Revision notes

Literature Book Lesson 4 The Dying Detective: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

The Dying Detective, part 1: Mrs Hudson's news and the locked door

Who is who at the start of the story.
PersonWho they are
Sherlock HolmesThe great detective, who seems to be dying of a rare disease.
Dr WatsonThe narrator; Holmes's friend and assistant, and a doctor.
Mrs HudsonHolmes's landlady, who looks after his house and is deeply worried about him.

Part 1 in five steps

  1. Bad news Mrs Hudson says Holmes is dying and will see only Watson.
  2. Shock Watson finds Holmes thin, feverish and twitching.
  3. Warning Holmes says the Eastern disease spreads by touch; Watson must keep back.
  4. Insult Holmes doubts Watson's medical skill and refuses London's experts.
  5. Trapped Holmes locks the door and makes Watson wait until six.
The events from Mrs Hudson's visit to the locked door.

In a story told by one character, the reader knows only what the narrator knows. Watson believes Holmes is dying, so we believe it too.

— Reading tip

Key takeaways: Watson tells the story. Holmes appears to be dying of an Eastern disease that he says spreads by touch. He refuses to be examined, insults Watson's skill, and locks Watson in the room from four to six o'clock. Small details, such as his sudden quick movement to the door, hint that something is being hidden.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Dying Detective, part 2: Culverton Smith walks into the trap

How the trap worked

  1. The box arrives Smith posts a box with an infected spring; Holmes sees the danger and avoids harm.
  2. The act Holmes fasts, uses make-up and pretends to be dying.
  3. The messenger A truly worried Watson convinces Smith that Holmes is dying.
  4. The confession Smith, thinking Holmes will die, boasts of both crimes while Watson listens.
  5. The signal The gas is turned up; Morton enters and arrests Smith.
Holmes's plan, from the poisoned box to the arrest.
Each strange detail of part 1 has a reason.
ClueWhat it really meant
Keep back, do not examine meA doctor's close look would show he was not ill.
Do not touch the ivory boxIt was Smith's deadly box with the infected spring.
Wait until sixSmith would be at home in his study only after six.
Coins in different pocketsNonsense orders to seem delirious.
Gas lamp half onDim light hid the make-up; turning it up was the signal.
Return before SmithWatson had to be hidden before Smith arrived to hear the confession.

A good detective story plants clues early and explains them at the end. Reread part 1 after part 2 and every clue makes sense.

— Reading tip

Key takeaways: Culverton Smith, a planter who knows Eastern diseases, had killed his nephew Victor and sent Holmes a box with an infected spring. Holmes pretended to be dying so that Smith would come and confess while Watson listened. The gas signal brought in Inspector Morton, who arrested Smith.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Characters and themes in The Dying Detective

Two clever men: Holmes and Smith

  • Holmes
    • Uses cleverness to uncover a crime
    • Deceives in order to get justice
    • Risks himself to protect others
    • Apologises to his friend
  • Culverton Smith
    • Uses cleverness to commit a crime
    • Deceives in order to escape justice
    • Harms others to protect himself
    • Shows no regret for his nephew
Both are clever, but they use their cleverness for opposite ends.
The main ideas of the story.
ThemeHow the story shows it
Deception used for justiceHolmes lies about being ill, but only to make a murderer confess.
Friendship and trustWatson stays loyal even when insulted; Holmes trusts him to play his part without knowing it.
Appearance and realityA 'dying' man is healthy; a polite visitor is a killer; a small box is a weapon.
Greed and crimeSmith killed his nephew and tried to silence Holmes to avoid prison.
Pride before a fallSmith's boasting, because he thinks no one is listening, destroys him.

Name the quality, then prove it: 'Watson is loyal: he rushes to Holmes without fear of the disease.'

— Answer-writing tip

Key takeaways: Holmes is a brilliant, brave planner who deceives for a good purpose; Watson is loyal, caring and trusting; Smith is a cunning, cold murderer undone by pride. The story shows that appearances deceive and that friendship can survive hard tests.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Words from The Dying Detective: glossary, sickness words and speech

Meanings follow the book's glossary; the examples are our own.
WordMeaningOur own example
horrifiedshocked and frightenedWe were horrified to see the bridge washed away.
gauntvery thin, usually from illness or hungerAfter the long fever, Grandpa looked gaunt.
flushedred in the faceHer cheeks were flushed after the race.
twitcha sudden quick movementThe cat's tail gave a twitch as the bird landed.
listlesslacking energy or interestThe heat made the whole class listless.
contagiousspreading easily from one person to anotherChickenpox is contagious, so Ravi stayed home.
advancingmoving forwardThe advancing floodwater reached the fields.
tongsa tool with two arms for picking things upUse the tongs to lift the hot roti.
deliriousunable to think or speak clearly, often because of feverWith a high fever, the child became delirious and talked nonsense.
coincidencetwo things happening together by chanceBy coincidence, my cousin and I wore the same shirt.
symptomschanges in the body that show a disease is presentFever and cough are common symptoms of flu.
dreadfulvery bad or unpleasantThere was a dreadful smell from the drain.

Words around the story

  • Illness
    • symptoms
    • fever
    • contagious
    • delirious
    • specialist
    • general practitioner
  • Crime
    • murder
    • attempt to murder
    • evidence
    • confess
    • arrest
    • handcuffs
  • Looks and feelings
    • gaunt
    • flushed
    • listless
    • horrified
    • trembling
Group new words by topic to remember them.
Our own sentences in the style of the story.
Direct speechReported speech
Holmes said, "I am very ill."Holmes said that he was very ill.
Watson said, "I will bring a doctor."Watson said that he would bring a doctor.
Smith asked, "How is he?"Smith asked how he was.
Holmes told Watson, "Stand back!"Holmes ordered Watson to stand back.
Smith asked, "Did a box come by post?"Smith asked whether a box had come by post.

Command: told/ordered + to. Yes/no question: asked + if/whether. Wh-question: asked + wh-word, in statement order.

— Reported speech rule

Key takeaways: Learn the glossary words with your own example for each. Group words by topic. When reporting speech, change pronouns, step the tense back, and choose the reporting verb by the kind of sentence.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Answering questions on The Dying Detective

Writing a short answer

  1. Find Locate the part of the story the question is about.
  2. Answer Give a direct answer in the first sentence.
  3. Support Add a reason or a detail from the story, in your own words.
Use the same three steps for every comprehension question.
Points for and against, ready for a discussion.
For keeping the secretAgainst keeping the secret
Watson's true worry convinced Smith.Watson and Mrs Hudson suffered real fear and grief.
A doctor's examination would have exposed the act.Holmes insulted Watson's skill as a doctor.
It caught a murderer who might have killed again.Friends usually trust each other with the truth.

Direct answer first, then the proof from the story.

— Answer-writing tip

Key takeaways: Find the part of the story, answer directly, then support with a detail in your own words. For 'how do you know' questions, the detail is the proof. In a discussion, give your view, your reasons and one point from the other side.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery