• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Economic growth, inequality and poverty under democracy

Compare the economic record of democracies and dictatorships as the textbook presents it, explain why growth depends on many factors, and discuss why democracy has struggled to reduce inequality and poverty.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe what the textbook says about growth under democratic and authoritarian governments.
  • List the factors besides the form of government that shape a country's economic development.
  • Explain the difference between political equality and economic equality.
  • Explain why the textbook says democracy has largely not reduced economic inequality.

If democracy gives good government, we may expect it to bring development too. People also hope it will narrow the gap between rich and poor. This lesson looks at the textbook's second and third expected outcomes: economic growth and development, and reduction of economic inequality and poverty. Here the textbook is frank that the record is mixed.

Outcome 2: economic growth and development

According to the textbook, when the performance of democratic and authoritarian governments between 1950 and 2000 is compared, authoritarian regimes show slightly higher rates of economic growth. This is a cause for concern, but the textbook argues that democracy cannot be rejected on this ground alone.

A country's economic development depends on many factors, not only on its form of government:

What shapes a country's economic development

  • Population size
  • Geographical location
  • International support
  • Government efforts to improve the economy
  • Physical and mental quality of citizens Health, education and skills of the people
Factors named in the PSEB textbook

The textbook adds that among less developed countries there is no big difference in growth rates whether they are ruled by dictators or by democracies. So democracy does not guarantee growth, but it is reasonable to expect that it will not fall behind dictatorship.

There is a further reason to prefer democracy economically. A working democracy gives fair representation to citizens of every region. This should help spread resources fairly and stop national income from going mostly to the rich.

Democracy does not guarantee faster growth, but there is no good reason to expect it to fall behind dictatorship - and it offers fairer representation to all.

Outcome 3: reducing inequality and poverty

Growth alone is not enough; the question is who benefits. Does everyone's standard of living rise? Or does growth widen the gap? Liberal democracy is built on political equality: each adult has one vote of equal value. But the textbook points out that political equality without economic equality often has little meaning for a poor person, and that democracies have largely failed to reduce economic inequality.

Political equality and economic equality
AspectPolitical equalityEconomic equality
MeaningEqual right to vote and to stand for electionA fair share of income, wealth and opportunities
Under democracyLargely achievedLargely not achieved, says the textbook
ExampleA labourer's vote counts the same as a factory owner'sBoth can afford food, clothing, shelter, education and health care

The textbook gives an example of inequality in democracies: in countries like South Africa and Brazil, it says, the richest 20 per cent of people get about 60 per cent of the national income, while the poorest 20 per cent get only about 3 per cent. The poorer sections often struggle for basic needs: food, clothing, shelter, education and health care.

The textbook also notes that in India, as in many countries, a large part of the electorate is poor. Political parties do not want to lose these voters, yet, it says, they are seen as lacking the will to fight poverty as strongly as people expect. It observes that the same situation is found in several other countries.

Worked example 1: reading an income share

Question: Using the textbook's figures, how many times larger is the income share of the richest 20 per cent than that of the poorest 20 per cent? Working: richest share = 60 per cent; poorest share = 3 per cent. 60 / 3 = 20. Answer: the richest fifth gets about 20 times the share of the poorest fifth - a clear sign of economic inequality even under democracy.

Worked example 2: does slower growth mean democracy is worse?

Question: Ravi says, 'Dictatorships grew slightly faster from 1950 to 2000, so dictatorship is better.' How should you reply? Reasoning: Step 1 - the difference is slight. Step 2 - growth depends on many factors (population, location, foreign support, government policy, people's health and education), not only the form of government. Step 3 - among poor countries the gap almost disappears. Step 4 - democracy offers fairer representation and dignity, which growth figures do not measure. Conclusion: the growth figure alone does not prove dictatorship is better.

Key takeaways: According to the textbook, authoritarian regimes grew slightly faster between 1950 and 2000, but growth depends on many factors and democracy need not lag behind. Democracy gives political equality, but economic equality has largely not followed; a small rich group holds a big share of income. Reducing poverty remains one of democracy's biggest unfinished tasks.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, which governments showed slightly higher economic growth between 1950 and 2000?

    1. Democratic governments
    2. Monarchies only
    3. Authoritarian (dictatorial) governments
    4. No government grew at all
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says authoritarian regimes showed slightly higher growth rates than democracies over 1950-2000, though the difference was small.

  2. 2. Which of these is NOT named by the textbook as a factor in a country's economic development?

    1. The number of political parties
    2. Population size
    3. Geographical location
    4. International support
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook lists population size, geographical location, international support, government efforts and the quality of citizens. The number of parties is not in its list.

  3. 3. Political equality in a democracy mainly means:

    1. everyone earns the same income
    2. everyone owns equal land
    3. everyone has the same job
    4. every adult has an equal right to vote and elect representatives
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Liberal democracy rests on political equality - each person has an equal right to choose representatives. Equal income or property would be economic equality, which democracy has largely not achieved.

  4. 4. The textbook's example says the richest 20% in some democracies get 60% of income and the poorest 20% get 3%. What does this show?

    1. Democracy has removed poverty
    2. Economic inequality can remain high in a democracy
    3. The poor have more income than the rich
    4. Income is shared equally
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A 60% share against a 3% share (20 times larger) shows that political equality has not brought economic equality.

  5. 5. Why does the textbook still think democracy is economically worth preferring?

    1. It always grows fastest
    2. It abolishes private property
    3. It gives fair representation to citizens of every region, which helps fairer distribution
    4. It needs no economic planning
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook argues that because democracy represents all citizens and regions fairly, it can spread resources more fairly and stop income going mostly to the rich.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery