• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Answering questions on The Dying Detective

Write clear answers in your own words to the kinds of comprehension questions the PSEB textbook asks on The Dying Detective, and prepare a short discussion about secrecy, friendship and justice.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Plan and write a short answer that uses evidence from the story.
  • Answer 'why' and 'how do you know' questions with a reason and a detail.
  • Speak for two or three minutes on a discussion topic linked to the story.

The PSEB textbook follows this story with many comprehension questions and one discussion topic. They test whether you can follow the plot, explain motives and judge the characters. This lesson shows a method and gives model answers to similar questions, written in fresh words.

A three-step method

Writing a short answer

  1. Find Locate the part of the story the question is about.
  2. Answer Give a direct answer in the first sentence.
  3. Support Add a reason or a detail from the story, in your own words.
Use the same three steps for every comprehension question.

Model answers

Frequently asked questions

What was Holmes's condition when Watson saw him?

Holmes looked close to death. His face was thin and hollow, his eyes were bright with fever, his cheeks were red and his hand kept twitching. He lay in bed without energy, in a dim and gloomy room.

Did Smith welcome Watson? How do you know?

No, not at first. Smith told his butler to say that he was not at home, and Watson had to push his way in. Only when Watson mentioned Holmes did Smith's manner change and he became eager to hear more.

Why did Watson not return with Smith?

Holmes had told him to come back before Smith, making any excuse. Watson pretended he had another appointment so that he could reach Holmes's room first and hide in the next room to hear what Smith said.

Did Smith go near Holmes? How do you know?

Yes. When Holmes asked for water, Smith gave it to him, so he must have been standing close to the bed. He was not afraid, because he knew the disease came from the spring in the box, not from touch.

Why did Holmes pretend to be ill?

He wanted Smith to believe he was dying, so that Smith would come to see him and, feeling safe, admit to killing his nephew and to sending the poisoned box. To look ill he fasted for three days, used make-up, kept the light dim and gave confused orders so that he would seem delirious.

Who arrested Smith, and on what charges?

Inspector Morton of Scotland Yard arrested him for the murder of his nephew Victor, and Holmes added the charge of attempting to murder Sherlock Holmes.

Worked example: improving a weak answer

Question: Why did Holmes not let Watson touch the ivory box? Weak answer: 'Because he hates his things being touched.' This repeats what Holmes said but misses the point. Better answer: Holmes said he hated having his things touched, but the real reason was that the box was the one Smith had sent. It contained a sharp spring carrying the deadly infection, so touching it could have harmed Watson. Watson, not knowing this, thought Holmes's mind was disturbed by illness. The better answer gives the surface reason, the real reason and Watson's reaction.

Preparing the discussion

The book asks you to discuss whether Holmes was justified in keeping his plan from Watson. Prepare like this: one opening sentence giving your view, two reasons, one point from the other side, and a closing sentence. Useful phrases: 'In my opinion...', 'On the other hand...', 'I agree with ... because...', 'Taking everything into account...'. You can also talk about related questions: Is it ever right to tell a lie for a good purpose? How should a friend respond when deceived for a good reason?

Points for and against, ready for a discussion.
For keeping the secretAgainst keeping the secret
Watson's true worry convinced Smith.Watson and Mrs Hudson suffered real fear and grief.
A doctor's examination would have exposed the act.Holmes insulted Watson's skill as a doctor.
It caught a murderer who might have killed again.Friends usually trust each other with the truth.

Direct answer first, then the proof from the story.

— Answer-writing tip

Key takeaways: Find the part of the story, answer directly, then support with a detail in your own words. For 'how do you know' questions, the detail is the proof. In a discussion, give your view, your reasons and one point from the other side.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which detail best proves that Smith did not welcome Watson at first?

    1. Smith had a bald head.
    2. Smith told his butler to say he was not at home.
    3. Smith lived at 13 Lower Burke Street.
    4. Smith smiled when he heard the story.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Telling the butler to say 'not at home' shows Smith did not want to see the visitor. The other details do not show his attitude to Watson's arrival.

  2. 2. Why was Smith not afraid to stand close to Holmes?

    1. He knew the illness came from the spring in his box, not from touch.
    2. He was wearing a mask.
    3. He had been cured of the disease before.
    4. Watson had told him Holmes was well.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Smith himself had arranged the infection through the box. He knew the illness did not spread by touch, so he could safely give Holmes water.

  3. 3. What is wrong with the answer 'Because he hates his things being touched' to the question about the ivory box?

    1. It is too long.
    2. It names the wrong character.
    3. It gives only Holmes's excuse, not the real reason that the box was dangerous.
    4. It uses reported speech.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The answer repeats Holmes's surface excuse. The real reason was that the box held Smith's infected spring, so the answer misses the key point.

  4. 4. In the three-step method, what comes right after finding the part of the story?

    1. Copying the paragraph from the book
    2. Writing a title
    3. Writing the moral
    4. Giving a direct answer in the first sentence
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The method is find, answer, support. After locating the part, you state the answer directly, then support it with a detail.

  5. 5. Which sentence is the best opening for a discussion on whether Holmes was right to hide his plan?

    1. Holmes lived in London.
    2. In my opinion, Holmes was right, because Watson's real worry was needed to fool Smith.
    3. The story has many characters.
    4. Smith was bald and frail.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A discussion should open with a clear view and a reason. The other sentences are facts that do not answer the question.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery