- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Challenges to democracy and suggestions for reform
Describe the challenges democracies face, the threats to Indian democracy ranked in the textbook, and the suggestions it gives for strengthening and reforming democracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the challenge of establishing democracy and the challenges faced by established democracies.
- List the threats to Indian democracy in the order the textbook ranks them.
- Explain why laws alone cannot reform democracy.
- List the textbook's suggestions for strengthening democracy and the seven pillars of democracy.
No democracy is perfect. The textbook treats challenges as opportunities: by overcoming them, a democracy reaches a higher level of maturity. It asks how democracy can be strengthened and what an ordinary citizen can do - questions with no final answers, but on which we can form our own views.
Where democracy is still to be established
After the Second World War, most countries freed from colonial rule chose democracy, but many are still far from true representative government. According to the textbook, by 2000 nearly a fourth of the world's countries did not have democratic governments. For them the challenge is to end undemocratic rule, reduce military control over government and set up sovereign governments that truly represent the people.
Challenges of established democracies
- Winning everyone's confidence: the textbook notes that some groups and regions in several countries, including India and neighbouring countries such as Nepal, have not fully accepted the democratic system.
- Power to local and state governments: many countries have not given real powers to their units, so the centre interferes often. The textbook notes that in India, up to 1967, the Centre interfered with state governments run by opposition parties.
- Including women and minorities: many democracies have not fully brought them into the democratic process.
- Decentralisation: economic and political decentralisation is still incomplete in India and many democracies.
- Strengthening the roots: institutions such as the Lok Sabha, Vidhan Sabhas, Gram Panchayats, Panchayat Samitis, Zila Parishads and Municipal Corporations must be under people's control, which needs less influence of the rich and powerful on decisions.
The textbook also asks students, with their teacher, to study examples from many countries - such as a military ruler in Chile refusing to give up power after losing a vote, or Poland's government banning the Solidarity trade union after its strike - and to classify the challenge each shows: constitutional crisis, democratic rights, working of institutions, decentralisation of power, free and fair elections, unity in diversity, or corruption.
Threats to Indian democracy, as ranked in the textbook
- Communalism
- Corruption
- Poverty
- Casteism
- Population explosion
- Violence
- Illiteracy
The textbook places communalism first because of the scale of harm it causes. As examples it gives the large-scale violence during the partition of Punjab and Bengal in 1947, riots at Muzaffarpur, and the killings of Sikhs in Delhi in 1984, which the textbook describes as the 1984 Delhi massacre and the Sikh genocide. Its reasons: such violence breaks social brotherhood, costs lives and property, weakens the roots of democracy, and needs great economic, social and political effort to rehabilitate victims and restore harmony.
Reforms: why laws alone are not enough
Because of corruption and other problems, some people argue for a more authoritarian system, pointing to the cost of frequent elections and the role of money in politics. The textbook rejects this: the answer is to remove the faults within democracy, not to abandon it. Parties should value merit over money, policies should serve everyone, and the federal structure should be strengthened.
India already has many laws, including anti-corruption laws such as the Lokpal Act. The real issue, says the textbook, is honest enforcement. Some laws, though well meant, cause new problems: it mentions laws in certain states that bar people with more than two children from contesting some elections, which could shut out many people and cause resentment. Its conclusion: without a change in citizens' mindset, democracy cannot overcome its challenges; its improvement lies in the people's hands.
| Suggestion | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| Ethical leadership | Leaders and citizens of high moral standing resist corruption |
| Educated citizens | Education helps people understand problems and decide wisely |
| Political freedom | Freedom of speech, association and assembly allows criticism of policies |
| Economic equity | Basic needs met for all prevents unrest |
| Social justice | No discrimination by caste, race, colour or religion |
| Civic awareness | Citizens know their rights and do their duties |
| Decentralisation | Power shared with people makes democracy stronger |
| Principled parties | Parties based on ideas, not religion or caste |
| Competent leadership | Capable, selfless leaders guide reform |
| Independent judiciary | Fearless, impartial courts give fair decisions |
Seven pillars of democracy
- Legitimacy Power to govern given by the people
- Separation of powers
- Popular participation
- Checks and balances
- Periodic elections
- Rule of law
- Fundamental human rights
Finally, the textbook says democracy keeps evolving, so its definition may need updating. It recalls key features - leaders chosen by the people, the chance to change them through elections, equality, freedom to criticise and dissent, tolerance of different ideas, peaceful solutions and the welfare of all - and asks each student to write their own definition of a good democracy in about 50 words.
Worked example: match the problem to the suggestion
Question: A village has many voters who cannot read the names on notices about a new scheme and so miss its benefits. Which suggestion addresses this most directly? Reasoning: the problem is that people cannot understand information about public affairs; the textbook says education helps citizens understand political, economic and social problems. Answer: 'educated citizens'.
Key takeaways: Nearly a fourth of countries lacked democracy by 2000, according to the textbook. Established democracies struggle with confidence of all groups, real power for local units, inclusion of women and minorities, and strong institutions. The textbook ranks communalism as the gravest threat to Indian democracy, followed by corruption, poverty, casteism, population explosion, violence and illiteracy. Laws help only when honestly enforced; real reform needs aware, educated, ethical citizens and leaders.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, roughly what share of the world's countries did not have democratic governments by 2000?
- Half
- About a fourth
- Three-fourths
- None
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says that by 2000 democratic governments had not been established in nearly a fourth of the world's countries.
-
2. Which threat does the textbook rank first among the challenges to Indian democracy?
- Communalism
- Illiteracy
- Population explosion
- Violence
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook's ranking is communalism, corruption, poverty, casteism, population explosion, violence and illiteracy.
-
3. What does the textbook see as the critical issue about anti-corruption laws such as the Lokpal Act?
- India has too few laws
- Laws should target particular groups
- Their honest enforcement
- They should be abolished
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says India has plenty of laws; the critical issue is that honest people enforce them, and that laws serve society as a whole.
-
4. Which suggestion in the textbook says parties should be based on ideas rather than religion or caste?
- Decentralisation
- Economic equity
- Independent judiciary
- Principled political parties
Show answer
Answer: D. 'Principled political parties' says parties rooted in ideology promote healthy politics, while parties based on religion or caste can weaken democracy.
-
5. Which of these is NOT one of the seven pillars of democracy shown in the textbook?
- Rule of law
- Rule by a single leader for life
- Periodic elections
- Checks and balances
Show answer
Answer: B. The seven pillars are legitimacy, separation of powers, popular participation, checks and balances, periodic elections, rule of law and fundamental human rights. Rule by one leader for life is the opposite of democracy.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.