• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Dying Detective, part 2: Culverton Smith walks into the trap

Retell the second half of the story: Holmes's strange instructions, Watson's visit to Culverton Smith, Smith's confession beside the 'dying' man, the arrest by Inspector Morton and Holmes's explanation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Retell the events from six o'clock to the arrest of Culverton Smith, in order.
  • Explain each of Holmes's odd instructions once the truth is known.
  • Say who Culverton Smith and Victor Smith were and how the crime was done.
  • Explain how Holmes trapped Smith into confessing.

In the first half, Holmes seems to be dying and behaving strangely. In the second half every strange detail turns out to be part of a clever plan. As you read this summary, notice how the clues from part 1 are explained one by one at the end.

What happens, part by part

5. The ivory box

While he waits, Watson cannot read, so he walks round the room looking at the pictures. On the mantelpiece he picks up a small black and white ivory box with a sliding lid. Holmes gives a terrible cry and orders him to put it down at once, saying he hates having his things touched. Watson decides that the illness has affected Holmes's mind and sits quietly until six.

6. Strange instructions

At six Holmes gives a list of odd orders. Watson must put his half-crowns (old British coins) in his watch-pocket and the rest of his change in his trouser pocket. He must light the gas lamp but keep it only half on, put letters and papers within Holmes's reach, and place the ivory box on the table, sliding its lid open a little with tongs. Then he must fetch Mr Culverton Smith of 13 Lower Burke Street. Holmes explains that Smith is not a doctor but a planter from Sumatra, now in London, who knows this disease. Watson must tell him that Holmes is dying, beg him to come, and then return before him, making some excuse not to come with him.

7. Watson visits Smith

Outside, Mrs Hudson is trembling and crying. While Watson waits for a cab, he meets Inspector Morton of Scotland Yard, the London police, who is not in uniform and asks how Holmes is. At Smith's house Watson hears Smith tell the butler to say he is not at home, so Watson pushes his way in. Smith is a frail, bald man. At first he is unwelcoming, but the mention of Holmes changes him at once. He asks how Holmes is and how he caught the disease. Watson tells him everything. Smith smiles and agrees to come. Watson pretends he has another appointment and hurries back ahead of him. Holmes praises him and sends him to hide silently in the next room.

8. The confession

From his hiding place Watson hears Smith arrive. Holmes, in a weak whisper, begs Smith to cure him. Smith says the symptoms are the same as those of Victor, his nephew, a strong young man who died on the fourth day. Holmes says he knows Smith killed Victor and offers to forget it if Smith cures him. Smith, sure that Holmes is dying, mocks him and asks whether a box came by post on Wednesday. Holmes says yes: it had a sharp spring inside that drew blood. Smith then admits everything. The spring carried the infection, Holmes had found out too much about Victor's death, and Smith will now pocket the box, the last piece of evidence.

9. The trap closes

Holmes, in his normal voice, asks Smith to turn up the gas. Smith does so, to watch him die more clearly, and then sees that something is wrong. Holmes calls it successful acting. Inspector Morton enters and arrests Smith for murder; Holmes laughingly adds the attempted murder of Sherlock Holmes. There is a struggle, a cry of pain and the click of handcuffs.

10. Holmes explains

Holmes apologises to Watson for being rude about his skill. It was needed to get Smith to the house, and he did not want Watson to know he was not ill. Three days of fasting and make-up created his sick look. Turning up the gas was the signal for Morton to come in. The talk about coins was only to make him seem delirious. Smith killed his nephew and tried to kill Holmes the same way to escape prison. The story ends with Holmes wanting a meal and thanking Watson.

How the trap worked

  1. The box arrives Smith posts a box with an infected spring; Holmes sees the danger and avoids harm.
  2. The act Holmes fasts, uses make-up and pretends to be dying.
  3. The messenger A truly worried Watson convinces Smith that Holmes is dying.
  4. The confession Smith, thinking Holmes will die, boasts of both crimes while Watson listens.
  5. The signal The gas is turned up; Morton enters and arrests Smith.
Holmes's plan, from the poisoned box to the arrest.

Clues and their meanings

Each strange detail of part 1 has a reason.
ClueWhat it really meant
Keep back, do not examine meA doctor's close look would show he was not ill.
Do not touch the ivory boxIt was Smith's deadly box with the infected spring.
Wait until sixSmith would be at home in his study only after six.
Coins in different pocketsNonsense orders to seem delirious.
Gas lamp half onDim light hid the make-up; turning it up was the signal.
Return before SmithWatson had to be hidden before Smith arrived to hear the confession.

Worked example: why did Holmes ask Smith to turn up the gas?

Link two details: Inspector Morton was waiting outside, and Holmes explains at the end that the brighter light was a signal. So the answer: Holmes asked Smith to turn up the gas because it was the agreed signal for Inspector Morton to come in and arrest Smith once he had confessed.

A good detective story plants clues early and explains them at the end. Reread part 1 after part 2 and every clue makes sense.

— Reading tip

Key takeaways: Culverton Smith, a planter who knows Eastern diseases, had killed his nephew Victor and sent Holmes a box with an infected spring. Holmes pretended to be dying so that Smith would come and confess while Watson listened. The gas signal brought in Inspector Morton, who arrested Smith.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who was Culverton Smith, according to Holmes?

    1. A famous London specialist
    2. A police officer from Scotland Yard
    3. A planter from Sumatra who knew about the disease
    4. Holmes's landlord
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Holmes says Smith is not a medical man but a planter who lives in Sumatra, now visiting London, and who knows about this disease.

  2. 2. Why did Holmes tell Watson to come back before Smith?

    1. So that Watson could hide and hear Smith's confession
    2. So that Watson could cook a meal
    3. So that Watson could fetch Dr Ainstree
    4. So that Watson could call Mrs Hudson's family
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Holmes sent Watson to the next room and told him to keep silent. Watson had to be there before Smith so he could secretly witness what Smith said.

  3. 3. Who was Victor, and what happened to him?

    1. Holmes's brother, who went to Sumatra
    2. Smith's butler, who ran away
    3. A sailor who brought the disease
    4. Smith's nephew, who died on the fourth day of the same illness
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Smith says the symptoms match those of Victor, his nephew, a strong young man who was dead on the fourth day. Holmes accuses Smith of killing him.

  4. 4. How had Smith tried to infect Holmes?

    1. By poisoning his water
    2. By posting him a box with a sharp infected spring inside
    3. By sending Chinese sailors to his house
    4. By touching him at Rotherhithe
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Smith asks about a box that came by post on Wednesday. It held a sharp spring that drew blood; Smith admits it carried the infection.

  5. 5. What, according to Holmes, made him look so ill?

    1. Three days of fasting and make-up
    2. A real fever from Sumatra
    3. The fog of the November day
    4. Medicine given by Watson
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Holmes explains that three days without food or drink, together with make-up, did the trick. He was never ill.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery