- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Dying Detective, part 1: Mrs Hudson's news and the locked door
Retell the first half of Arthur Conan Doyle's The Dying Detective in your own words: Mrs Hudson's visit, Holmes's frightening state, why he keeps Watson away and how he locks him in until six o'clock.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the story and who tells it.
- Retell the events from Mrs Hudson's visit to the locking of the door, in the right order.
- Describe how Holmes looks and behaves when Watson first sees him.
- Explain the reasons Holmes gives for not letting Watson come near him or treat him.
The Dying Detective is Lesson 4 of the PSEB Class 10 English Literature Book (Supplementary Reader). It is a simplified version of a Sherlock Holmes story by Arthur Conan Doyle (1859-1930), the British writer who created Sherlock Holmes, the most famous detective in fiction. The original story first appeared in 1913. Like most Holmes stories, it is told by Dr Watson, Holmes's friend and helper, who is himself a doctor. Because Watson tells the story, we know only what he sees and hears, and that is exactly why the ending surprises us as much as it surprises him.
The people in the first half
| Person | Who they are |
|---|---|
| Sherlock Holmes | The great detective, who seems to be dying of a rare disease. |
| Dr Watson | The narrator; Holmes's friend and assistant, and a doctor. |
| Mrs Hudson | Holmes's landlady, who looks after his house and is deeply worried about him. |
What happens, part by part
1. The landlady's news
Mrs Hudson comes to Watson in great distress. Holmes has been getting weaker for three days, and she fears he will not live through another day. He has refused to see a doctor. When she said she could bear it no longer and would fetch one, Holmes agreed only to Watson. On the drive back she tells Watson what little she knows: Holmes had been working on a case at Rotherhithe, an area near the river in London, and came home ill. He went to bed on Wednesday afternoon and has not eaten or drunk anything for three days. She did not dare to go against his wishes.
2. A frightening sight
It is a dim, foggy November day and the room is gloomy. Holmes's face is thin and hollow, his eyes shine with fever, his cheeks are red and his hand keeps jerking. He lies without energy. When Watson moves towards him, Holmes shouts at him to stand back. He says he has caught a deadly disease from Sumatra, an island in the East, and that it spreads by touch. Watson, as a loyal friend and a doctor, is not frightened and steps forward, but Holmes says he will talk only if Watson keeps his distance.
3. Holmes insults Watson's skill
Watson insists on examining and treating him. Holmes replies that he trusts Watson's friendship but not his medical knowledge: Watson is an ordinary general doctor, not an expert in this disease. Watson offers to bring the best specialists in London, such as Sir Jasper Meek or Penrose Fisher. Holmes groans and asks what Watson knows of strange Eastern illnesses with names Watson has never heard. Holmes claims he learnt about these diseases in his recent researches and caught the illness along the way. These words hurt Watson, but he still wants to help.
4. The locked door
When Watson turns to fetch another doctor, Dr Ainstree, the 'dying' man suddenly springs from the bed, locks the door and keeps the key. A moment later he is back in bed. He tells Watson it is four o'clock and that he must stay until six; after that Watson may fetch a doctor of Holmes's choosing. Watson calls this madness, but he has no choice. Notice how surprising this is: a man who is too weak to eat can still move fast enough to lock a door. This is the first clue that all is not as it seems.
Part 1 in five steps
- Bad news Mrs Hudson says Holmes is dying and will see only Watson.
- Shock Watson finds Holmes thin, feverish and twitching.
- Warning Holmes says the Eastern disease spreads by touch; Watson must keep back.
- Insult Holmes doubts Watson's medical skill and refuses London's experts.
- Trapped Holmes locks the door and makes Watson wait until six.
Worked example 1: why did Mrs Hudson go to Watson?
Think it through: Mrs Hudson wanted a doctor; Holmes refused every doctor; the only doctor he would accept was Watson. So the answer in your own words: Mrs Hudson, Holmes's landlady, went to Watson because Holmes was seriously ill, had eaten nothing for three days and would allow no doctor except Watson to be called.
Worked example 2: why did Holmes keep Watson away?
At this point in the story Holmes gives two reasons: the disease spreads by touch, so Watson must stay back for his own safety; and Watson is not a specialist in Eastern diseases. A good answer gives both reasons. When you have read the ending, you can add the real reason: a doctor examining him closely would have discovered that he was not ill at all.
In a story told by one character, the reader knows only what the narrator knows. Watson believes Holmes is dying, so we believe it too.
Key takeaways: Watson tells the story. Holmes appears to be dying of an Eastern disease that he says spreads by touch. He refuses to be examined, insults Watson's skill, and locks Watson in the room from four to six o'clock. Small details, such as his sudden quick movement to the door, hint that something is being hidden.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who tells the story of The Dying Detective?
- Sherlock Holmes
- Dr Watson
- Mrs Hudson
- Inspector Morton
Show answer
Answer: B. The story uses 'I' for Watson: he hears the news from Mrs Hudson, sees Holmes and reports what happens. So Watson is the narrator.
-
2. According to Mrs Hudson, where had Holmes been working before he fell ill?
- In Sumatra
- At Scotland Yard
- At Lower Burke Street
- On a case at Rotherhithe, near the river
Show answer
Answer: D. Mrs Hudson says he had been working on a case down at Rotherhithe, near the river, and came back ill. Sumatra is where he says the disease comes from, not where he worked.
-
3. Why does Holmes first tell Watson to stand back?
- He says the disease is deadly and spreads by touch.
- He is angry that Watson came late.
- He does not want Watson to see his papers.
- He thinks Watson has brought the police.
Show answer
Answer: A. Holmes says the disease from Sumatra is deadly and contagious by touch, so Watson must keep away for his own sake.
-
4. What does Holmes say about Watson as a doctor?
- That he is the best doctor in London
- That he has never practised medicine
- That he is a general practitioner, not a specialist in this disease
- That he is too young to treat anyone
Show answer
Answer: C. Holmes trusts Watson's friendship but says facts are facts: Watson is a general doctor and not an expert in this rare Eastern disease.
-
5. What surprising thing does Holmes do when Watson goes towards the door to fetch Dr Ainstree?
- He faints on the floor.
- He jumps up, locks the door and keeps the key.
- He calls Mrs Hudson for help.
- He writes a letter to Dr Ainstree.
Show answer
Answer: B. The 'dying' man quickly locks the door and holds the key, then returns to bed and tells Watson to wait until six. His speed is an early hint that he is not as weak as he seems.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.