- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Religion, communalism and secular politics
Distinguish religious diversity from communalism, describe the forms communalism takes in politics as the textbook lists them, and explain how India's secular Constitution responds.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give the textbook's historical examples of rulers who respected all faiths.
- Explain what communal politics assumes and why that assumption is wrong.
- List the forms communalism takes in politics.
- Explain the secular provisions of the Indian Constitution.
Almost every country has people of more than one religion. The PSEB textbook makes a careful distinction: religious difference in itself is not dangerous. The danger begins when the followers of one religion try to dominate others, or when religion is used to divide citizens politically. This is called communalism (the textbook also uses the word sectarianism).
A history of living together
The textbook reminds us that people of many faiths have lived in India since ancient times, and that several rulers respected all religions:
- Emperor Ashoka became a follower of Buddhism but gave full freedom to follow and spread other religions.
- Akbar, a Muslim, also allowed freedom of religion; the Din-i-Ilahi, which drew on ideas from many faiths, is cited as evidence of his liberal outlook.
- Maharaja Ranjit Singh, a Sikh ruler of Punjab, ruled a population in which, according to the textbook, only about 19-22% were Sikhs. People of different faiths, and even European officers, held high posts in his court and army, and the textbook notes that no communal incident of his reign is recorded as an adverse event.
The textbook then describes how British rule followed a policy of 'Divide and Rule'. It links this to the later Partition of the country, in which millions of people became homeless and many lost their lives to religious hatred.
The secular answer of the Constitution
After independence, the framers made India a secular state so that it would not face such problems again. The Constitution includes the Right to Freedom of Religion among the Fundamental Rights: people of every faith are free to profess, practise and propagate their religion. The state has no official religion and treats all religions equally.
Religious diversity is not the problem. Communalism begins when one religion is used to dominate others or to divide citizens politically.
What communal politics assumes
Communal politics rests on the idea that religion alone makes a social community: all followers of one religion have the same basic interests, and the interests of different religions are opposed. In its extreme form it claims that people of other faiths must live under the followers of the majority religion.
The textbook calls this assumption wrong. Every person plays many roles and has many identities; every community contains people with different opinions; and in a democracy all of them have the right to speak. Treating all members of a religion as if they think alike silences the variety of voices within that community.
Forms of communalism in politics
Forms communalism takes, as the textbook lists them
- Religion-based parties Appeal to one religion's voters; the textbook says they move away from the national mainstream
- Insecurity among minorities Attacks on places of worship can make minorities feel unsafe and alienated
- Religious intolerance Giving a religious colour even to small incidents
- Communalisation of politics Turning disputes into religious and political battles
- Religious pressure groups Rival demands that make government decisions hard
- Voting behaviour Voting for a candidate mainly because of shared religion
The textbook gives examples of where such politics has led, including the anti-Sikh violence of 1984, the demolition of the Babri Masjid structure in 1992, and attacks on Christians in several states in 1998-99. It also warns that conflict grows when the state favours one religion or tries to give it the status of a national religion.
| Religion | Share of population |
|---|---|
| Hindus | 79.8% |
| Muslims | 14.2% |
| Christians | 2.3% |
| Sikhs | 1.72% |
| Buddhists | 0.7% |
For Punjab, the textbook's 2011 figures give Sikhs 57.7% and Hindus 38.5% of the population, with smaller shares of Muslims and Christians.
Worked example 1: diversity or communalism?
Question: In a made-up town, two festivals of different faiths fall in the same week and both communities help each other with arrangements. In another town, a leader tells voters that people of another faith are a threat to them. Which situation shows communalism? Reasoning: The first is religious diversity with mutual respect, which the textbook says is not dangerous. The second uses religion to create fear and division for political gain. Answer: The second town.
Worked example 2: testing the communal assumption
Question: A pamphlet claims, 'All members of community X want the same thing.' Give two reasons from the lesson why this is wrong. Answer: (1) Each person has many identities - farmer, teacher, woman, Punjabi - and these shape interests too. (2) Every community contains different opinions, and democracy gives each person the right to express them.
Key takeaways: India has a long history of rulers who respected all faiths. Divide and Rule fed communal hatred that ended in Partition. The secular Constitution guarantees freedom of religion and gives the state no religion. Communal politics wrongly assumes a religion's followers share identical interests; it appears as religion-based parties, minority insecurity, intolerance, communalised politics, religious pressure groups and religion-based voting.
Check your understanding
-
1. Whose liberal religious policy is shown by the Din-i-Ilahi?
- Ashoka
- Aurangzeb
- Akbar
- Maharaja Ranjit Singh
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook cites Akbar's Din-i-Ilahi, drawing on many faiths, as evidence of his liberal outlook.
-
2. According to the textbook, what is the central (wrong) assumption of communal politics?
- All citizens are equal whatever their faith
- Religion alone forms a social community with identical interests
- The state must treat all religions equally
- People have many identities
Show answer
Answer: B. Communal politics assumes followers of one religion form one community with the same interests, opposed to others. The other options describe secular, democratic ideas.
-
3. What does it mean to say India is a secular state?
- The state has no official religion and treats all religions equally
- Only one religion is allowed
- Religion is banned in public
- Each state chooses an official religion
Show answer
Answer: A. Secularism in the Constitution means no state religion, equal treatment and freedom of religion as a Fundamental Right.
-
4. Which policy of British rule does the textbook link to the later Partition of India?
- Separation of powers
- Power sharing
- Federalism
- Divide and Rule
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the British followed a policy of Divide and Rule, which it connects to the division of the country and the suffering that followed.
-
5. Which of these is an example of communalism in voting behaviour?
- Voting for a candidate because of his work for the area
- Voting for a candidate mainly because he shares the voter's religion
- Not voting because of illness
- Voting after reading every party's programme
Show answer
Answer: B. Choosing a candidate mainly on the basis of shared religion is the communal voting pattern the textbook describes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.