• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Dignity, freedom and the growing expectations from democracy

Explain how democracy is expected to protect dignity and freedom, describe its record on women and caste as the textbook does, and explain why criticism of democracy is itself a sign of its success.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why dignity and freedom are central to democracy.
  • Describe what the textbook says about the dignity of women and of discriminated castes.
  • Explain why the evaluation of democracy is never complete.
  • Explain why the textbook calls criticism of democracy a sign of its success.

Money and growth are not everything. People also want to be treated with respect, to be free, and to feel safe. The fourth outcome the textbook expects from democracy is that it will ensure the dignity, freedom and security of individuals better than any other form of government.

Outcome 4: dignity, freedom and security

Respect and freedom are basic pillars of democracy, because everyone wishes to be treated with dignity. The textbook notes that many conflicts begin when people feel they are not given the respect they deserve. All democracies accept these ideas, at least in principle, but how far they are practised differs from country to country.

In societies that lived for a long time under subjugation and feudal ways, equality and respect for all come slowly. It takes time for a society to become democratic in practice, not just in law.

Dignity of women

The textbook points out that most societies in history were dominated by men. After long and hard struggles by women, the world has come to accept that women deserve equal status with men. Many democracies have given women equal rights, while, the textbook says, non-democratic countries often do not treat women as legally and morally equal to men.

Dignity of discriminated castes

The same gap appears with caste inequality. In India, says the textbook, democracy has played a big role in restoring the dignity of castes that were deprived and discriminated against, and has given them chances to develop. However, caste-based inequality and ill-treatment still occur. The textbook links this mainly to weak implementation of laws and gaps in society's moral and legal protection. Despite this, Indian democracy has done much to help citizens understand and use their rights.

Dignity under democracy: progress and gaps

  • Progress
    • Equal status of women accepted in law
    • Dignity of discriminated castes restored to a large extent
    • More chances to develop
    • Citizens more aware of their rights
  • Gaps that remain
    • Caste-based inequality still occurs
    • Laws not always implemented well
    • Social attitudes change slowly
    • Equality in practice takes time
As described in the PSEB textbook

Democracy promises dignity in law; making it real in daily life is a slow process that depends on laws being enforced and attitudes changing.

Expectations that keep growing

Democracy differs from other systems in one more way: its evaluation is never complete. Each time it meets one set of expectations, people raise new ones. As people enjoy its benefits, they want still more improvement.

The cycle of democratic expectations

  1. People expect something For example, a school in every village
  2. Democracy delivers part of it
  3. People enjoy the benefit
  4. New, higher expectations arise For example, better teachers in those schools

Then back to step 1: People expect something

This is why, when asked how democracy is doing, people often point out its weaknesses. The textbook makes an important point: criticising the flaws of democracy is itself a sign of its success. It shows people have become more aware and are able to examine the work of their elected representatives. This growing awareness strengthens their faith in democracy. Under a dictatorship, such open complaints would often not be allowed.

Worked example 1: what does a complaint tell us?

Situation (made up): In a village meeting, Simran says the new health centre has no doctor on Sundays. Reasoning: Step 1 - a few years ago the village had no health centre at all; that expectation was met. Step 2 - now a higher expectation (a doctor every day) has arisen. Step 3 - Simran can say this openly and ask her representative to act. Conclusion: the complaint is a sign that people are aware and free to criticise - a mark of a working democracy, not of its failure.

Worked example 2: law and practice

Question: The Constitution forbids discrimination by caste, yet a newspaper reports a case of caste-based ill-treatment. Does this mean democracy has done nothing for dignity? Reasoning: Step 1 - the textbook says democracy has largely restored the dignity of discriminated castes and given them opportunities. Step 2 - it also says such cases still happen because laws are not always enforced and protection has gaps. Answer: No. It shows progress is real but incomplete; the remedy is better enforcement and awareness.

Key takeaways: Democracy is expected to ensure dignity, freedom and security. Women's equal status is widely accepted in democracies, and Indian democracy has done much for discriminated castes, though inequality persists where laws are weakly enforced. Expectations from democracy keep rising, and open criticism shows citizens are aware - a sign of democracy's success.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, why does equality and respect for all take time in some societies?

    1. They lived for long under subjugation and feudal ways
    2. They have no laws at all
    3. They have too many elections
    4. They have no women citizens
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says societies long marked by subjugation and feudalism take time to practise equality and respect, even after democracy arrives.

  2. 2. What does the textbook mainly link continuing caste-based inequality to?

    1. The right to vote
    2. Too much education
    3. Weak implementation of laws and gaps in protection
    4. The absence of a constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says such inequalities persist mainly because laws are not well implemented and society's moral and legal protection has gaps. India does have a constitution that forbids discrimination.

  3. 3. Why is the evaluation of democracy 'never complete'?

    1. Elections are never held
    2. Each time some expectations are met, new ones arise
    3. Democracy has no aims
    4. People stop caring about it
    Show answer

    Answer: B. As people enjoy the benefits of democracy they expect more, so evaluation keeps going in a continuous cycle.

  4. 4. The textbook calls criticism of democracy's flaws a sign of its success because it shows that:

    1. democracy has failed completely
    2. people want a dictatorship
    3. the government has banned complaints
    4. citizens are aware and able to examine their representatives
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Criticism shows growing awareness and the ability to scrutinise elected representatives, which strengthens faith in democracy.

  5. 5. According to the textbook, how do non-democratic countries often treat women compared with democracies?

    1. They often do not recognise women as legally and morally equal to men
    2. They always give women more rights
    3. They treat everyone exactly equally
    4. They abolished all differences long ago
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says many democracies have granted women equal rights, while non-democratic countries often fail to recognise women as equal to men in law and morality.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Indian democracy: achievements

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery