• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Characters and themes in The Dying Detective

Describe Holmes, Watson, Culverton Smith, Mrs Hudson and Inspector Morton with evidence from the story, and explain its main themes: deception for justice, friendship and trust, and greed that leads to murder.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Give two qualities of each main character with evidence from the story.
  • Explain the main themes in your own words.
  • Discuss whether Holmes was right to hide his plan from Watson.

Questions on this story often ask what kind of person a character is, or whether a character did the right thing. A strong answer names a quality and then proves it with something the character did or said. This lesson gives you that evidence for each person in the story.

Sherlock Holmes

  • Brilliant planner: every detail, from the dim light to the hidden witness, is arranged in advance.
  • Great actor: he fasts for three days and plays a feverish, wandering man so well that a doctor is fooled.
  • Brave and determined: he risks his health and puts himself face to face with a murderer to get proof.
  • Secretive and sometimes rude: he hurts Watson's feelings, though he apologises at the end.

Dr Watson

  • Loyal and caring: he rushes to Holmes at once and is not afraid of catching the disease.
  • Obedient: he follows even strange orders, such as moving coins between pockets.
  • Professional: as a doctor he wants to examine and treat his patient properly.
  • Honest and trusting: his real worry is what convinces Smith, because he believes every word Holmes says.

Culverton Smith

  • Cruel and cold: he says it does not matter to him how his nephew died.
  • Cunning: he uses his knowledge of Eastern diseases to kill in a way that looks natural.
  • Proud and careless: sure that Holmes is dying, he boasts about his crimes and walks into the trap.

Mrs Hudson and Inspector Morton

Mrs Hudson is caring and anxious: she trembles and cries outside the door, yet she does not dare to disobey Holmes. Inspector Morton of Scotland Yard has a small but important part. He waits near the house without his uniform, so as not to warn Smith, and comes in on the signal to make the arrest.

Two clever men: Holmes and Smith

  • Holmes
    • Uses cleverness to uncover a crime
    • Deceives in order to get justice
    • Risks himself to protect others
    • Apologises to his friend
  • Culverton Smith
    • Uses cleverness to commit a crime
    • Deceives in order to escape justice
    • Harms others to protect himself
    • Shows no regret for his nephew
Both are clever, but they use their cleverness for opposite ends.

Themes

The main ideas of the story.
ThemeHow the story shows it
Deception used for justiceHolmes lies about being ill, but only to make a murderer confess.
Friendship and trustWatson stays loyal even when insulted; Holmes trusts him to play his part without knowing it.
Appearance and realityA 'dying' man is healthy; a polite visitor is a killer; a small box is a weapon.
Greed and crimeSmith killed his nephew and tried to silence Holmes to avoid prison.
Pride before a fallSmith's boasting, because he thinks no one is listening, destroys him.

Worked example: was Holmes justified in hiding his plan from Watson?

This is the book's discussion question, and there are two sides. Yes: Watson is an honest man and a poor actor. Only his real fear could convince Smith that Holmes was dying; if he had known the truth, his face or words might have given the game away. Also, a doctor examining Holmes would have exposed the trick. No: Holmes made his closest friend and his landlady suffer real grief for days, and insulted Watson's skill. A balanced answer gives both sides and then your view, for example: the plan was justified because it caught a murderer and saved lives, but Holmes was right to apologise for the pain he caused.

Worked example: should Holmes have spoken so rudely to Watson?

Plan the answer: state your view, give the reason Holmes himself gives, and add a judgement. For instance: Holmes's words were unkind and hurt a loyal friend, but they had a purpose, because they kept Watson from examining him and made Watson go for Smith. Holmes knew this was hurtful, which is why he says sorry at the end.

Name the quality, then prove it: 'Watson is loyal: he rushes to Holmes without fear of the disease.'

— Answer-writing tip

Key takeaways: Holmes is a brilliant, brave planner who deceives for a good purpose; Watson is loyal, caring and trusting; Smith is a cunning, cold murderer undone by pride. The story shows that appearances deceive and that friendship can survive hard tests.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which quality of Watson is shown when he is ready to go near Holmes despite the warning about a contagious disease?

    1. Greed
    2. Cowardice
    3. Laziness
    4. Loyalty and courage
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Watson is told the disease spreads by touch, yet he still steps forward to help. That shows loyalty to his friend and courage.

  2. 2. Why was Watson's real worry useful to Holmes's plan?

    1. It made Mrs Hudson call the police.
    2. It convinced Smith that Holmes really was dying.
    3. It helped Watson find the ivory box.
    4. It made Dr Ainstree come quickly.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Smith had to believe Holmes was dying to come and boast. Watson's honest distress made his message believable.

  3. 3. Which theme is shown by a 'dying' man who is healthy and a small box that is a weapon?

    1. Love of nature
    2. City and village life
    3. Appearance and reality
    4. Hard work brings success
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Things in the story are not what they seem: Holmes looks ill but is well, and an innocent-looking box hides a deadly spring. That is the theme of appearance versus reality.

  4. 4. What leads to Culverton Smith's downfall?

    1. His pride: he boasts about his crimes, sure that Holmes will die
    2. His kindness to Watson
    3. His fear of Inspector Morton
    4. His illness from Sumatra
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Believing Holmes is dying and no one else is listening, Smith openly admits the murder and the box. His overconfidence gives Holmes the proof.

  5. 5. Which is the best reason Holmes could give for not telling Watson the plan?

    1. Watson was too busy to listen.
    2. Holmes wanted to make fun of doctors.
    3. Watson might have given the secret away by his face or words.
    4. Mrs Hudson had asked him not to.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Holmes says he did not want Watson to know he was not ill. An honest man who knows the truth may fail to look worried, and Smith might then suspect a trap.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery