prediction | Says what will happen later | It will open tomorrow |
| Wider group | Moves from some to all, or from a sample to everyone | All libraries are closed today |
| Reversal | Turns the statement round | If it is closed, there is a holiday |
| Outside knowledge | Uses a fact the statement does not give | The librarian is on leave |
| Opinion | Adds a judgement such as best or should | The library should not close |
Name the family: added reason, prediction, wider group, reversal, outside knowledge or opinion. Reject it, and keep only restatements and forced results.