• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Democracy and social divisions

Explain why a democracy must give a voice to every social group, and use the textbook's examples of Northern Ireland and Yugoslavia to show how social divisions can turn into political divisions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Say what the chapter means by democracy and why it is needed in a diverse society.
  • Explain how India's Constitution gives representation to different sections of society.
  • Describe how a social division becomes a political division.
  • Compare how conflict ended in Northern Ireland and in Yugoslavia.

Look around your classroom. Students speak different home languages, follow different faiths, come from villages and cities, and from families with very different incomes. A country is the same classroom on a huge scale. The PSEB textbook opens Civics with a simple question: how can people who differ in so many ways live together as equal citizens? Its answer is democracy, a system in which a government elected by the people works for the people.

Differences in society and the purpose of democracy

The textbook points out that, since ancient times, people in the Indian subcontinent have been identified by language, religion, colour, economic condition and similar markers. Practices such as caste division, communalism and widespread poverty go against the idea of human equality. A democratically elected set-up tries to use the political and legal system to reduce these social and economic gaps.

Several institutions take part in this effort: political parties, pressure groups, and socio-religious and economic organisations. In a democracy no single party or organisation owns power. Power rests on participation and is shared by different groups. Parties compete and sometimes clash, but the textbook stresses that these are conflicts of interest, which must never become personal enmity.

Representation of every section

A democracy does not pretend that social differences do not exist, and it does not try to wipe them out. Instead it shares political power in a way that takes these differences into account. That is why the framers of India's Constitution made reservations at various levels of government for Scheduled Castes (SC), Scheduled Tribes (ST), women and Backward Classes, keeping in mind their social and educational needs.

India has diversity of language, region, caste, gender, religion and economic status. To weave these into one thread of unity, every section needs a fair share in decision-making, so that decisions reflect the agreement of all. This is the idea of unity in diversity: differences remain, but they strengthen democracy instead of breaking it.

In a democracy, social divisions are not ignored or erased; political power is shared so that every group has a voice.

When social division turns into political division

Every society, big or small, is a mix of groups, and each group tries to influence politics. The danger comes when parties build their politics only on an existing social division. Then the social division becomes a political division. The textbook gives two examples from Europe.

Example 1: Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom. According to the textbook, about 53% of its people are Protestant and 47% Roman Catholic, two branches of Christianity. Nationalist parties, which represent most Catholics, wanted Northern Ireland to join the Republic of Ireland, a mainly Catholic country. Unionist parties, representing most Protestants, wanted it to stay with Britain. The conflict between them cost many civilian lives.

In 1998 the British government and the Nationalists signed the Good Friday Agreement. Both sides agreed to stop violence, a Northern Ireland Assembly was set up with powers to make policy on devolved subjects, and friendly ties with the Republic of Ireland were encouraged. The problem was settled through dialogue and discussion.

Example 2: Yugoslavia and Kosovo

Yugoslavia was a multi-ethnic country in which politics came to be organised along ethnic lines, and the country broke into several parts. In 1998-99 fighting broke out in the Kosovo region between ethnic Albanians and ethnic Serbs. A peace agreement was reached in 1999 with the help of NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation), and Kosovo was placed under United Nations administration. Tension continued, and in 2008 Kosovo declared its independence.

Two ways a divided society ended up

  • Northern Ireland
    • Two main groups: Catholics and Protestants
    • Good Friday Agreement, 1998
    • Violence stopped; an elected Assembly shares power
    • Country stayed together
  • Yugoslavia
    • Many ethnic groups
    • Politics organised on ethnic lines
    • Kosovo conflict 1998-99; NATO-backed peace in 1999
    • Country broke into several new states
Based on the textbook's comparison of the two cases.

Why the different results? The textbook explains that Northern Ireland had essentially two groups, which made a settlement by dialogue possible, while violence among many groups in Yugoslavia did not die down. The lesson it draws: regional and ethnic differences should be handled by respecting each group's uniqueness, not by crushing them with force.

Worked example 1: is a social difference always dangerous?

Question: A student says, 'A country with many languages and religions can never be a stable democracy.' Is this right? Reasoning: Step 1 - the textbook says that in a democracy it is natural for parties to make promises to different sections and to give them representation. Step 2 - when groups get a fair share and common policies, they feel a sense of belonging, which makes a nation strong. Step 3 - danger arises only when one division is used to set groups against each other. Answer: No. Diversity becomes dangerous only when politics is built on hostility between groups; shared power turns diversity into strength.

Worked example 2: reading the Northern Ireland case

Question: Which group wanted Northern Ireland to stay with Britain, and why? Reasoning: Britain is a mainly Protestant country; the Unionist parties represented the Protestants of Northern Ireland. Answer: The Unionists (mostly Protestants), because they identified with Protestant-majority Britain. The Nationalists (mostly Catholics) wanted union with the Catholic-majority Republic of Ireland.

Key takeaways: Democracy shares power among groups instead of ignoring their differences. India reserves seats for SC, ST, women and Backward Classes to give them a voice. A social division turns political when parties exploit it. Northern Ireland solved its conflict by dialogue in the 1998 Good Friday Agreement; Yugoslavia, with many groups and ethnic politics, broke apart, and Kosovo declared independence in 2008.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, what does a democracy do with social divisions?

    1. It removes them by law
    2. It ignores them completely
    3. It shares political power keeping them in mind
    4. It allows only the majority group to rule
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says social divisions are neither ignored nor eliminated; political power is distributed keeping social differences in mind, for example through reservations.

  2. 2. For which groups has India made reservations at various levels of government, as the chapter lists them?

    1. Only for Scheduled Castes
    2. Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, women and Backward Classes
    3. Only for religious minorities
    4. Only for people living in villages
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter names SC, ST, women and Backward Classes, keeping in mind their social and educational needs.

  3. 3. What did the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 achieve?

    1. It ended violence in Northern Ireland and set up an elected Assembly
    2. It made Northern Ireland part of the Republic of Ireland
    3. It divided Yugoslavia into new states
    4. It made Kosovo independent
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both groups agreed to stop violence and a Northern Ireland Assembly was created. Northern Ireland remained in the UK. Kosovo's declaration of independence came in 2008 and had nothing to do with this agreement.

  4. 4. Between which two groups was the conflict in Kosovo in 1998-99?

    1. Protestants and Catholics
    2. Dutch and French speakers
    3. Sinhalese and Tamils
    4. Ethnic Albanians and ethnic Serbs
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Kosovo conflict was between ethnic Albanians and ethnic Serbs. Protestants and Catholics belong to the Northern Ireland example.

  5. 5. Why, according to the textbook, did dialogue succeed in Northern Ireland but not in Yugoslavia?

    1. Northern Ireland had no political parties
    2. Northern Ireland had mainly two groups, Yugoslavia had many
    3. Yugoslavia had no army
    4. NATO refused to help Yugoslavia
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook explains that the presence of only two groups in Northern Ireland made a negotiated settlement possible, while violence among multiple groups in Yugoslavia did not subside.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery