- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Caste and politics
Explain how caste influences Indian politics and how politics and the Constitution have in turn changed the caste system, as the PSEB textbook describes both sides.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the caste system and the reformers who worked to end untouchability.
- Compare the views of Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. B.R. Ambedkar as the textbook presents them.
- List the ways caste influences politics, including the Mandal Commission episode.
- Explain how the political system has changed caste, including Article 17 and the creamy layer.
The textbook calls caste the fundamental basis of social classification in India. Its relationship with politics runs both ways: caste affects politics, and politics affects caste. The textbook says this relationship has a negative and a positive side. This lesson looks at both, in the order the book uses.
The caste system and the reformers
The textbook describes the varna system as treating certain caste groups as separate and inferior. History shows that some castes were treated so badly that they were called untouchables. Social reformers such as Mahatma Jyotiba Phule, Mahatma Gandhi, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, Periyar E.V. Ramasamy and Kanshi Ram worked to remove this evil and to build a caste-free social order.
Two views on untouchability, as the textbook presents them
-
Mahatma Gandhi
- Called the untouchables 'Harijans'
- Saw caste as part of the tradition but wanted its defects removed
- Stressed respect for all labour
-
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
- Used the terms Dalits / Scheduled Castes
- Wanted religion based on principles rather than traditions
- Aimed at ending the caste system itself
- Urged Dalits to shed any sense of inferiority and test old beliefs by reason
Because of these efforts and social and economic change, caste has changed a great deal. The textbook lists economic growth, urbanisation, the end of the zamindari (landlord) system, the spread of education and literacy, and the freedom to choose one's occupation. In cities, nobody asks the caste of the person sitting next to them on a bus or at a hotel table. The Constitution prohibits caste discrimination.
Yet caste has not disappeared. Most people still marry within their own caste or tribe, untouchability has not been fully eradicated, and groups that had access to education for centuries are still ahead in modern education. The textbook notes that caste and economic level remain closely linked.
How caste influences politics
- Parties: the textbook says that although the Constitution's spirit is against caste-based parties, some parties draw their support mainly from particular castes.
- Choice of candidates: parties often field a candidate from the caste that has the most voters in a constituency.
- Voting behaviour: many voters prefer a candidate of their own caste, paying little attention to the candidate's ability or record.
- Cabinet making: the Prime Minister and Chief Ministers are legally free to choose ministers, but in practice they include representatives of different castes.
- Reservation of seats: seats are reserved for SC and ST in Parliament, State Legislatures and local bodies. The framers saw this as necessary to raise their standard of living; it is often called positive discrimination.
- Reaction to reservation: some people outside these groups resent it, and agitations sometimes follow.
- Caste-based pressure groups: for example, unions of Scheduled Caste employees at central and state level, and rival unions of others.
The Mandal Commission
The Mandal Commission was set up by the Central Government in January 1979, during the term of Prime Minister Morarji Desai, under the chairmanship of B.P. (Bindeshwari Prasad) Mandal. It was asked to identify socially and educationally backward classes. It submitted its report on 30 December 1980, and its key recommendation was a 27% reservation for Backward Classes. When the government of Prime Minister V.P. Singh decided to implement it in August 1990, there were widespread protests. According to the textbook, the episode also built solidarity among Backward Classes and helped regional parties grow, especially in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar.
How politics has changed caste
- Untouchability abolished: Article 17 of the Constitution abolishes untouchability, and practising it is a punishable offence. People who suffered it for centuries gained dignity and entered legislatures, services and public life in large numbers.
- Political equality: the principle of 'one person, one vote, one value' means no citizen can be denied political rights or government service because of caste.
- Greater participation: castes once pushed aside realised that no party can win power without their support, and their political participation rose.
- The creamy layer: the benefits of special provisions did not reach everyone in these groups equally. Those who gained most and became well established are called the creamy layer.
Caste influences politics, but politics has also loosened the hold of caste: Article 17 abolished untouchability, and 'one person, one vote, one value' made every citizen politically equal.
Worked example 1: which side of the relationship?
Question: Sort these into 'caste affects politics' or 'politics affects caste': (a) a party picks a candidate from the largest caste in a constituency; (b) a person from a community once treated as untouchable becomes a minister thanks to reserved seats and equal rights. Reasoning: In (a) caste shapes a political decision. In (b) a political and legal arrangement changes the social position of a caste. Answer: (a) caste affects politics; (b) politics affects caste.
Worked example 2: understanding the creamy layer
Question: In a made-up village, two families belong to the same backward class. One has a parent who became a senior officer through a reserved post; the other still works as landless labourers. Which family is closer to the 'creamy layer', and why does the idea matter? Reasoning: The creamy layer means members of a group who have already gained from special provisions and are well established. Answer: The officer's family. The idea matters because benefits should reach those in the group who still need them most.
Key takeaways: Reformers from Phule to Ambedkar fought untouchability, and social change has weakened caste, though it has not vanished. Caste affects parties, candidates, voting, cabinets and pressure groups; reservations and the Mandal Commission (1979, report 1980, 27% recommendation) show how central it is. In turn, Article 17, political equality and greater participation have changed the caste system itself.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article of the Constitution abolishes untouchability?
- Article 14
- Article 17
- Article 21
- Article 32
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 17 abolishes untouchability and makes its practice an offence. Article 14 is equality before law, 21 is life and liberty, 32 is the right to constitutional remedies.
-
2. Who chaired the commission that recommended 27% reservation for Backward Classes?
- B.P. Mandal
- Justice R.S. Sarkaria
- Balwant Rai Mehta
- Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
Show answer
Answer: A. The Mandal Commission, set up in January 1979, was chaired by B.P. Mandal. Sarkaria headed the Centre-State relations commission and Balwant Rai Mehta the 1957 committee on local government.
-
3. Reserving seats for SC and ST in legislatures to raise their standard of living is often called:
- the creamy layer
- divide and rule
- positive discrimination
- separation of powers
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says the reservation of seats for these groups is often termed positive discrimination: unequal treatment meant to create real equality.
-
4. Which statement is an example of caste affecting politics rather than politics affecting caste?
- Untouchability is made a legal offence
- Every vote is given equal value
- Lower castes enter government service through reserved posts
- Voters choose a candidate mainly because he belongs to their caste
Show answer
Answer: D. Caste-based voting is caste shaping a political act. The other three are political and legal measures changing the position of castes.
-
5. According to the textbook, what was Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's ultimate goal?
- To rename the castes
- To eradicate the caste system
- To keep caste but remove its defects
- To form a caste-based party
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says eradication of the caste system was Ambedkar's ultimate goal. Keeping caste while removing its defects is how the textbook describes Gandhi's view.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.