• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Three factors that decide the politics of social divisions

Use the three aspects named in the textbook - sense of identity, how demands are raised, and how the government responds - to judge whether social divisions will strengthen or threaten a democracy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the three aspects on which politics in a divided society depends.
  • Use Sri Lanka, Yugoslavia and Belgium as examples of each aspect.
  • Explain why the textbook calls the expression of social divisions normal and even healthy.
  • State the condition under which struggle against injustice stays democratic.

Lesson 1 showed that the same kind of social difference can end in peace in one country and break-up in another. What makes the difference? The PSEB textbook gives three aspects, like three dials that together decide the outcome. Learning them lets you analyse almost any case of social conflict you read about.

The three aspects

What decides the outcome in a divided society

  1. 1. Sense of identity How strongly people see themselves as one group, apart from others
  2. 2. How demands are presented Whether leaders raise demands within the Constitution, without harming other groups
  3. 3. Government's response Whether the government shares power or suppresses demands
The three aspects listed in the textbook.

Aspect 1: a strong sense of identity

When people feel their group identity very strongly, they may start to think of themselves as superior or entirely different from others. Such people find it hard to live alongside others, and a powerful group may slip into the politics of repression. The textbook's remedy is to appreciate the uniqueness of others while each group keeps its own. A person can be proud of being Punjabi, for example, and equally proud of being Indian; multiple identities make accommodation easier.

Aspect 2: how leaders present the demands

The second aspect is how political parties and leaders frame a community's demands. Demands that fall within the Constitution and do not harm another community can be met easily. The textbook gives two contrasting cases:

  • Sri Lanka: a policy of giving privileges to Sinhalese people and denying Tamils their civil rights was seen as going against the identity and interests of the Tamil community.
  • Yugoslavia: leaders of different ethnic groups made demands for their own groups that could not be met within the borders of one country, so the country was divided.

Aspect 3: how the government responds

The third and often decisive aspect is the government's attitude. Belgium encouraged unity by sharing power among its Dutch-, French- and German-speaking communities, giving each rights in its own region. Sri Lanka, in contrast, followed a policy the textbook calls discriminatory towards the minority Tamils. If a government is ready to share power and honestly tries to meet the reasonable demands of a minority, social division is no threat. If it crushes legitimate demands in the name of national unity, the effort backfires: unity imposed by force often breeds separatist feelings.

The three aspects with the textbook's examples
AspectPeaceful directionDangerous direction
Sense of identityRespecting other groups while keeping one's own identityFeeling superior; politics of repression
Presentation of demandsDemands within the Constitution that harm no other groupDemands that cannot be met within one country (Yugoslavia)
Government's responseSharing power (Belgium)Suppressing or discriminating (Sri Lanka)

Social divisions can be healthy

The textbook concludes that social differences are not always dangerous. Their expression in a democracy is normal and natural, and can even be a sign of healthy politics. It is how small or neglected groups bring their problems to the government's attention. The way a democracy settles linguistic, ethnic and regional demands shows how mature it is.

Balancing all groups is not easy. Groups that feel deprived or marginalised may have to struggle hard against injustice, but the textbook insists the struggle must be constitutional: peaceful means, and pressure through elections. Where inequality is so harsh that it cannot be accepted, struggle may even appear to threaten unity, yet history shows democracy is the best way to identify such problems and balance differences.

Demands within the Constitution + a government willing to share power = social division that strengthens democracy.

Worked example 1: applying the three aspects

Question: Imagine a made-up country, 'Saranpur', where a minority speaks Language X. Its leaders ask for schools in Language X in their region. The government refuses and bans the language from offices. Use the three aspects to predict the result. Reasoning: Aspect 2 - the demand is within constitutional limits and harms no other group, so it could easily be met. Aspect 3 - the government chooses suppression instead of sharing. The textbook warns that forced unity creates separatist feelings. Answer: Tension is likely to grow, as in Sri Lanka; accepting the demand, as Belgium did, would have reduced conflict.

Worked example 2: healthy or harmful?

Question: Farmers of a district hold peaceful meetings and vote for candidates who promise better irrigation. Is this expression of a group interest harmful to democracy? Reasoning: The group uses peaceful, constitutional means and puts pressure through elections, which is exactly how the textbook says demands should be raised. Answer: It is healthy. It draws the government's attention to a neglected need.

Key takeaways: Politics in a divided society depends on (1) the strength of group identity, (2) how leaders present demands, and (3) how the government responds. Belgium's power sharing kept the country together; Sri Lanka's discrimination and Yugoslavia's impossible demands led to conflict. Expressing social divisions is normal in a democracy, provided the struggle stays peaceful and constitutional.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is NOT one of the three aspects the textbook lists for politics in a divided society?

    1. A strong sense of identity among people
    2. The way politicians present public demands
    3. The size of the country's army
    4. The government's attitude towards people's demands
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The three aspects are identity, presentation of demands, and the government's response. The army's size is not one of them.

  2. 2. Which country does the textbook give as an example of fostering unity by sharing power among language communities?

    1. Belgium
    2. Sri Lanka
    3. Yugoslavia
    4. Northern Ireland
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Belgium shared power among its Dutch, French and German speakers, giving them rights in their own regions.

  3. 3. According to the textbook, what often happens when a government tries to create unity by force?

    1. Social divisions disappear at once
    2. Separatist feelings and tendencies grow
    3. The minority gives up its demands
    4. The country becomes richer
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says attempts to impose unity through the use of force often create separatist sentiments, which is the opposite of what was intended.

  4. 4. Which type of demand does the textbook say can be accommodated easily?

    1. A demand that one group should rule over others
    2. A demand that requires breaking up the country
    3. A demand backed by violence
    4. A demand within the Constitution that does not harm another community
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Demands within the ambit of the Constitution that do not hurt other communities are easy to accommodate.

  5. 5. What, according to the textbook, shows the maturity of a democracy?

    1. Having only one language
    2. The way it resolves its linguistic, ethnic and regional demands
    3. Never allowing groups to raise demands
    4. Having no political parties
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says the method by which a democracy solves its specific linguistic, ethnic and regional demands showcases its maturity.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Caste and politics

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery