• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

What we expect from democracy: an accountable and legitimate government

Explain why the results of democracy must be judged, list the yardsticks used to judge it, and show why a slower but accountable, transparent government is still preferred.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the questions this chapter of the PSEB textbook asks about democracy.
  • List the yardsticks on which democracy is usually judged better than other forms of government.
  • Explain why democracy is a form of government that creates conditions, which citizens must use.
  • Explain accountability, responsiveness, transparency and legitimacy, and why slow decisions are not wasted time.

In earlier classes you learnt what democracy is and how it works. This chapter of the PSEB textbook (Civics, Chapter 4) asks a practical question: what does democracy actually deliver? Has it given people a responsive government, economic growth, less poverty, and dignity and freedom? And what helps democracy succeed in India? Judging results is important, because a system that only sounds good on paper but fails in practice would lose people's trust.

Why democracy is rated above other systems

Over history, democracy has been praised as better than dictatorship, monarchy or rule by religious authority. The textbook gives the yardsticks behind this praise:

  • Equal rights: every citizen has the same rights, whoever they are.
  • Dignity of the individual: it builds self-respect and a sense of being in control of one's life.
  • Better decisions: decisions are made after wider discussion and include more people.
  • Peaceful handling of conflict: it gives an orderly way to settle disagreements.
  • Room to correct mistakes: wrong decisions can be challenged and changed, and grievances heard.

The textbook also notes that some critics say democracy in India looks fine in theory but falls short in practice. That is why we need to look at its real outcomes. According to the textbook, more than 100 countries today have democratic governments, each with a constitution, political parties, regular elections and guaranteed rights. Yet their social, economic and cultural conditions differ, so results differ too.

Democracy is a form of government. It can only create conditions for achieving goals; citizens must take those opportunities for its aims to be realised.

Outcome 1: accountable, responsible and constitutional government

In a democracy citizens choose their leaders, and those leaders must answer to the people. Wherever possible, people should also take part in decisions. The basic purpose is a government that responds to people's needs and expectations.

Some say democracy is less efficient than dictatorship or monarchy because a ruler who need not consult anyone can decide quickly. Democracy relies on discussion and negotiation, which takes time. But speed is not the only test. A quick decision that people do not accept can create long-term problems. A democratic decision follows a set procedure, so it is usually more acceptable and more effective. The time spent is therefore not wasted.

Quick decision versus democratic decision

  • Non-democratic ruler
    • Decides fast
    • No need to consult people
    • Decision may be unpopular
    • Problems can last long
    • Process is hidden
  • Democratic government
    • Takes time to discuss
    • Follows rules and procedure
    • Decision more widely accepted
    • More effective in the long run
    • Citizens can examine the process

Transparency and the tools of accountability

Every citizen has the right to examine how decisions are made. This openness, called transparency, is largely missing in non-democratic regimes. To keep a government accountable, the textbook says democracy needs: regular, free and fair elections; open public debate on major issues; and the right to information so citizens can know what the government is doing. Democracies have done well on elections and debate, but some have been weak in sharing information. Even so, they generally do better than non-democratic governments here.

We also expect a democratic government to attend to people's needs and to be free of corruption. The textbook admits that this expectation is often not met: needs are neglected and corruption continues. But non-democratic governments are just as open to corruption. What marks a democracy is that wrongdoing can be exposed, taken to court and answered for.

Legitimacy: the people's own government

Democracy may at times be slow, less efficient or less transparent, yet it has one quality no other system has: it is elected by the people, so it is their own government. This is its legitimacy. The demand for democracy keeps growing, even in countries without it, because people want to be ruled by representatives they elect. The textbook calls this ability to win popular support itself a sign of democracy's success.

Worked example 1: is a slow decision a failure?

Situation (made up): A town council takes three months to decide where to build a new bus stand, holding public meetings first. A neighbouring area under a single appointed officer decides in a week. Reasoning: Step 1 - the council's decision took longer because it followed a procedure and heard people. Step 2 - because residents were consulted, they are more likely to accept and use the bus stand. Step 3 - the officer's fast decision may face protests or go unused. Conclusion: the delay is the cost of a more acceptable decision, not proof that democracy has failed.

Worked example 2: matching the tool to the goal

Question: A citizen wants to know how much was spent on repairing village roads. Which feature of democracy helps? Reasoning: elections let people change leaders; public debate lets them discuss issues; but to know facts about government action they need the right to information. Answer: the right to information, which supports transparency and accountability.

Key takeaways: Democracy is judged on equal rights, dignity, better decisions, peaceful conflict resolution and the chance to correct mistakes. It creates conditions; citizens must use them. Its decisions are slower but more acceptable. Elections, public debate and the right to information keep it accountable. Corruption exists under every system, but a democracy lets it be exposed. Its greatest strength is legitimacy: it is the people's own government.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, why is democracy often called slow?

    1. It is run by a single leader
    2. It depends on discussion and negotiation before deciding
    3. It decides everything by force
    4. It never takes any decision
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Democracy follows a procedure of deliberation and dialogue among many people, which takes time. A single leader is a feature of dictatorship, which can decide fast.

  2. 2. Which of these is NOT one of the yardsticks on which democracy is judged better than other systems?

    1. Equal rights for all citizens
    2. Peaceful resolution of conflicts
    3. A way to correct mistakes
    4. Guaranteed highest economic growth
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook lists equal rights, dignity, better decisions, peaceful conflict resolution and room to correct mistakes. It does not claim democracy guarantees the highest growth; the next lesson shows dictatorships have sometimes grown slightly faster.

  3. 3. Which right most directly lets citizens know what the government is doing?

    1. Right to information
    2. Right to vote
    3. Right to form associations
    4. Right to property
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook names the right to information as the way citizens learn about government actions, which supports transparency. Voting chooses leaders but does not reveal how decisions were made.

  4. 4. What does the 'legitimacy' of a democratic government mean?

    1. It always makes quick decisions
    2. It is free from all corruption
    3. It is the people's own government, elected by them
    4. It never needs public debate
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Legitimacy means the government's right to rule comes from the people who elect it. Democracies are not free from corruption, and they rely on debate, so the other options are wrong.

  5. 5. The textbook says democracy can only create conditions for achieving goals. What follows from this?

    1. Democracy needs no participation from citizens
    2. Citizens must use the opportunities it creates for its aims to be realised
    3. Democracy solves all social and economic problems by itself
    4. Only the government is responsible for results
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Because democracy is a form of government, its aims are realised only when citizens make use of the opportunities it gives. It is not a cure for all problems by itself.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery